The Challenge: Favorite/Fantasy Casts

The first 2 big challenges (BOTSeasons and BOTSexes) had people that will probably never do a challenge again! Belou, Chris, Sharon, Lindsay, Kelley, Danny, Stephen, Flora, Mike (Miami), Holly (MVT), Josh (Latin America), Tara, Shane (Down Under), Christina, Jake, Antoine, Lori, Melissa, Emily, James, Puck, Ellen, David E... It had an all around amazing cast. Plus those 2 challenges had cast regulars: Veronica, Rachel, Coral, Miz, Theo, Shane, Tonya, Aneesa, Mark, Julie, Timmy Plus a few cast members who came back 1 more time: Holly (Inferno I), Dan (BOTS II), Eric (BOTS II), Ayanna (BOTS II- I slept in my uniform, because I wanted to win today!)

Duel 3: In this fantasy all the players would be as they were at their prime (as in, not comparing how Veronica would be now against Laurel, but comparing them as they would be at their best) Ev Laurel Emily (DC) Emily (Road Rules) Rachel (RR) Ruthie KellyAnne Jodi Veronica Aneesa Coral Julie Tina Tori Jillian Sarah (Brooklyn) Ayanna Robin Evan CT Alton Abram Derrick Brad Mark Timmy Darrell The Miz Frank Landon MJ Wes Cohutta Pete Noor Kenny

[QUOTE=ColiesMom;54045]I enjoyed Susie and Cara! There was one extremely strong member of the Island. You should have seen her tan![/QUOTE] Because they coddled Colie but neglected Paula, and tried to throw challenges on inferno 3? Didn't Johnny Bananas say she worked on her tan so she could wave at boats as they passed by?

I thought, if they altered a few people on the Ruins, that could've been one of the best casts also. Don't get me wrong, that was an all star cast, but I think it would've added a lot of drama if Cara replaced Ibis on the Champions team. Ibis didn't bring anything to that challenge. Replacing Syrus would've been cool too because, just like Ibis he just didn't bring any drama and hardly had any confessionals at all.

Battle of the Series' [B]Concept[/B] First challenge to pit, [U]arguably[/U], the best challengers from each series against each other in the first three way team challenge. Challenge total prize pool is $500,000 with $150,000 in team bank account money split in 15 challenges, $150,000 in team bank account money split in 15 elimination round victories, and a $200,000 final challenge prize. [B]Format[/B] 1. Three way team challenge with the reward being $10,000 in team bank account, and team immunity from up coming elimination round. 2. Losers of the team challenge pick one member of each *** from the the opposing team to go into the elimination against each other, with the *** being determined at random (spinning wheel, lottery ball format, etc). Only members of the same *** will face each other however. 3. Winner of the elimination round is awarded $10,000 in team bank account. Loser is sent home. Elimination rounds are Inferno/Ruins based (unique elimination challenge each time) [B]Extenuating Circumstances[/B] -If an entire *** from a series is eliminated, then the elimination round is automatically set to the remaining *** by default. -If an entire series is eliminated before the final challenge, then that series' team bank account is awarded to the victors of the final challenge. -If an entire series that is left with only men (Team:X) is to face off against a series that is left with only women (Team:Y) then Team:Y is awarded the ability to chose the participants of both teams going into that specific elimination round. [B]Chronology and Final Challenge[/B] Challenge($10,000) then Elimination($10,000) x15. 15 Challengers sent home, 15 remaining for final challenge. Final challenge teams could vary from 1v9v5 to 10v5 to 5v5v5 and anything in between. [B]Rosters[/B] [B]Men[/B][LIST=] [[COLOR="Red"]RW[/COLOR]]Landon Lueck [[COLOR="Red"]RW[/COLOR]]Chris 'CT' Tamburello [[COLOR="Red"]RW[/COLOR]]Alton Williams [[COLOR="Red"]RW[/COLOR]]Brad Fiorenza [[COLOR="Red"]RW[/COLOR]]Wes Bergmann [[COLOR="Blue"]RR[/COLOR]]Darrell Taylor [[COLOR="Blue"]RR[/COLOR]]Derrick Kosinski [[COLOR="Blue"]RR[/COLOR]]Mark Long [[COLOR="Blue"]RR[/COLOR]]Abram Boise [[COLOR="Blue"]RR[/COLOR]]Shane Landrum [[COLOR="SeaGreen"]FM[/COLOR]]Evan Starkman [[COLOR="SeaGreen"]FM[/COLOR]]Kenny Santucci [[COLOR="SeaGreen"]FM[/COLOR]]Pete Connolly [[COLOR="SeaGreen"]FM[/COLOR]]Eric Banks [[COLOR="SeaGreen"]FM[/COLOR]]Noor Jehangir [/LIST] [B]Women[/B][LIST=] [[COLOR="Red"]RW[/COLOR]]Kelly-Anne Judd [[COLOR="Red"]RW[/COLOR]]Sarah Rice [[COLOR="Red"]RW[/COLOR]]Tonya Colley [[COLOR="Red"]RW[/COLOR]]Julie Stoffer [[COLOR="Red"]RW[/COLOR]]Brittini Sherrod [[COLOR="Blue"]RR[/COLOR]]Rachel Robinson [[COLOR="Blue"]RR[/COLOR]]Tina Barta [[COLOR="Blue"]RR[/COLOR]]Susie Meister [[COLOR="Blue"]RR[/COLOR]]Kina Dean [[COLOR="Blue"]RR[/COLOR]]Jodi Weatherton [[COLOR="SeaGreen"]FM[/COLOR]]Evelyn Smith [[COLOR="SeaGreen"]FM[/COLOR]]Diem Brown [[COLOR="SeaGreen"]FM[/COLOR]]Laurel Stucky [[COLOR="SeaGreen"]FM[/COLOR]]Cara Maria Sorbello [[COLOR="SeaGreen"]FM[/COLOR]]Theresa Gonzalez [/LIST] [B]Roster Reasoning[/B] [COLOR="Red"]Notable absentees from RW[/COLOR]: Mike Mizanin is unlikely to ever return to challenges due to WWE career/contract. [COLOR="Blue"]Notable absentees from RR[/COLOR]: Timmy Beggy is unlikely to ever return to challenges due to physical injuries. Theo Vonkurnatowski is unlikely to ever return to challenges due to comedy career.

[QUOTE=thamsenman;183533]Because they coddled Colie but neglected Paula, and tried to throw challenges on inferno 3?[/quote] YES

[QUOTE=feminthea;183083]I stopped watching for a while and didn't see some of these challenges - do they ever show the old seasons on MTV anymore?[/QUOTE] Sadly no. Oh and I say Battle of the Seasons.

Probably the Duel for me, that cast was awesome with Derrick, Evan, Wes, CT and many others.

[CENTER][B][U]Real World/Road Rules Challenge: Battle of the Seasons 2[/U][/B] [B]Hosts:[/B] Mark and Eric [B][U]Real World Team[/U][/B] Jon & Beth (Los Angeles) Colin & Ruthie (Hawaii) Jamie & Juile (New Orleans) Mike & Coral (Back to NY) Alton & Irulan or Frank/Steven & Trishelle (Las Vegas) Brad & Robin (San Diego) Danny & Melinda or Wes & Johanna (Austin) Tyrie & Jenn (Denver) CJ & Emilee (Cancun) Ty & Emily or Mike & Ashley (DC) [B][U]Road Rules Team[/U][/B] Timmy & Emily (Second Adventure) Dan & Roni (Northern Trail) Chadwick & Susie (Down Under) Yes & Veronica (Semester at Sea) Theo & Holly (Maximum Velocity Tour) Adam & Katie (Quest) Darrell & Rachel (Campus Crawl) Abram & Mary Beth/Tina (South Pacific) Derrick/Patrick & Jillian/Jodi (X-Treme) Dan & Tori (Viewers Revenge)[/CENTER] If only this could be the format and cast for the next challenge...Can you guys say best challenge ever?

I'd love to see a Duel 3! (Sorry, I've only seen from Fresh Meat and forward, so I don't know any of the people that haven't been on a Challenge since then.) Abram (RR: South Pacific) Alton (RW: Las Vegas) Brad (RW: San Diego) Bronne (RW: Cancun) CT (RW: Paris) Darrell (RR: Campus Crawl) Davis (RW: Denver) Johnny (RW: Key West) Landon (RW: Philadelphia) Mike (RW: DC) Pete (FM2) Scott (RW: Brooklyn) Wes (RW: Austin) Ayiiia (RW: Cancun) Baya (RW: Brooklyn) Brittini (RW: Hollywood) Emily (RW: DC) Jonna (RW: Cancun) KellyAnne (RW: Sydney) Laurel (FM2) Rachel (RR: Campus Crawl) Sarah (RW: Brookyln) Svetlana (RW: Key West) Theresa (FM2) Tonya (RW: Chicago) Veronica (RR: Semester at Sea)

I would love to see a completely stacked Duel 3! I have 2 versions of my ideal cast, one that is practical (competitors who would realistically be able to do a challenge in the near future) and one that is completely fantasy, with all the best competitors competing like they did in their prime. [B][U]Practical Cast: [/U][/B][COLOR=Blue]CT Landon Evan Wes Brad Abram Darrell Noor Pete Derrick Kenny Mark [COLOR=Red]Ev Laurel Cara Maria Kelly Anne Sarah (Rice) Susie Kina Tori Jillian Jenn Aneesa Emily (from DC) [U][B][COLOR=Black]Fantasy Cast [/COLOR][/B][/U][/COLOR][/COLOR][COLOR=Blue]CT Landon Evan Wes Brad Abram Darrell Noor Timmy Derrick Alton Mark[/COLOR] [COLOR=Blue][COLOR=Red]Ev Laurel Cara Maria Kelly Anne Sarah (Rice) Coral Jodi Tori Rachel (Robinson) Veronica Aneesa Emily (from DC)[/COLOR][/COLOR]

The Gauntlet 4 Old School vs. New School Of course, it's called fantasy for a reason. But I tried to be SLIGHTLY realistic. Slightly. Old School (RW New York-RW Philadelphia, RR USA-RR Extreme. AKA: Anything before Fresh Meat) Abram (Road Rules: South Pacific) Belou (Road Rules: Europe) Brad (Real World: San Diego) Coral (Real World: Back to New York) Darrell (Road Rules: Campus Crawl) Emily (Road Rules: USA II) Flora (Real World: Miami) Julie (Real World: New Orleans) Kendal (Road Rules: Campus Crawl) Landon (Real World: Philadelphia) Mark (Road Rules: USA) Mike (Real World: Back to New York) Piggy (Road Rules: Australia) Puck (Real World: San Francisco) Veronica (Road Rules: Semester at Sea) Yes (Road Rules: Semester at Sea) New School (Anything from Fresh Meat and after) Ashley (Real World: DC) Ayiiia (Real World: Cancun) Brianna (Real World: Hollywood) Bronne (Real World: Cancun) Brooke (Real World: Denver) Cohutta (Real World: Sydney) Dan (Road Rules: Viewers Revenge) JD (Real World: Brooklyn) Kenny (Fresh Meat) Laurel (Fresh Meat 2) Mike (Real World: DC) Pete (Fresh Meat 2) Sandy (Fresh Meat 2) Svetlana (Real World: Key West) Tori (Road Rules: Viewers Revenge) Wes (Real World Austin) With the ten episode format, twenty people would be eliminated out of thirty two, thus leaving twelve players remaining at the final challenge. Sigh...

What do you think about this cast for the Duel 3 (assuming we get a Duel III)-- Challenge Duel 3 ---------------- 1.Emily (D.C.) 2.Emilee(Cancun) 3.Ayaii (Cancun) 4.Jemmye (B2 New Orleans) 5.Laurel (FM2) 6.Cara Maria (FM2) 7.Kellyanne (Sydney) 8.Sarah (Brooklyn) 9.Kim (Hollywood) 10.Brianna (Hollywood) 11.Teresa (FM2) 12.Mandy (FM2) 13.Ashli (Sydney) 14.Brittni (Hollywood) 15.Ashley (D.C.) Males ------------ 1.Ty (DC) 2.Johnny (Key West) 3.JD (Brooklyn) 4.CJ (Cancun) 5.Vinny (FM2) 6.Kenny (FM1) 7.Evan (FM1) 8.Darell (RR:Campus Crawl) 9.Mark (RR1) 10.Landon (Philly?) 11.Scott (Brooklyn) 12.Brandon (FM2) 13.Chet (Brooklyn) 14.Isaiac (Sydney) 15.Mike (D.C.) 10 Challenges Challenge winners pick 1 person of the same *** (1 male & 1 female) to send into the duel.That person chooses their opponent. Of course, challenge winners are exempt until they have to face their 1 duel. Challenge winners can choose to pick 1 or both of their personal duels.Every challenger faces the duel once. If you win the duel, you recieve $5,000 to put into your bank. If you lose in the second round of duels, you lose your bank, and it goes back into the pot. The final duel will be worth $5,000 + the pot (made up of money lost in all of the combined duels. There will be 8 final chalengers consisting of 4 males and 4 females. 1st place- $100k a piece. 2nd - $20k. 3rd $10k. 4th - $0.

[QUOTE=kdub90;188410]What do you think about this cast for the Duel 3 (assuming we get a Duel III)-- Challenge Duel 3 ---------------- 1.[B]Emily (D.C.) [/B] 2.[B]Emilee(Cancun)[/B] 3.Ayaii (Cancun) 4.[B]Jemmye (B2 New Orleans)[/B] 5.[B]Laurel (FM2)[/B] 6.Cara Maria (FM2) 7.[B]Kellyanne (Sydney)[/B] 8.Sarah (Brooklyn) 9.Kim (Hollywood) 10.Brianna (Hollywood) 11.Teresa (FM2) 12.[B]Mandy (FM2)[/B] 13.[B]Ashli (Sydney)[/B] 14.Brittni (Hollywood) 15.[B]Ashley (D.C.)[/B] Males ------------ 1.[B]Ty (DC)[/B] 2.[B]Johnny (Key West)[/B] 3.JD (Brooklyn) 4.[B]CJ (Cancun)[/B] 5.Vinny (FM2) 6.[B]Kenny (FM1)[/B] 7.[B]Evan (FM1)[/B] 8.Darell (RR:Campus Crawl) 9.[B]Mark (RR1)[/B] 10.[B]Landon (Philly?)[/B] 11.Scott (Brooklyn) 12.[B]Brandon (FM2)[/B] 13.Chet (Brooklyn) 14.Isaiac (Sydney) 15.Mike (D.C.) 10 Challenges Challenge winners pick 1 person of the same *** (1 male & 1 female) to send into the duel.That person chooses their opponent. Of course, challenge winners are exempt until they have to face their 1 duel. Challenge winners can choose to pick 1 or both of their personal duels.Every challenger faces the duel once. If you win the duel, you recieve $5,000 to put into your bank. If you lose in the second round of duels, you lose your bank, and it goes back into the pot. The final duel will be worth $5,000 + the pot (made up of money lost in all of the combined duels. There will be 8 final chalengers consisting of 4 males and 4 females. 1st place- $100k a piece. 2nd - $20k. 3rd $10k. 4th - $0.[/QUOTE] I would shoot myself to watch the bolded castmembers I would want to see Wes, Josh(yeah I know), Eric, J.D and Ryan (24) (again I know), Noor and girls like Sahar, Sydney, Callie,and Ashlee.

I wouldn't mind seeing a Duel 3 with: [u]Women[/u] Shauvon Casey Brooke Jenn Paula Katelynn Theresa Katie Tonya Ibis Diem Robin Beth Rachel (Moyal) Callie (DC) Cara [u]Men[/u] Cohutta Ryan Danny CJ Luke (FM2) Adam Nehemiah Zach Ace Davis J.D. Andrew (DC) Bronne Chet Josh (DC) Pat, Canada's #1 DJ (Cancun) Yes, I'm being serious about these lists. I think it'd be highly entertaining and probably more fair than it usually is.

My dream Duel 3 scenario would be Women Evelyn Beth Aneesa Brittini Emily Ashley Baya Mckenzie :) Laurel Svetlana Ruthie Kim Coral Holly Aviv Kelly Anne Men Abram Alton Andrew Mike (DC) Scott Ryan Cohutta Danny Eric Nies Dan (Northern Trail) Antoine Mike (Miami) CT Brad Chadwick

[QUOTE=Aereas;188447]I wouldn't mind seeing a Duel 3 with: [u]Women[/u] Shauvon Casey Brooke Jenn Paula Katelynn Theresa Katie Tonya Ibis Diem Robin Beth Rachel (Moyal) Callie (DC) Cara [u]Men[/u] Cohutta Ryan Danny CJ Luke (FM2) Adam Nehemiah Zach Ace Davis J.D. Andrew (DC) Bronne Chet Josh (DC) [B]Pat, Canada's #1 DJ (Cancun) [/B] Yes, I'm being serious about these lists. I think it'd be highly entertaining and probably more fair than it usually is.[/QUOTE] I'm cracking up!! HILARIOUS!! XD

My fantasy cast for the Duel 3 [U]Women [/U] Coral Rachel (RR Campus Crawl) Evelyn (FM) Aneesa Laurel (FM) Cara Maria (FM) Emily (DC) Jodi Kina Tina Tonya Susie Kelly Anne Jonna [U]Men[/U] Mark (RR 1) Darrell Wes Evan Brad CT Landon Derrick Scott (RW Brooklyn) Abe (RR SP) Mike (RW DC) Noor FM Pete FM Dan (RR VR) Dan (RR NT) Wouldnt mind a Duel 3 with the best competitors or a duel type challenge with almost all the cast members Aereas has.

Here is my Inferno 4 cast. [COLOR="DarkRed"]Bad *****: Wes (RW: Austin) CT (RW: Paris) Abram (RR: South Pacific) Joey (RW: Cancun) Danny (RW: Austin) Rachel (RR: Campus Crawl) Evelyn (Fresh Meat) Veronica (RR: Semester at Sea) Ayiiia (RW: Cancun) Aneesa (RW: Chicago) [/COLOR] [COLOR="Navy"]Good Guys: Mark (RR: USA- First Adventure) Alton (RW: Las Vegas) Cohutta (RW: Sydney) Bronne (RW: Cancun) Brad (RW: San Diego) Kimberly (RW: Hollywood) Jonna (RW: Cancun) Tori (RR: Viewer's Revenge) Baya (RW: Brooklyn) Devyn (RW: Brooklyn) [/COLOR]

We should have a thread dedicated to basically a waiting list if you will, for the Duel 3. I have a feeling that the Duel 3 should be a great challenge. I mean we already know that Evelyn said she'd do it, and she wants Rachel, KellyAnne, Jodi, and Laurel on it. Those are 5 really strong girls right there. Then Darrell said he would only come back for the Duel 3, Mark said he'd only do another duel. I have a feeling that Landon would probably do it because he didn't win the Duel 2 and he wanted to. I also think it'd be cool if on the Duel 3 they have the four previous Duel winners, Wes, Jodi, Evan, and Rachel. I also think it'd be cool if Frank was on the Duel 3 to match up against Wes. Here is a list of people that I think would be suited for the Duel 3 or who I think will potentially be on it. Guys: Wes (RW: Austin) Danny (RW: Austin) Landon (RW: Philadelphia) Luke (Fresh Meat II) Mark (RR: USA- First Adventure) Darrell (RR: Campus Crawl) Evan (Fresh Meat) Syrus (RW: Boston) Frank (RW: Las Vegas) CJ (RW: Cancun) Dan (RR: Viewer's Revenge) Pete (Fresh Meat II) Mike (RW: Washington, D.C.) Brandon (Fresh Meat II) Ryan (RW: Brooklyn) Knight (RW: New Orleans) Eric (RW: New Orleans) Eric (Fresh Meat) Vinny (Fresh Meat II) Johnny (RW: Key West) Kenny (Fresh Meat) Adam (RW: Paris) Ty (RW: Washington, D.C.) Noor (Fresh Meat II) Dunbar (RW: Sydney) Abram (RR: South Pacific) Girls: KellyAnne (RW: Sydney) Theresa (Fresh Meat II) Evelyn (Fresh Meat) Paula (RW: Key West) Sarah (RW: Brooklyn) Rachel (RR: Campus Crawl) Jodi (RR: X-Treme) Laurel (Fresh Meat II) Diem (Fresh Meat) Jemmye (RW: New Orleans) Mckenzie (RW: New Orleans) Emily (RW: Washington, D.C.) Jenn (RW: Denver) Cara Maria (Fresh Meat II) Callie (RW: Washington, D.C.) Jonna (RW: Cancun) Emilee (RW: Cancun) Aneesa (RW: Chicago) Brittini (RW: Hollywood) Kimberly (RW: Hollywood) Katelynn (RW: Brooklyn) Brianna (RW: Hollywood) Tell me who'd you like to see on the Duel 3 of these people, 13 guys and 13 girls. Who do you think will be on it? Who do you think won't be on it?

[QUOTE=El Scorcho;190390] Tell me who'd you like to see on the Duel 3 of these people, 13 guys and 13 girls. Who do you think will be on it? Who do you think won't be on it?[/QUOTE] How about Derrick, Mandi, Ayiiia, Tori, Brad?

[QUOTE=El Scorcho;190390] Tell me who'd you like to see on the Duel 3 of these people, 13 guys and 13 girls. Who do you think will be on it? Who do you think won't be on it?[/QUOTE] I would love to see on the Duel 3: 1. Miz 2. Derrick 3. Evan 4. Darrell 5. Adam 6. CT 7. Wes 8. Ryan 9. Theo 10. Mark Long 11. Eric 12. Brad 13. Pete (Fresh meat 2) girls: 1. Diem 2. Aneesa 3. Tonya 4. Jillian 5. Tina 6. Beth 7. Coral 8. Susie 9. Evelyn 10. Paula 11. Jenn 12. Rachel 13. Jodi

After what has went down, I wouldn't be down with CT doing another challenge. That incident with Adam was unbearable enough. Anyways... Here's my pics for The Ruins II CHAMPIONS Males ------ 1 Nehemiah 2 Frank 3 Landon 4 Abram 5 Evan 6 Johnny 7 ? (maybe derrick) 8 Wes Females -------- 1 Carley 2 Rachel (RR:CC) 3 Rachel (RW) 4 Veronica 5 Ibis 6 Aviv 7 Johanna 8 Cara CHALLENGERS Males ------ 1 Brandon 2 Vinny 3 Pete 4 Cohutta 5 Scott 6 Chet 7 Mike (D.C.) 8 Eric (B2N.O.) OR Stephen (Denver) Females -------- 1 Briana (HW) 2 Kim (HW) 3 Sarah (BK) 4 Emily (D.C.) 5 Ashley (D.C) 6 Ayaii (Cancun) 7 Emilee (Cancun) 8 Laurel (FM2) I don't think I'll be seeing Ty or CT in a future challenge, so I didn't include them. Darell and Mark are probably only gonna do individual challenges. Let me know what you think, or who you agree on.

I'm not sure if Cara has won a challenge, but I put her as having won 1. It'd be cool if someone put a list of the past number of challenges with the winners; so, it can be used as a reference.

[QUOTE=kdub90;191173]I'm not sure if Cara has won a challenge, but I put her as having won 1. It'd be cool if someone put a list of the past number of challenges with the winners; so, it can be used as a reference.[/QUOTE] Cara won the Gauntlet with the Road Rules team.

The Inferno II, The Gauntlet 2, The Duel, The Gauntlet III, and The Duel 2.

Any gauntlet was great because it introduced a ton of newcomers. The Duel was a good cast, before we were sick of the fresh meat. And Battle of the Sexes 2 had a pretty diverse cast.

I think Battle of the Sexes easily had the best cast for reasoing just view this video of the premiere: [url=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tvY5kz7DJd0]YouTube - TBOTS ep 1 part 1[/url]

[QUOTE=El Scorcho;183555]I thought, if they altered a few people on the Ruins, that could've been one of the best casts also. Don't get me wrong, that was an all star cast, but I think it would've added a lot of drama if Cara replaced Ibis on the Champions team. Ibis didn't bring anything to that challenge. Replacing Syrus would've been cool too because, just like Ibis he just didn't bring any drama and hardly had any confessionals at all.[/QUOTE] I love seeing old faces return, so Ibis and Syrus were welcome additions in my book. Ibis brought a good deal of drama in the episode she was unfortunately sent home in. Syrus didn't bring any drama but definitely show that "Big Sy" still has it in him when he took out Adam in their Ruins. You are absolutely right, though, about adding Cara to the mix - she would have stirred up a lot of ****. I'm sure Susie and her would have gone against Johnny in an Inferno III flashback... it also would have been interesting to see how Susie's role would have changed on the champions team. Having said that, I don't really like Cara. :D

Mixing in old with new is a great idea but that's if the old is willing to return.