The Challenge: Favorite/Fantasy Casts

[QUOTE=Ch@llengeFan;333805]Green team would get smoked and the politics are way too complicated. People on the show get real stressed out with the Duel format. [B]This would have people losing their minds[/B].[/QUOTE] ...And that's a bad thing?

[QUOTE=Debut Album;333835]...And that's a bad thing?[/QUOTE] Depends on who you ask. Some people prefer prior challenges with more freedom and some prefer the newer ones where people feel the pressure of the house more.

The Duel 3 ( As Realistic as possible) Cast- Men- CT- ( Best Real Worlder/ Challenger Everrrrrr) Dustin- ( Funny and entertaining) Kenny- ( Great player and brings some viewers) Trey- ( Give him a second chance) Marlon- ( Repersents guys from Portland) Rob- ( Bit boring but why not) Leroy- ( Great) Frank- ( CRAZY and CRAZY and just won) Zach- ( Great and came off a win) Dunbar- ( Ok) Broone- ( When well he do one) Wes- ( *** But good entertainment) Women- Cara Maria- ( My favorite challenge contestant ever) Laurel- ( Everyone Loves Her) Evlynne- ( Challenge MVP) Heather- ( Sweat Heart) Nany- ( Crazy and Emotional) Ashley- ( Just came off of a win) Trishelle- ( Great) Nia- ( Repersents Portland for the girls) Marie- ( Crazy and Good entertanment) Luara- ( Loved Her During St. Thomas) Kelly Ann- (she was going to do the last season but got removed) Diem- ( Love Her and hope she will do one sence she beat cancer again Substitution - Men- Nate- ( I think he deserves a second chance) Mike- ( OK) Johnny- ( Hate him but great player) Women- Jasmine- (CRAZY) Devyn- ( Worst challenge contestant but extremely funny) Pricilla- ( Not Sure if she 21 yet but she would be entertaining if she is)

The Challenge: Battlegrounds 14 Pairs each consist of a winner and a challenger. Cast Winners- Kenny Johnny Evan Zach Frank Mark Brad Evlynne Paula Camila Katie Jodi Ashley Sam Challengers- CT Leroy Ty Dustin Knight Nate Rob Cara Maria Laurel Diem Marie Nany Kelly Ann Jonna Pairs would be pick by a competition that the winners compete in. Winner get first choice and so on. Examples of pairs: {Zach (Winner) and Cara Maria (Challenger)} {Evlynne (Winner) and CT (Challenger)}

[QUOTE=Ch@llengeFan;333840]Depends on who you ask. Some people prefer prior challenges with more freedom and some prefer the newer ones where people feel the pressure of the house more.[/QUOTE] I would prefer a challenge where they had Freedom but would still have the Pressure of the game looming on them.

[QUOTE=netkpr21;333899]The Duel 3 ( As Realistic as possible) Cast- Men- CT- ( Best Real Worlder/ Challenger Everrrrrr) Dustin- ( Funny and entertaining) Kenny- ( Great player and brings some viewers) Trey- ( Give him a second chance) Marlon- ( Repersents guys from Portland) Rob- ( Bit boring but why not) Leroy- ( Great) Frank- ( CRAZY and CRAZY and just won) Zach- ( Great and came off a win) Dunbar- ( Ok) Broone- ( When well he do one) Wes- ( *** But good entertainment) Women- Cara Maria- ( My favorite challenge contestant ever) Laurel- ( Everyone Loves Her) Evlynne- ( Challenge MVP) Heather- ( Sweat Heart) Nany- ( Crazy and Emotional) Ashley- ( Just came off of a win) Trishelle- ( Great) Nia- ( Repersents Portland for the girls) Marie- ( Crazy and Good entertanment) Luara- ( Loved Her During St. Thomas) Kelly Ann- (she was going to do the last season but got removed) Diem- ( Love Her and hope she will do one sence she beat cancer again Substitution - Men- Nate- ( I think he deserves a second chance) Mike- ( OK) Johnny- ( Hate him but great player) Women- Jasmine- (CRAZY) Devyn- ( Worst challenge contestant but extremely funny) Pricilla- ( Not Sure if she 21 yet but she would be entertaining if she is)[/QUOTE] Nice cast for the most part, but Devyn is in way the worst. Not without taking Casey and Naomi into account.

[QUOTE=Fresh Meat;333919]Nice cast for the most part, but Devyn is in way the worst. Not without taking Casey and Naomi into account.[/QUOTE] Pst and Shavoun and Katelynn. I wouldn't even place Devyn in that top five, she wasn't THAT sucky.

Completely unrealistic cast for the Duel 3 although everyone has done a challenge. Adam Larson Dan Setzler Theo Darrell Derrick Kosinski CT Brad Wes Evan Johnny CJ Ty Leroy Zach Frank Trey Susie Veronica Rachel Jillian Evelyn Paula Jenn Kelly Anne Sarah Laurel Theresea Emily Camilla Ashley Jemmye Nany

This is my ideal realistic cast, Cutthroat II Girls Jemmye - NOLA Sahar - NOLA KellyAnne - Sydney Ashlee - NOLA Ashley - DC Cooke - Las Vegas Nany - Las Vegas Naomi - Las Vegas Ayiiia - Cancun Devyn - Brooklyn Averey - Portland Nia - Portland Marie - St Thomas Laurel - Fresh Meat II Guys Ryan - NOLA Knight - NOLA Preston - NOLA Ty - DC CT - Paris Frank - San Diego Jordan - Portland Marlon - Portland Johnny - Portland Swift - St Thomas JD - Brooklyn Wes - Austin Kenny - Fresh Meat Dustin - Las Vegas Issac - Sydney

Here's what I would kind of like to see. Why don't they break up the best alliance ever (JEK) and put them with separate teams in Cutthroat? Watch them have to create teams and compete against each other. It also gives the rest of the cast the opportunity to turn on them because they won't be stacked together. Also, they should cast "like" people. People that are comparable in some way. For example [B]Girls[/B] Elite: Emily (DC), Rachel (Campus Crawl) & Laurel (Fresh Meat II) Alternate: Evelyn (Fresh Meat) Long Time Losers: Sarah (Brooklyn), Aneesa (Chicago) & Jenn (Denver) Alternate: Diem (Fresh Meat)...all good competitors that have reached finals Unproven Athletes: Cooke (Vegas 2), Nia (Portland) & Ashlee (NOLA2) Alternate: Theresa (Fresh Meat 2). All college-plus athletes that haven't competed or won in Theresa's case Small but Fiesty: Katie (The Quest), Jasmine (Cancun) & Jillian (X-Treme) Alternate: Ruthie (Hawaii)...all small but either have won or have shown they'll at least fight to be there. I'm sure there's more good examples. Good competitors that excel or should in finals: Paula (Key West), Ashley (San Diego 2) & Jonna (Cancun) Alternate: Cara Maria (Fresh Meat)...self explanatory [B]Guys[/B] Won Multiple Times: Landon (Philadelphia), Derrick (X-Treme) & Darrell (Campus Crawl) Alternate: Abram (South Pacific) New Potential Stars: Zach (San Diego 2), Ty (DC) & Leroy (Vegas 2) Alternate: Some Portland Guy that is Athletic (Marlon?) Long Time Losers: Tyrie (Denver), Danny (Austin) & Adam (Paris) Alternates: Ryan (Fresh Meat)...I didn't include CT just because he's tough to include in this group of losers Won Once: Frank (Las Vegas), Nehemiah (Austin) & Dunbar (Sydney) Alternates: Randy (San Diego) or Wes (Austin) I'd also love to see if they could get "Blast from the Past" for both....Mallory (Paris), Christena (South Pacific), Holly (Latin America), Roni (Northern Trail), Elka (Boston), Dan (Northern Trail), Kelfa (Down Under), Randy (San Diego-also fits here), Colin (Hawaii), etc...Mark Long could probably also fit there So, I guess teams like Team Evan: Rachel, Aneesa, Nia, Katie, Jonna, Landon, Zach, Adam & Nehemiah Team Kenny: Emily, Sarah, Cooke, Jillian, Ashley, Derrick, Ty, Tyrie & Frank Team Johnny: Laurel, Jenn, Ashlee, Jasmine, Paula, Darrell, Leroy, Danny & Dunbar

[QUOTE=kvm1977;334580]Here's what I would kind of like to see. Why don't they break up the best alliance ever (JEK) and put them with separate teams in Cutthroat? Watch them have to create teams and compete against each other. It also gives the rest of the cast the opportunity to turn on them because they won't be stacked together.[/QUOTE] I would love that to happen. I like the JEK alliance but I have always wanted to see them compete against each other throughout the game and not only in the final. I believe that would bring excellent ratings. I liked the different categories to created there, not so much the cast, but the idea is great.

[QUOTE=mario21jorge;334584]I liked the different categories to created there, not so much the cast, but the idea is great.[/QUOTE] Yeah, I'm very open about other types of categories or other people. Just kind of did it off the top of my head. I tried to include new & old but probably had more "older cast" members since those are the ones I prefer.

I thought about this last night. I think it would be cool of they did old school vets (those who appeared on challenges before freshmeat 1), new school vets ( those who.appeared on challenges after freshmeat 1) and new school challengers (those who only.appeared on one challenge after fm2 or never done a challenge) teams of 10 My ideal cast.would be: Old school vets: Mark Derrick Abram CT Darrell Rachel Veronica Tina Coral Trishelle New School Vets Johnny Evan Kenny CJ Tyler Laurel Cara Maria Diem Sarah Paula New school challengers: Frank Knight Zach 2 new people Jemmye Mckenzie Devyn 2 new people

Rivals II (male/female partners) Johnny/Rachel Kenny/Theresa Wes/Cara Maria Frank S/Nany Ty/Katie Dunbar/KellyAnne Abram/Tina Vinny/Mandi Tyler/Laurel Frank R/Tori Brad/Casey Evan/Veronica CT/Coral Derrick/Beth

Battle of the Exes II 1) Wes/KellyAnne (in my dreams)... 2) Laurel Stucky/CT 3) Derrick K/Casey Cooper 4) Susie Meister/Timmy Beggy 5) Melinda Stolp/Danny Jamieson 6) Frank Roesseler/Jillian Zoboroski 7) Alton Williams/Sarah Rice 8) Trishelle Cannatella/Steven Hill 9) Coral Smith/Abram Boise 10) Jonna Mannion/Zach Nichols 11) Laura Waller/Trey Weatherholz or Marie Roda/Robb Schriber 12) Ryan Kehoe/Davis Mallory 13) new couple involving Portland duo 14) Ashley/Mike Manning OR Battle of the Best Friends (needs a better name, but whatevs.) Girls Cara Maria/Laurel Susie/Sarah (I'd rather see Cara Z, but I doubt she'll come back) Katie/Trishelle Joi/Averey Veronica/Rachel Emily/Camila Carley/Ev Guys Kenny/Evan Frank/Zach Leroy/Mike Marlon/Jordan (?) CT/Adam Johnny/Tyler Wes/Danny Or if I could recast BOTS Fresh Meat Carley Cara Maria Brandon Kenny DC Ashley Emily Mike Ty Austin Melinda Danny Wes Johanna Sydney KellyAnne Cohutta Dunbar Ashli St Thomas Marie Laura Trey Robb Las Vegas (2002) Irulan Trishelle Steven Trishelle Las Vegas (2010) Mike Dustin Heather Marter Nany Real World: San Diego (hybrid team) Zach Ashley Brad Robin Or if there was a Ruins 2... Champions Frank S. Zach Wes Tyler Kenny Evan Derrick Abram Carley Paula Camila Katie Rachel R. Ev Ashley K. Sam Challengers CT Adam Luke Ty Danny Derek C. Robb Dustin Z. Marie Nany Diem Laurel Emily S. Cara Maria Emilee F. Melinda Challengers

Battle of the Season 3 This is kinda unrealistic, but basically same as BOTS 2 but with "Seasons" as the Challenge Seasons on which they exclusively appeared on. None of these people have been on another team's "challenge" before. Hopefully I didn't mess this up. It took a while. Team BOTS 3 [All rookies] Ashley (RW: Washington DC) Averey (RW: Portland) Swift (RW: Saint Thomas) Ryan (RW: Brooklyn) Team BOTS 2 Frank S. (RW: San Diego [2011]) Laura (RW: Saint Thomas) Nany (RW: Las Vegas [2011]) Trey (RW: Saint Thomas) Team Rivals Laurel (Fresh Meat 2) Leroy (RW: Las Vegas [2011]) Theresa (Fresh Meat 2) Tyler (RW: Key West) Team Duel 2 Brittani (RW: Hollywood) Derek (RR: Viewers' Revenge) Diem (Fresh Meat) Isaac (RW: Sydney) Team Island Cohutta (RW: Sydney) Colie (RW: Denver) Dan (RR: Viewers' Revenge) KellyAnne (RW: Sydney) Team Battle of the Sexes 2 Frank R. (RW: Las Vegas [2002]) Kina (RR: X-Treme) Theo (RR: Maximum Velocity Tour) Veronica (RR: Semester at Sea) Team Extreme Challenge Emily (RR: USA 2) Jamie (RW: New Orleans [2000]) Susie (RR: Down Under) Syrus (RW: Boston)

Cutthroat 2. Team Gold. Frank(San Diego 2) Derrick(X-Treme) Ty(DC) Chet(Brooklyn) Dan(Viewers Revenge) Devyn(Brooklyn) Mckenzie(New Orleans 2) Jonna(Cancun) Melinda(Austin) Kellyanne(Sydney) Team Platinum Abram(South Pacific) CJ(cancun) Dustin(Las Vegas 2) Leroy(Las Vegas 2) Knight(New Orleans 2) Marie(St Thomas) Joi(Portland) Ashley(San Diego 2) Jasmine(Cancun) Emily(DC) Team Diamond Swift(St Thomas) Davis(Denver) Jordan(Portland) Landon(Philedelphia) Cohutta(Sydney) Nany(Las Vegas 2) Latoya(St Thomas) Rachel(Campus Crawl) Lacey(Austin) Coral(Back to New York)

[QUOTE=RobbioRobbio;334699]Rivals II (male/female partners) Derrick/Beth[/QUOTE] They could plan their strategy in Polish and no one would understand them. I like it.

The Challenge: The Island 2 The Challengers: Adam Royer Ashley Kelsey C.J Koegel Averey Tressler Dunbar Flinn Devyn Simone Dustin Zito Joi Niemeyer Isaac Stout Nany Gonzalez Johnny Reilly Naomi Defensor Jordan Wiseley Sarah Rice The Veterans: Abram Boise Aneesa Ferriera Darrel Taylor Coral Smith Chris Tamburello Katie Doyle Kenny Santucci Mallory Snyderr Steven Hill Melinda Stolp Shane Landrum Rachel Robinson Wes Bergmann Susie Miester Location: Greek Islands Format: The Ruins

Dunbar Flinn Sarah Rice Wouldn't they be veterans?

[QUOTE=wutzrenzi;335102]Dunbar Flinn Sarah Rice Wouldn't they be veterans?[/QUOTE] He went by season date rather than amount of challenges. I presume he stopped at either Denver or Key West

[QUOTE=Npresh24;335084]The Challenge: The Island 2 The Challengers: Adam Royer Ashley Kelsey C.J Koegel Averey Tressler Dunbar Flinn Devyn Simone Dustin Zito Joi Niemeyer Isaac Stout Nany Gonzalez Johnny Reilly Naomi Defensor Jordan Wiseley Sarah Rice The Veterans: Abram Boise Aneesa Ferriera Darrel Taylor Coral Smith Chris Tamburello Katie Doyle Kenny Santucci Mallory Snyderr Steven Hill Melinda Stolp Shane Landrum Rachel Robinson Wes Bergmann Susie Miester Location: Greek Islands Format: The Ruins[/QUOTE] So why isn't this just called "The Ruins 2"?

[QUOTE=alaskak94;335130]So why isn't this just called "The Ruins 2"?[/QUOTE] In theory similar to The Ruins but in the beginning of the challenge, 2 Girls and Boys from each team will get voted off. After that the game starts. The Teams are more like tribes in survivor rather than Teams except that they are in more favorable living environment.

I would really like to see Leroy, Naomi, Mike, Andrew, Emily, Ashley L., Brittni, Isaac, Dunbar, Svetlana, and Ayiiia on the next challenge.

Attempted to make a realistic format/cast The Challenge Battle of the Sexes 3 Bringing back the scoreboard. The male and female at the bottom of the scoreboard after each challenge will be automatically sent into the elimination round. The only way for a person at the bottom of the scoreboard to avoid an elimination round would to be the top male or female performer for that challenge. The top 3 male and female performers will create the inner circle in which they will each vote in a male and female to face the person already going to elimination. Four male and female competitors will make it to the final. Susie (Down Under) Rachel (Campus Crawl) Jillian (X-Treme) Paula (Key West) Kelly Anne (Sydney) Sarah (Brooklyn) Emilee (Cancun) Laurel (Fresh Meat 2) Theresea (Fresh Meat 2) Emily (DC) Camilla (Spring Break) Jemmye (New Orleans 2) Nany (Vegas 2) Ashley (San Diego 2) Couple of Portland Girls Darrell (Campus Crawl) CT (Paris) Landon (Philadelphia) Nehemiah (Austin) Wes (Austin) Evan (Fresh Meat) Tyler (Key West) Johnny (Key West) Chet (Brooklyn) CJ (Cancun) Ty (DC) Leroy (Las Vegas 2) Frank (San Diego 2) Zach (San Diego 2) Trey (St. Thomas) Portland Guy

Your girls team is pretty good if this concept were to ever come back but I feel like your guys team is way to stacked haha. If you want the girls to actually have a shot the guys team needs to be dumbed down a bit with some weak players to make it at least a bit fair.

[B]Cutthroat 2:[/B] Paula Laurel Diem Aneesa Sarah Emily Camila Kelly Anne Marie Nany Jemmye Janelle Heather M. Ashlee Nia Wes Leroy Evan Johnny CT Isaac Frank Zach Pete Chet Dustin Noor Ty CJ Johnny (Portland)

[QUOTE=Ch@llengeFan;335658]Attempted to make a realistic format/cast The Challenge Battle of the Sexes 3 Bringing back the scoreboard. The male and female at the bottom of the scoreboard after each challenge will be automatically sent into the elimination round. The only way for a person at the bottom of the scoreboard to avoid an elimination round would to be the top male or female performer for that challenge. The top 3 male and female performers will create the inner circle in which they will each vote in a male and female to face the person already going to elimination. Four male and female competitors will make it to the final. Susie (Down Under) Rachel (Campus Crawl) Jillian (X-Treme) Paula (Key West) Kelly Anne (Sydney) Sarah (Brooklyn) Emilee (Cancun) Laurel (Fresh Meat 2) Theresea (Fresh Meat 2) Emily (DC) Camilla (Spring Break) Jemmye (New Orleans 2) Nany (Vegas 2) Ashley (San Diego 2) Couple of Portland Girls Darrell (Campus Crawl) CT (Paris) Landon (Philadelphia) Nehemiah (Austin) Wes (Austin) Evan (Fresh Meat) Tyler (Key West) Johnny (Key West) Chet (Brooklyn) CJ (Cancun) Ty (DC) Leroy (Las Vegas 2) Frank (San Diego 2) Zach (San Diego 2) Trey (St. Thomas) Portland Guy[/QUOTE] You'll have to replace at least Jillian if you want your cast to be realistic.

Realistic Veterans Vs Rookies Cast The Challenge: The Ruins 2 (Season 24) The Rookies: Anastasia Miller Adam Royer Ashlee Feldman Frank Sweeney Averey Tressler Isaac Stout Carley Johnson Johnny Reilly Joi Niemeyer Pete Connolly Nany Gonzalez Robb Schrieber Naomi Defensor Zach Nichols The Veterans Chet Cannon Camila Nakagawa Dustin Zito Diem Brown Chris Tamburello Emily SChromm Johnny ********* Jonna Mannion Leroy Garret Paula Meronek Tyler Duckworth Sarah Rice Wes Bergmann Theresa Gonzalez

[QUOTE=Npresh24;336100]Realistic Veterans Vs Rookies Cast The Challenge: The Ruins 2 (Season 24) [/QUOTE] An ALternatice to the previous cast The Veterans: Chris Tamburello Camila Nakagawa Dustin Zito Diem Brown Johnny ********* Emily Schromm Leroy Garret Jonna Mannion Tyler Duckworth Paula Meronek Ty Ruff Sarah Rice Wes Bergmann Theresa Gonzalez The Rookies: Adam Royer Ashlee Feldman Frank Sweeney Averey Tressler Isaac Stout Devyn Simone Johnny Reilly Carley Johnson Pete Connolly Lacey Buehler Trey Weatherholtz Nany Gonzalez Zach Nichols Naomi Defensor