[QUOTE=LurkerNoMore;435201]I really like this Heroes vs Villains idea, I think it could be really marketable if done right. I decided to challenge myself and see if I could create another 32 cast member season without anyone from the first cast I made. The first one was significantly better, but it would still be decent with the generational/era gap amongst the cast members (even if some of them are pure fantasy picks!), you could definitely create a hybrid of the two and it would be just as good.
[B][U]The Challenge: The Ruins II[/U][/B]
[COLOR="#006633"][U]Heroes:[/U]
Abram
Bronne
Derrick
Frank
Landon
Luke
Noor
Will
Ashlee
Baya
Brittini
Devyn
Julie
Katie
Mallory
Ruthie[/COLOR]
[ATTACH]5941[/ATTACH]
[COLOR="#800080"][U]Villains:[/U]
Adam
David
Dustin
Karamo
Stephen N
Stephen W
Ty
Tyler
Ashley
Ayiiia
Brianna
Jenn
Kimberly
Melissa
Nany
Trisha[/COLOR]
[ATTACH]5942[/ATTACH]
Some people are interchangeable, like Kim, who was a hero on Duel 2 but a complete ***** on her season.
At first glance, the Villains are considerably weaker, but if they were to dwindle down to Dustin, Ty, Tyler, Jenn, and Nany (maybe even some outliers like Kim, Ashley, Ayiiia, Adam, and Karamo as well), they could be quite a formidable team.[/QUOTE]
What did Stephen(Denver) did that was villainous? I'm just curious. He is one of those cast members that are easily forgettable like Jose(Key West).
[QUOTE=LurkerNoMore;435201]I really like this Heroes vs Villains idea, I think it could be really marketable if done right. I decided to challenge myself and see if I could create another 32 cast member season without anyone from the first cast I made. The first one was significantly better, but it would still be decent with the generational/era gap amongst the cast members (even if some of them are pure fantasy picks!), you could definitely create a hybrid of the two and it would be just as good.
[B][U]The Challenge: The Ruins II[/U][/B]
[COLOR=#006633][U]Heroes:[/U]
Abram
Bronne
Derrick
Frank
Landon
Luke
Noor
Will
Ashlee
Baya
Brittini
Devyn
Julie
Katie
Mallory
Ruthie[/COLOR]
[ATTACH]5941[/ATTACH]
[COLOR=#800080][U]Villains:[/U]
Adam
David
Dustin
Karamo
Stephen N
Stephen W
Ty
Tyler
Ashley
Ayiiia
Brianna
Jenn
Kimberly
Melissa
Nany
Trisha[/COLOR]
[ATTACH]5942[/ATTACH]
Some people are interchangeable, like Kim, who was a hero on Duel 2 but a complete ***** on her season.
At first glance, the Villains are considerably weaker, but if they were to dwindle down to Dustin, Ty, Tyler, Jenn, and Nany (maybe even some outliers like Kim, Ashley, Ayiiia, Adam, and Karamo as well), they could be quite a formidable team.[/QUOTE]
That girl cast is amazing, it's sad that we won't see what Ashley, Baya and Ashlee can bring to the table. I feel like Julie can be interchangeable, it was crazy how she changed from a mormon "good girl" to a crazy phsyco like that. She was tv gold.
I disagree a little on what you consider to be a villain. There's some people, like Nany, that may be crazy and a bad ***, but I don't really consider them to be a villain.
I feel like Brianna is such a sweet girl and doesn't deserve to be in the villains, but the others I can understand why.
Battle of the Seasons:
With 6 players on each team.
Vegas-Dustin,Leroy,Adam,Heather,Nany,Cooke
Portland-Jordan,Marlon,Johnny,Averey,Nia,Jess
San Diego-Zach,Frank,Nate,Priscilla,Ashley,Alex
NOLA-Knight,Eric,Ryan,Sahar,Jemmye,Ashlee
Ex-Plosion-Cory,Tom,Brian,Jenny,Jamie,Hailey
St.Thomas-Trey,Swift,Robb,Marie,Latoya,Laura
[QUOTE=JayTee;435222]I'm going with Vegas. Unless San Diego 2 managed to get rid of everyone on their team except for Zach, Frank and Ashley K.[/QUOTE]
Me too, with Portland a close second.
[QUOTE=JayTee;435209]Ashley and Baya look ***** in their pics.
[B]I see that there's a lot of Black love for the villains cast lol[/B][/QUOTE]
I noticed that after I posted the collage, ****!
[QUOTE=melm3;435213]What did Stephen(Denver) did that was villainous? I'm just curious. He is one of those cast members that are easily forgettable like Jose(Key West).[/QUOTE]
I vaguely remember him having issues with Davis.
[QUOTE=nevidcm;435217]That girl cast is amazing, it's sad that we won't see what Ashley, Baya and Ashlee can bring to the table. I feel like Julie can be interchangeable, it was crazy how she changed from a mormon "good girl" to a crazy phsyco like that. She was tv gold.
I disagree a little on what you consider to be a villain. There's some people, like Nany, that may be crazy and a bad ***, but I don't really consider them to be a villain.
I feel like Brianna is such a sweet girl and doesn't deserve to be in the villains, but the others I can understand why.[/QUOTE]
Nany was more to balance the teams out. She walks around acting like a "bad *****", and she does start a lot of fake drama so I thought Villain was a slight stretch, but mildly appropriate.
Bri's debatable too. She probably deserves to be on the Heroes, but I felt for drama purposes that putting her and Kim on the same team was a good idea. [URL="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g6OniCbqOhw"]Plus there's this.[/URL]
I think there's an argument for many people the blur the line between hero and villain. CT for example, he definitely was a villain years ago, but then look at his hero edit on Rivals.
[B][U]The Challenge: Battle of the Ages[/U][/B]
[U][B]Legends (Old School):[/B][/U]
Abram
Ace
Brad
CT
Darrell
Eric
Mark
Syrus
Wes
Aneesa
Arissa
Beth
Coral
Elka
Lacey
Mallory
Rachel
Ruthie
[COLOR="#A9A9A9"][U][B]Warriors (New School):[/B][/U]
Brandon
Cory
Johnny
Leroy
Marlon
Nate
Trey
Tyrie
Zach
Averey
Cara Maria
Jenn
Jenny
Laura
Laurel
Marie
Nia
Sam[/COLOR]
[ATTACH]5943[/ATTACH]
[B]The Challenge: Old School vs. New School[/B]
[COLOR="#FF0000"][B]Old School: (until Real World: Sydney)[/B]
Abram Boise
Beth Stolarcsyk
Cohutta Grindstaff
Coral Smith
Derrick Kosinski
Diem Brown
Johnny "Bananas" Devenanzio
KellyAnne Judd
Mark Long
Nehemiah Clark
Rachel Robinson
Steven Hill
Svetlana Shusterman
Trishelle Cannatella
Veronica Portillo
Wes Bergmann[/COLOR]
[ATTACH]5946[/ATTACH]
[COLOR="#0000FF"][B]New School: (Real World: Hollywood - present)[/B]
Averey Tressler
Ayiiia Elizarraras
Brian Williams
Cory Wharton
Dustin Zito
Emily Schromm
Frank Sweeney
Heather Cooke
Jenny Delich
Johnny Reilly
Jonna Mannion
Marie Roda
Robb Schreiber
Theresa Gonzalez
Thomas Buell
Zach Nichols[/COLOR]
[ATTACH]5947[/ATTACH]
[QUOTE=nevidcm;435400][B]The Challenge: Old School vs. New School[/B]
[COLOR="#FF0000"][B]Old School: (until Real World: Sydney)[/B]
Abram Boise
Beth Stolarcsyk
Cohutta Grindstaff
Coral Smith
Derrick Kosinski
Diem Brown
Johnny "Bananas" Devenanzio
KellyAnne Judd
Mark Long
Nehemiah Clark
Rachel Robinson
Steven Hill
Svetlana Shusterman
Trishelle Cannatella
Veronica Portillo
Wes Bergmann[/COLOR]
[ATTACH]5946[/ATTACH]
[COLOR="#0000FF"][B]New School: (Real World: Hollywood - present)[/B]
Averey Tressler
Ayiiia Elizarraras
Brian Williams
Cory Wharton
Dustin Zito
Emily Schromm
Frank Sweeney
Heather Cooke
Jenny Delich
Johnny Reilly
Jonna Mannion
Marie Roda
Robb Schreiber
Theresa Gonzalez
Thomas Buell
Zach Nichols[/COLOR]
[ATTACH]5947[/ATTACH][/QUOTE]
I love it, btw how do you guys get pictures?
The Challenge: Allied Forces
[COLOR="#FF0000"]Chet & Ryan[/COLOR]
[COLOR="#0000FF"]CT & David B[/COLOR]
[COLOR="#008000"]Dan & David L[/COLOR]
[COLOR="#FFD700"]Dave & Will[/COLOR]
[COLOR="#800080"]Eric & Mark[/COLOR]
Evan & Kenny
[COLOR="#A9A9A9"]Aneesa & Svetlana[/COLOR]
[COLOR="#ff0066"]Baya & Devyn[/COLOR]
[COLOR="#ff6600"]Cara Maria & Laurel[/COLOR]
[COLOR="#FF0000"]Joi & Nia[/COLOR]
[COLOR="#0000FF"]Leah & Mallory[/COLOR]
[COLOR="#008000"]Sarah & Susie[/COLOR]
[COLOR="#FFD700"]Dustin & Nany[/COLOR]
[COLOR="#800080"]Johnny & Jenn[/COLOR]
Knight & Ashlee
[COLOR="#A9A9A9"]Mike M & Emily[/COLOR]
[COLOR="#B22222"]Miz & Coral[/COLOR]
[COLOR="#40E0D0"]Wes & Lacey[/COLOR]
[ATTACH]5958[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH]5959[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH]5960[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH]5961[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH]5962[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH]5963[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH]5964[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH]5965[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH]5966[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH]5967[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH]5968[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH]5969[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH]5970[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH]5971[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH]5972[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH]5973[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH]5974[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH]5975[/ATTACH]
^^ Kenny&Evan are the winners, Johnny and Jenn are a good couple too. I would like if all couples are either girl/guy pairs (Bananas&Paula, CT&Cara Maria, Nany&Dustin, Wes&Ev etcc) or girl&girl and guy&guy pairs and winners are one from girl and from guy pairs. I think mixed is little bit unfair
[QUOTE=LurkerNoMore;435756]The Challenge: Allied Forces
[COLOR="#FF0000"]Chet & Ryan[/COLOR]
[COLOR="#0000FF"]CT & David B[/COLOR]
[COLOR="#008000"]Dan & David L[/COLOR]
[COLOR="#FFD700"]Dave & Will[/COLOR]
[COLOR="#800080"]Eric & Mark[/COLOR]
Evan & Kenny
[COLOR="#A9A9A9"]Aneesa & Svetlana[/COLOR]
[COLOR="#ff0066"]Baya & Devyn[/COLOR]
[COLOR="#ff6600"]Cara Maria & Laurel[/COLOR]
[COLOR="#FF0000"]Joi & Nia[/COLOR]
[COLOR="#0000FF"]Leah & Mallory[/COLOR]
[COLOR="#008000"]Sarah & Susie[/COLOR]
[COLOR="#FFD700"]Dustin & Nany[/COLOR]
[COLOR="#800080"]Johnny & Jenn[/COLOR]
Knight & Ashlee
[COLOR="#A9A9A9"]Mike M & Emily[/COLOR]
[COLOR="#B22222"]Miz & Coral[/COLOR]
[COLOR="#40E0D0"]Wes & Lacey[/COLOR]
[ATTACH]5958[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH]5959[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH]5960[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH]5961[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH]5962[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH]5963[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH]5964[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH]5965[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH]5966[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH]5967[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH]5968[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH]5969[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH]5970[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH]5971[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH]5972[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH]5973[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH]5974[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH]5975[/ATTACH][/QUOTE]
Guy guy pairs are way to unfair same with guy girl. If you're going to do same *** teams make it guy/guy and Girl/girl like rivals. Putting some pairs with two guys is handing them the money
[QUOTE=Challenge 17;435783]Guy guy pairs are way to unfair same with guy girl. If you're going to do same *** teams make it guy/guy and Girl/girl like rivals. Putting some pairs with two guys is handing them the money[/QUOTE]
My thought was make it Rivals-styled. Alternate between male/male, female/female, and male/female days. 12 eliminations, 6 teams in the final (2 of each gender match-up). 3 teams would win, 6 winners total.
[QUOTE=LurkerNoMore;435788]My thought was make it Rivals-styled. Alternate between male/male, female/female, and male/female days. 12 eliminations, 6 teams in the final (2 of each gender match-up). 3 teams would win, 6 winners total.[/QUOTE]
Ah I see, that's much more fair then. Winners are Even & Kenny, Cara & Laurel and Johnny & Jenn
Okay, I've rarely due these but after watching the first episode of Steve Austin's Broken Skull Challenge this crossed by mind for a potential Duel III. I'm also using something from Big Brother. Here's my thought...a duel is supposed to be a contest between 2 people typically to settle a point of honor. Let's actually see 2 people go head to head. But here's how I think it should be cast then I'll get into the rules.
Casting starts as normal with production making their first and second rounds of availability calls. Once they determine who is willing to do a challenge they start be selecting 3 [B]of the best[/B] competitors and 3 [B]of the best[/B] strategic players. Everyone will disagree with who falls into those categories but let's start with...
Men
Competitors
Landon-Philadelphia
CT-Paris
Darrell-Campus Crawl
Strategists
Wes-Austin
Johnny-Key West
Mark-First Adventure
Women
Competitors
Laurel-FM2
Emily-DC
Rachel-Campus Crawl
Strategists
Veronica-Semester at Sea
Susie-Down Under
Coral-Back to NY
Yes, this is "veteran heavy" but I'm just using this as a starting ground. Following production making their selections they allow "the fans" to vote to fill out the remaining cast. Anyone that is willing to participate is posted and, like with Big Brother All-Stars, the fans vote to determine who will be added to the cast to take on the best of the best. Production then will take the top 5 people of both ***es per the voting. In addition, they will send an additional person from the most recent season of The Real World to ensure they're introducing new cast members. Something that has been a problem in the past (see NOLA2). This gives us 12 guys and 12 girls for a total of 11 episodes as only 2 people make the final. Duel = 2.
Now, going back to the broken skull challenge. Each "mission" will be a bracket where players will go head to head in rounds to determine the winner of the mission. Pure competition. The "missions" will be set to different categories much like the elimination rounds in Season 2 (Mental, Physical, Endurance & Strategy) with the winner of the mission getting to pick of member of their *** and the opposing *** to go into the Duel. The winner is also given the ability to set the bracket for the following mission but will not be notified of the "category" prior to making the bracket. The first bracket will be determined by a random draw.
So, for example, Emily & CT win the first mission. Emily selects Wes. CT then picks Johnny & Coral. Emily picks Susie. Using this order the person of the same *** that won always gets to set the matchup based on the decision of the other winner. Winning missions will put a target on your back but allows you complete power. How it should be IMO.
This sets up perfect drama with legit alliances and will create a ton of very ****** off people. Just spitballing here
[QUOTE=Debut Album;435322]Cutthroat 2: Generations
Red Team-Real World/Road Rules Era(Battle of the Seasons 1-The Gauntlet 2)
Mark(Road Rules 1)
Brad(San Diego)
Ace(Paris)
Abram(South Pacific)
Darrell(Campus Crawl)
Beth(Los Angeles)
Susie(Down Under)
Coral(Back to New York)
Veronica(Semester at Sea)
Ruthie(Hawaii)
Blue Team-Fresh Meat 1 Era(Fresh Meat 1-The Ruins)
John(Key West)
Wes(Austin)
Evan(Fresh Meat 1)
Dunbar(Sydney)
Kenny(Fresh Meat 1)
Jenn(Denver)
Kellyanne(Sydney)
Diem(Fresh Meat 1)
Evelyn(Fresh Meat 1)
Casey(Fresh Meat 1)
Grey Team-The New Generation(Fresh Meat 2-now)
Frank(San Diego 2)
CJ(Cancun)
Zach(San Diego 2)
Cory(Ex-plosion)
Brandon(Fresh Meat 2)
Emily(DC)
Laurel(Fresh Meat 2)
Nany(Las Vegas 2)
Cara Maria(Fresh Meat 2)
Jonna(Cancun)[/QUOTE]
I actually think teams are good and I do not know, who is the winners. Glad to see some fresh meaters there
[QUOTE=Debut Album;435322]Cutthroat 2: Generations
Red Team-Real World/Road Rules Era(Battle of the Seasons 1-The Gauntlet 2)
Mark(Road Rules 1)
Brad(San Diego)
Ace(Paris)
Abram(South Pacific)
Darrell(Campus Crawl)
Beth(Los Angeles)
Susie(Down Under)
Coral(Back to New York)
Veronica(Semester at Sea)
Ruthie(Hawaii)
Blue Team-Fresh Meat 1 Era(Fresh Meat 1-The Ruins)
John(Key West)
Wes(Austin)
Evan(Fresh Meat 1)
Dunbar(Sydney)
Kenny(Fresh Meat 1)
Jenn(Denver)
Kellyanne(Sydney)
Diem(Fresh Meat 1)
Evelyn(Fresh Meat 1)
Casey(Fresh Meat 1)
Grey Team-The New Generation(Fresh Meat 2-now)
Frank(San Diego 2)
CJ(Cancun)
Zach(San Diego 2)
Cory(Ex-plosion)
Brandon(Fresh Meat 2)
Emily(DC)
Laurel(Fresh Meat 2)
Nany(Las Vegas 2)
Cara Maria(Fresh Meat 2)
Jonna(Cancun)[/QUOTE]
Why would you put weak Casey out of all the other better female competitors who'll be more entertaining than that.
Grey Team wins because of her.
[QUOTE=hannamez8;435974]Why would you put weak Casey out of all the other better female competitors who'll be more entertaining than that.
Grey Team wins because of her.[/QUOTE]
I couldn't think of anyone else ot put In her place.
[QUOTE=hannamez8;435974]Why would you put weak Casey out of all the other better female competitors who'll be more entertaining than that.
Grey Team wins because of her.[/QUOTE]
It is cuttthroat! Own team can vote who is going into eliminiation round and if blue wants to get rid of her, they can
Pages