The Challenge: Favorite/Fantasy Casts

The Gauntlet 4 (must have already done at least 4 challenges to be a Vet) [SIZE=4][B][FONT=Arial Black][COLOR="#FF0000"]Veterans [/COLOR][/FONT][/B][/SIZE] Bananas Leroy Brandon Wes Derrick Ryan (Fresh Meat) CT Paula Camila Theresa Jonna Laurel Katie Sarah [SIZE=4][FONT=Arial Black][B][COLOR="#0000FF"]Rookies[/COLOR][/B][/FONT][/SIZE] Frank Zach Dustin Johnny Reilly Cory Trey Jordan Nany Devyn Jessica Jenny (Explosion) Cooke Emily S KellyAnne What do you guys think?

[QUOTE=Bronze710;434279]The Gauntlet 4 (must have already done at least 4 challenges to be a Vet) [SIZE=4][B][FONT=Arial Black][COLOR="#FF0000"]Veterans [/COLOR][/FONT][/B][/SIZE] Bananas Leroy Brandon Wes Derrick Ryan (Fresh Meat) CT Paula Camila Theresa Jonna Laurel Katie Sarah [SIZE=4][FONT=Arial Black][B][COLOR="#0000FF"]Rookies[/COLOR][/B][/FONT][/SIZE] Frank Zach Dustin Johnny Reilly Cory Trey Jordan Nany Devyn Jessica Jenny (Explosion) Cooke Emily S KellyAnne What do you guys think?[/QUOTE] Love this cast! I would probably put Cara in for vets :)

[QUOTE=Demetri;434283]Love this cast! I would probably put Cara in for vets :)[/QUOTE] I was going to, but I didn't want to make the veteran girls too stacked without taking out people like Laurel (a Laurel vs. Emily S elimination would be awesome), Theresa or Paula. I feel like there aren't too many strong rookie girls.

[QUOTE=Bronze710;434285]I was going to, but I didn't want to make the veteran girls too stacked without taking out people like Laurel (a Laurel vs. Emily S elimination would be awesome), Theresa or Paula. I feel like there aren't too many strong rookie girls.[/QUOTE] Yes someone else who has been wishing for a Laurel and Emily elimination!

[QUOTE=Bronze710;434285]I was going to, but I didn't want to make the veteran girls too stacked without taking out people like Laurel (a Laurel vs. Emily S elimination would be awesome), Theresa or Paula. I feel like there aren't too many strong rookie girls.[/QUOTE] It would be amazing but it can't happen with a gauntlet..... at least not unless they are on the same team

[QUOTE=Challenge 17;434287]It would be amazing but it can't happen with a gauntlet..... at least not unless they are on the same team[/QUOTE] Depends what Gauntlet. The first Gauntlet was didn't see people go against their own team

[CENTER]The Challenge: Heroes vs. Villains [COLOR="#0000FF"]Heroes: Brian Williams Zach Nichols Johnny Bananas Robb Schreiber Brad Fiorenza Leroy Garrett Derrick Kosinski Arielle Scott Nany Gonzalez Emily Schromm Averey Tressler Jonna Mannion Sarah Rice KellyAnne Judd[/COLOR] [COLOR="#FF0000"]Villains: Wes Bergmann Cory Wharton Frank Sweeney Jordan Wiseley CT Tamburello Trey Weatherholtz Adam Royer Nia Moore Laurel Stucky Marie Roda Heather Cooke Ashley Mitchell Theresa Gonzalez Camila Nakagawa[/COLOR][/CENTER]

[QUOTE=nevidcm;434294][CENTER]The Challenge: Heroes vs. Villains [COLOR="#0000FF"]Heroes: Brian Williams Zach Nichols Johnny Bananas Robb Schreiber Brad Fiorenza Leroy Garrett Derrick Kosinski Arielle Scott Nany Gonzalez Emily Schromm Averey Tressler Jonna Mannion Sarah Rice KellyAnne Judd[/COLOR] [COLOR="#FF0000"]Villains: Wes Bergmann Cory Wharton Frank Sweeney Jordan Wiseley CT Tamburello Trey Weatherholtz Adam Royer Nia Moore Laurel Stucky Marie Roda Heather Cooke Ashley Mitchell Theresa Gonzalez Camila Nakagawa[/COLOR][/CENTER][/QUOTE] Based on edits I'd switch Bananas & CT

[QUOTE=Challenge 17;434297]Based on edits I'd switch Bananas & CT[/QUOTE] In my opinion they are interchangeable, but I have a feeling they would put Bananas on the Heroes team and CT on the villains, but I may be wrong.

[QUOTE=Challenge 17;434297]Based on edits I'd switch Bananas & CT[/QUOTE] Bananas was already a "good guy" and CT a "bad sss" on the same season Not sure either fit the "hero" mold but it truly doesn't matter...they'll do whatever they want

The Ruins-Old School vs New School Old-School Mark(Road Rules 1) Brad(San Diego 1) Ace(Paris) Steven(Las Vegas 1) Abram(South Pacific) Landon(Philadelphia) Syrus(Boston) Beth(Los Angles) Trishelle(Las Vegas 1) Veronica(Semester at Sea) Susie(Down Under) Elka(Boston) Mallory(Paris) Tina(South Pacific) New School Frank(San Diego 2) Cory(Ex-plosion) Jordan(Portland) Leroy(Las Vegas 2) Zach(San Diego 2) CJ(Cancun) Brian(Ex-plosion) Emily(DC) Nany(Las Vegas 2) Jonna(Cancun) Jenny(Explosion) Sarah(Brooklyn) Avery(Portland) Arielle(Ex-plosion)

[QUOTE=nevidcm;434300]In my opinion they are interchangeable, but I have a feeling they would put Bananas on the Heroes team and CT on the villains, but I may be wrong.[/QUOTE] Good point, I do like your cast tho

Cutthroat 2 [COLOR=#0000FF]Blue Team[/COLOR] [COLOR=#0000FF] Brad Davis Derrick Diem Dustin Emily Jodi Kina Landon Laura Robb Sarah [/COLOR] [COLOR=#808080][B]Gray Team[/B][/COLOR] [COLOR=#808080] Alton Aneesa CT Cara Z. Cohutta Johnny R. Laurel Leroy Nany Susie Tori Wes Zach [/COLOR] [COLOR=#FF0000][B]Red Team[/B][/COLOR] [COLOR=#FF0000] Abram Brian Cory Darrell Hailey Jenna Mark Rachel Theresa Tina Wes Veronica[/COLOR]

You have Wes on both the Grey team and Red.

Cutthroat 2 Location Japan [COLOR="#800080"]Purple Team Bananas Cohutta Thomas Derrick Wes Sarah Laurel Jonna Devyn Laura [/COLOR][B]Black Team Leroy Issac Zach Brian Tyler Jenny Emily Aneesa LaToya Jenn [/B][COLOR="#00FF00"]Green Team Pete CT Darrell CJ Johnny R KellyAnne Rachel Nany Averey Hailey [/COLOR]

[QUOTE=JayTee;434396]You have Wes on both the Grey team and Red.[/QUOTE] Forgot to replace Gray Team Wes with Theo.

[B][U]The Challenge: The Ruins II[/U][/B] [COLOR="#0000CD"][U]Heroes:[/U] Andrew Brian CJ CT Darrell Davis Leroy Mike M Ashley K Callie Cara Maria Diem Emily Hailey KellyAnne Sarah[/COLOR] [ATTACH]5918[/ATTACH] [COLOR="#B22222"][U]Villains:[/U] Cory Greg Johnny Jordan Knight Puck Ryan L Thomas Beth Cooke Coral Erika Jamie Nia Rachel Tina[/COLOR] [ATTACH]5919[/ATTACH]

Heroes

I would pay money to see RW Hollywood Greg do a challenge. Other than Joey, he made Hollywood very entertaining in his time there imo

[QUOTE=JayTee;434739]I would pay money to see RW Hollywood Greg do a challenge. Other than Joey, he made Hollywood very entertaining in his time there imo[/QUOTE] I actually agree. I think it would be hilarious to see him on a challenge. I feel like he would be hated by ALOT of people.

Lurker made a very interesting cast I mean you have legends, regulars, rookies, and people that have never done a challenge. It can be any teams game because of how diversified each team is. However, I would not have Puck on a challenge because I don't think his old bones can walk a mile, let alone compete on a Challenge. If it were me, I would just replace Puck with Frank Sweeney and Davis with someone like Ace.

Greg would be TV gold on a challenge. However I feel like he would be a lot different now. He should have been casted on a challenge right after his season. That would have been amazing but he probably declined considering he wouldn't even go to the reunion.

Cutthroat style complete random teams but wondering who you guys think would win Red Team 1. Tyrie 1. Jillian 2. Brad 2. Ruthie 3. Mark 3. Anessa 4. CT 4. Johanna 5. Nehemiah 5. Ayiaa Green Team 1. Derek 1. Joanna 2. Bananas 2. Coral 3. Evan 3. Rachel Moyer 4. LeeRoy 4. Tonya 5. Tyler 5. Camilla Blue Team 1. Issac 1. Laurel 2. TY 2. Colie 3. Frank Sweeney 3. Paula 4. Kenny 4. Beth 5. Alton 5. Cara Maria

[QUOTE=JayTee;434902]Lurker made a very interesting cast I mean you have legends, regulars, rookies, and people that have never done a challenge. It can be any teams game because of how diversified each team is. However, I would not have Puck on a challenge because I don't think his old bones can walk a mile, let alone compete on a Challenge. If it were me, I would just replace Puck with Frank Sweeney and Davis with someone like Ace.[/QUOTE] Thanks! Diversity was really what I was going for, I think it is something recent seasons have heavily lacked. I only included Puck because he is the most iconic RW villain IMO. He'd definitely be the first male sent packing. If they ever decide to do Heroes vs Villains/Good Guys vs Bad *****, with the right amount of time and effort, the cast could be incredible.

[QUOTE=LurkerNoMore;435056]Thanks! Diversity was really what I was going for, I think it is something recent seasons have heavily lacked. [B]I only included Puck because he is the most iconic RW villain IMO. He'd definitely be the first male sent packing.[/B] If they ever decide to do Heroes vs Villains/Good Guys vs Bad *****, with the right amount of time and effort, the cast could be incredible.[/QUOTE] Isn't he in jail? Or did I miss something I liked the cast though

[QUOTE=kvm1977;435058]Isn't he in jail? Or did I miss something I liked the cast though[/QUOTE] David Edwards can be Puck's replacement if he is in jail. He's quite an infamous RW villain as well.

[QUOTE=kvm1977;435058][B]Isn't he in jail?[/B] Or did I miss something I liked the cast though[/QUOTE] Probably!

The Challenge: Battle of the Names Location: Peru This format will have teams paired together based on having the same name. There will be separate winners for males and females. Male Teams: Johnny B. (RW Key West) & Johnny R. (RW Portland) Theo G. (RW Chicago) & Theo V. (RR Maximum Velocity Tour) Derrick (RR Xtreme) & Derek C. (RW Cancun) Eric J. (RR Campus Crawl) & Eric N. (RW New York) Frank R. (RW Las Vegas 2002) & Frank S. (RW San Diego 2011) Adam K. (RW Paris) & Adam L. (RR Quest) Zach M. (RW Key West) & Zach N. (RW San Diego 2011) David B. (RW New Orleans 2000) & David B. (RW Seattle) Female Teams: Sarah G. (RR Campus Crawl) & Sarah R. (RW Brooklyn) Heather M. (RW Las Vegas 2011) & Heather Cooke (RW Las Vegas 2011) Rachel M (RW Austin). & Rachel R. (RR Campus Crawl) Emilee (RW Cancun) & Emily S. (RW DC) Ashley K. (RW San Diego 2011) & Ashley M. (RW Ex-Plosion) Jenn (RW Denver) & Jenny (RW Ex-Plosion) Cara Z. (RR South Pacific) & Cara Maria (Fresh Meat II) Katie (RR Quest) & Katelynn (RW Brooklyn) Some name pairings may not be exact but these are nothing compared to some of the stretches MTV/BMP pulls. Obviously a good amount of this cast wouldn't be realistic today. Who would win and make a 3 team final for each gender?

[QUOTE=KingWalsh;434996]Cutthroat style complete random teams but wondering who you guys think would win Red Team 1. Tyrie 1. Jillian 2. Brad 2. Ruthie 3. Mark 3. Anessa 4. CT 4. Johanna 5. Nehemiah 5. Ayiaa Green Team 1. Derek 1. Joanna 2. Bananas 2. Coral 3. Evan 3. Rachel Moyer 4. LeeRoy 4. Tonya 5. Tyler 5. Camilla Blue Team 1. Issac 1. Laurel 2. TY 2. Colie 3. Frank Sweeney 3. Paula 4. Kenny 4. Beth 5. Alton 5. Cara Maria[/QUOTE] I think Green but I do like Blue more

[QUOTE=LurkerNoMore;434536][B][U]The Challenge: The Ruins II[/U][/B] [COLOR="#0000CD"][U]Heroes:[/U] Andrew Brian CJ CT Darrell Davis Leroy Mike M Ashley K Callie Cara Maria Diem Emily Hailey KellyAnne Sarah[/COLOR] [ATTACH]5918[/ATTACH] [COLOR="#B22222"][U]Villains:[/U] Cory Greg Johnny Jordan Knight Puck Ryan L Thomas Beth Cooke Coral Erika Jamie Nia Rachel Tina[/COLOR] [ATTACH]5919[/ATTACH][/QUOTE] I really like this Heroes vs Villains idea, I think it could be really marketable if done right. I decided to challenge myself and see if I could create another 32 cast member season without anyone from the first cast I made. The first one was significantly better, but it would still be decent with the generational/era gap amongst the cast members (even if some of them are pure fantasy picks!), you could definitely create a hybrid of the two and it would be just as good. [B][U]The Challenge: The Ruins II[/U][/B] [COLOR="#006633"][U]Heroes:[/U] Abram Bronne Derrick Frank Landon Luke Noor Will Ashlee Baya Brittini Devyn Julie Katie Mallory Ruthie[/COLOR] [ATTACH]5941[/ATTACH] [COLOR="#800080"][U]Villains:[/U] Adam David Dustin Karamo Stephen N Stephen W Ty Tyler Ashley Ayiiia Brianna Jenn Kimberly Melissa Nany Trisha[/COLOR] [ATTACH]5942[/ATTACH] Some people are interchangeable, like Kim, who was a hero on Duel 2 but a complete ***** on her season. At first glance, the Villains are considerably weaker, but if they were to dwindle down to Dustin, Ty, Tyler, Jenn, and Nany (maybe even some outliers like Kim, Ashley, Ayiiia, Adam, and Karamo as well), they could be quite a formidable team.