The Challenge: Favorite/Fantasy Casts

Free Agents 2 Males: 1. CT 2. Wes 3. Johnny 4. Zach 5. Corey 6. Brian 7. Mark 8. Alton 9. Jordan 10. Dustin 11. Leroy 12. CJ 13. Landon 14. Derrick 15. Darrell Females: 1. Rachel 2. Laurel 3. Emily 4. Cooke 5. Aneesa 6. KellyAnne 7. Jenny 8. Nany 9. Ashley (ExPlosion) 10. Camila 11. Ashley (DC) 12. Devyn 13. Paula 14. Nia 15. Averey

Since we were discussing this in the FA speculation thread, feel free to add a season summary lol (not realistic obviously): Duel 3: Males: CT Landon Derrick Abram Darrell Johnny Bananas Evan Mark Wes Jordan Zach Johnny R. Dustin Leroy Frank S. Females: Evelyn Rachel Laurel Ruthie Emily S. Sarah Camila KellyAnne Cooke Svetlana Brittini Kimberly Theresa Aneesa

My unrealistic fantasy Duel 3 cast: Males: Mark CT Wes Johnny Zach CJ Jordan Corey Brian Darrell Landon Abe Dustin Scott Brad Simon Females: Rachel Ev Laurel Emily Cooke Svetlana Averey Nia Jenny Ashlee Ashley L Susie Coral Beth Veronica Nany

If BMP asked fans to create a new challenge format and theme for Season 26 and you submitted an answer... what would it be?

[QUOTE=Livewitpeace;398001]If BMP asked fans to create a new challenge format and theme for Season 26 and you submitted an answer... what would it be?[/QUOTE] Isn't that the same thing you guys write about in this thread anyways? Fantasy cast?

[QUOTE=Livewitpeace;398001]If BMP asked fans to create a new challenge format and theme for Season 26 and you submitted an answer... what would it be?[/QUOTE] I've always hoped they put up a poll of everyone who says yes to the challenge and get all the fans to vote on it.

The Challenge: Free Agents I put together a cast for Free Agents of competitors who have never won a challenge. 01. Adam King 02. Sarah Rice 03. Danny Jamieson 04. Mandi Moyer 05. Luke Wolfe 06. Cara Maria Sorbello 07. CJ Koehel 08. Ruthie Alcaide 09. Vinny Foti 10. KellyAnne Judd 11. Isaac Stout 12. Theresa Gonzalez 13. Tyrie Ballard 14. Ayiiia Elizarras 15. Cohutta Grindstaff 16. LaToya Jackson 17. Leroy Garrett 18. Ashley Lindley 19. Johnny Reilly 20. Heather Cooke 21. Brandon Swift 22. Nany Gonzalez 23. Ty Riff 24. Aneesa Ferriera 25. Robb Schrieber 26. Nia Moore 27. Jordan Wiseley 28. Jonna Mannion

[QUOTE=El Scorcho;398111]The Challenge: Free Agents I put together a cast for Free Agents of competitors who have never won a challenge. 01. Adam King 02. Sarah Rice 03. Danny Jamieson 04. Mandi Moyer 05. Luke Wolfe 06. Cara Maria Sorbello 07. CJ Koehel 08. Ruthie Alcaide 09. Vinny Foti 10. KellyAnne Judd 11. Isaac Stout 12. Theresa Gonzalez 13. Tyrie Ballard 14. Ayiiia Elizarras 15. Cohutta Grindstaff 16. LaToya Jackson 17. Leroy Garrett 18. Ashley Lindley 19. Johnny Reilly 20. Heather Cooke 21. Brandon Swift 22. Nany Gonzalez 23. Ty Riff 24. Aneesa Ferriera 25. Robb Schrieber 26. Nia Moore 27. Jordan Wiseley 28. Jonna Mannion[/QUOTE] No way Leroy is losing with this weak cast

[QUOTE=Challenge 17;398112]No way Leroy is losing with this weak cast[/QUOTE] CJ, Cohutta, Jordan, and Johnny R. would give Leroy a run for his money. I see them doing better in a final than Leroy.

[QUOTE=Livewitpeace;398115]CJ, Cohutta, Jordan, and Johnny R. would give Leroy a run for his money. I see them doing better in a final than Leroy.[/QUOTE] Lol I love Cohutta but he's not beating Leroy in a final, Jordan & CJ might and as for Johnny R we will wait and see

[QUOTE=Challenge 17;398117]Lol I love Cohutta but he's not beating Leroy in a final, Jordan & CJ might and as for Johnny R we will wait and see[/QUOTE] If BMP was to do a final where you are solely individual the whole time (the way it should be in a individual game) I don't think Leroy would win. I believe Jordan and CJ, especially Jordan would be faster runners and better at any puzzles than Leroy.

Jordan the win for sure! Does anyone else think that Jordan is not liked by many male cast members?

[QUOTE=Fresh Meat;397849]I enjoyed the Exes cast, but that season didn't really do for me aside from establish Emily as a breakout star and finally seeing CT and Diem back.[/QUOTE] Yeah and seeing mark and rachel comeback was a higlight for me, but the season was pretty simple.

Cutthroat 2 Location Rome Italy East vs west vs international based on where the real world season was [COLOR="#FF0000"]East Ashley L Emily Coral Paula Sarah Scott Johnny Mike M Tyler Chet [/COLOR][COLOR="#00FFFF"]West Jenny Nany Cooke Averey Ashley K Zach Jordan Cory Leroy Thomas [/COLOR][COLOR="#00FF00"]International Jonna LaToya KellyAnne Mallory Trisha Simon Cohutta CT CJ Robb [/COLOR]

(I hear the AYTO cast would love to do a challenge and i think they got good ratings if i'm right) [COLOR="#00FF00"]Challenge: Bananas CT Darrell Mark Tyler Laurel Cara Maria Emily Camila Rachel[/COLOR] [COLOR="#FFFF00"]Are You The One: Ethan CT Ryan Dre Adam Shanley Jessica Amber Kayla Brittany[/COLOR] (I think the challenge would clean house, and maybe some other reality tv-shows would do them do :P)

The Duel 3 Location Tokyo Japan realistic for the most part [COLOR="#FF0000"][B]Jordan[/B][/COLOR] [COLOR="#FF0000"][B]Hailey[/B][/COLOR] [COLOR="#00FF00"][B]Leroy[/B][/COLOR] [COLOR="#00FF00"][B]Sarah[/B][/COLOR] [COLOR="#0000FF"][B]Zach[/B][/COLOR] [COLOR="#0000FF"][B]Jonna[/B][/COLOR] [COLOR="#FFFF00"][B]Dustin[/B][/COLOR] [COLOR="#FFFF00"][B]Jenny[/B][/COLOR] [B][B]Derrick[/B][/B] [B][B]Rachel [/B][/B] [COLOR="#800080"][B]Cory[/B][/COLOR] [COLOR="#800080"][B]Nany [/B][/COLOR] [COLOR="#00FFFF"][B]Darrell[/B][/COLOR] [COLOR="#00FFFF"][B]Jenn[/B][/COLOR] [COLOR="#008000"][B]CT[/B][/COLOR] [COLOR="#008000"][B]KellyAnne[/B][/COLOR] [COLOR="#000080"][B]Wes[/B][/COLOR] [COLOR="#000080"][B]Ashlee[/B] [/COLOR] [COLOR="#A9A9A9"][B]Thomas[/B][/COLOR] [COLOR="#A9A9A9"][B]LaToya[/B][/COLOR] [COLOR="#B22222"][B]CJ[/B][/COLOR] [COLOR="#B22222"][B]Emily[/B] [/COLOR] [COLOR="#0099ff"][B]Mark[/B][/COLOR] [COLOR="#0099ff"][B]Aneesa [/B][/COLOR] [COLOR="#ff3366"][B]Tyler[/B][/COLOR] [COLOR="#ff3366"][B]Camilla[/B][/COLOR]

Battle of the Seasons 3 - no one from BOTS 2 [COLOR=#A52A2A][B]Road Rules: Campus Crawl[/B][/COLOR] [COLOR=#A52A2A]Darrell Taylor Kendal Sheppard Rachel Robinson Shane Landrum[/COLOR] [COLOR=#A9A9A9][B]Real World: Paris[/B][/COLOR] [COLOR=#A9A9A9]CT Tamburello Leah Gillingwater Mallory Snyder Simon Sherry-Wood[/COLOR] [COLOR=#008000][B]Real World: San Diego[/B][/COLOR] [COLOR=#008000]Brad Fiorenza Cameran Eubanks Randy Barry Robin Hibbard[/COLOR] [COLOR=#FF0000][B]Real World: Sydney[/B][/COLOR] [COLOR=#FF0000]Ashli Robson Cohutta Grindstaff Isaac Stout KellyAnne Judd[/COLOR] [COLOR=#0000FF][B]Real World: Washington DC[/B][/COLOR] [COLOR=#0000FF]Ashley Lindley Emily Schromm Mike Manning Ty Ruff[/COLOR] [COLOR=#800080][B]Real World: Las Vegas [Hybrid][/B][/COLOR] [COLOR=#800080]Arissa Hill Frank Roessler Heather Cooke Leroy Garrett [/COLOR] [COLOR=#40E0D0][B]Real World: Portland[/B][/COLOR] [COLOR=#40E0D0]Averey Tressler Jordan Wiseley Marlon Williams Nia Moore[/COLOR] [COLOR=#FFD700][B]Real World: Ex-Plosion[/B][/COLOR] [COLOR=#FFD700]Cory Wharton Jamie Larson Jenny Delich Thomas Buell[/COLOR]

[QUOTE=alaskak94;398943]Battle of the Seasons 3 - no one from BOTS 2 [COLOR=#a52a2a][B]Road Rules: Campus Crawl[/B][/COLOR] [COLOR=#a52a2a]Darrell Taylor Kendal Sheppard Rachel Robinson Shane Landrum[/COLOR] [COLOR=#a9a9a9][B]Real World: Paris[/B][/COLOR] [COLOR=#a9a9a9]CT Tamburello Leah Gillingwater Mallory Snyder Simon Sherry-Wood[/COLOR] [COLOR=#008000][B]Real World: San Diego[/B][/COLOR] [COLOR=#008000]Brad Fiorenza Cameran Eubanks Randy Barry Robin Hibbard[/COLOR] [COLOR=#ff0000][B]Real World: Sydney[/B][/COLOR] [COLOR=#ff0000]Ashli Robson Cohutta Grindstaff Isaac Stout KellyAnne Judd[/COLOR] [COLOR=#0000ff][B]Real World: Washington DC[/B][/COLOR] [COLOR=#0000ff]Ashley Lindley Emily Schromm Mike Manning Ty Ruff[/COLOR] [COLOR=#800080][B]Real World: Las Vegas [Hybrid][/B][/COLOR] [COLOR=#800080]Arissa Hill Frank Roessler Heather Cooke Leroy Garrett [/COLOR] [COLOR=#40e0d0][B]Real World: Portland[/B][/COLOR] [COLOR=#40e0d0]Averey Tressler Jordan Wiseley Marlon Williams Nia Moore[/COLOR] [COLOR=#ffd700][B]Real World: Ex-Plosion[/B][/COLOR] [COLOR=#ffd700]Cory Wharton Jamie Larson Jenny Delich Thomas Buell[/COLOR][/QUOTE] I love this cast! Campus Crawl would be my favorite to win. It would be awesome to see that group do a challenge together some time.

While watching "The Wire" I came up with a new idea for a challenge. It's called "MTV The Challenge: Prison I: Cops vs. Criminals" If I would be in charge of promoting it, I would make this season 15 episodes long and hyping it as the "BIGGEST CHALLENGE EVER" since it will have 40 contestants who made the biggest Impact on the real world / Road Rules / Fresh Meat and The Challenge. Rules: - First they think it's an individual challenge again and they party the first night thinking what the prison theme will be. On the first challenge, their task will be to choose between two doors "Cops or Criminals" and the first challenge is like "Bottleneck Stampede" and the first/fastest ones there discover that this is indeed a team challenge and they can decide if they want someone on their team or not by fighting with them so they don't get behind the door. The last two guys and the last girls can decide where they go and are automatically the team leader for the next challenge and save from the Elimination round "Prison". - The other must win the daily challenge to stay safe and the losing team needs to decide who they want to send to prison. However, the chosen one can choose his oppenent. - Individual bank accounts just like the Ruins where they also can lose their Money or multiple it by going into elimination. - Winning the final - 250'000 $ will split between the remaining members which means 400'000 $ are up for grabs on this challenge. - To avoid a Desaster like on Ruins after the mid season (7 episodes) everybody is eligible going into the Elimination except the leaders. Cast (not really possible though) Cops / Criminals CT / Abram Darrell or Brad / Johnny D Cohutta / Cory Brian Williams / Wes Tyrie / Knight or Johnny R CJ / Zach Jordan / Thomas Leroy / Isaac Frank Roessler / Trey Mike Manning / Ty Emily / Nia Sarah / Laurel Cara Maria / Nany Hailey / Jenny Devyn / Jasmine Diem / Susie Ashley K / Kelly Anne Averey / Jemmye One of the Heathers from Las Vegas 2 / Rachel Robinson Averey / Aneesa Robin / Jenn This challenge will however be the farewell to Road Rules and the old era of the challenger.

If you could change the theme of any challenge but keep the cast what would you change? I'd change cutthroat to free agents (minus Eric & Shauvon) and I think it would be cool The Challenge: Free Agents Location Prague Czech Republic 01. Derrick 02. Sarah 03. Brandon 04. Emily 05. Tyler 06. Paula 07. Dunbar 08. Theresa 09. Abram 10. Katie 11. TY 12. Emilee 13. Johnny 14. Mandi 15. Vinny 16. Tori 17. Luke 18. Laurel 19. Dan 20. Camilla 21. Chet 22. Ayyia 23. Derek 24. Caramaria 25. Brad 26. Melinda 27. JD 28. Jenn

[QUOTE=Challenge 17;399078]If you could change the theme of any challenge but keep the cast what would you change? I'd change cutthroat to free agents (minus Eric & Shauvon) and I think it would be cool The Challenge: Free Agents Location Prague Czech Republic 01. Derrick 02. Sarah 03. Brandon 04. Emily 05. Tyler 06. Paula 07. Dunbar 08. Theresa 09. Abram 10. Katie 11. TY 12. Emilee 13. Johnny 14. Mandi 15. Vinny 16. Tori 17. Luke 18. Laurel 19. Dan 20. Camilla 21. Chet 22. Ayyia 23. Derek 24. Caramaria 25. Brad 26. Melinda 27. JD 28. Jenn[/QUOTE] Thats a good one and really the only one. I mean I liked Cutthroat but I wouldn't wanna see it done again. I'm just not crazy about team challenges anymore. I like pairs and individuals. We need to see more individual challenges too imo or a pair challenge that puts Rookies and Veterans together of the same *** by random draw and then half way through the challenge they switch partners again by random draw but keep it Rookies/Veterans but it would just shake up the politics.

[QUOTE=Livewitpeace;399090]Thats a good one and really the only one. I mean I liked Cutthroat but I wouldn't wanna see it done again. I'm just not crazy about team challenges anymore. I like pairs and individuals. We need to see more individual challenges too imo or a pair challenge that puts Rookies and Veterans together of the same *** by random draw and then half way through the challenge they switch partners again by random draw but keep it Rookies/Veterans but it would just shake up the politics.[/QUOTE] So who do you think the final 4 would be idk how Much people make the final in free agents so I'm guessing 4

[QUOTE=Challenge 17;399094]So who do you think the final 4 would be idk how Much people make the final in free agents so I'm guessing 4[/QUOTE] Emily, Laurel, Sarah & Tori Abram, Brad, Johnny & Tyler

[QUOTE=Livewitpeace;399090]Thats a good one and really the only one. I mean I liked Cutthroat but I wouldn't wanna see it done again. I'm just not crazy about team challenges anymore. I like pairs and individuals. We need to see more individual challenges too imo or a pair challenge that puts Rookies and Veterans together of the same *** by random draw and then half way through the challenge they switch partners again by random draw but keep it Rookies/Veterans but it would just shake up the politics.[/QUOTE] So you wouldn't change the theme of any other season? Like even if you could switch a few people to fit the format?

[QUOTE=Challenge 17;399101]So you wouldn't change the theme of any other season? Like even if you could switch a few people to fit the format?[/QUOTE] I would definitely change The Island for a Duel. The cast was so good, and I feel it was a waste. Just look at the cast: Johnny Kenny Derrick Abram Cohutta Dan Dave Ryan Dunbar Tyrie Kellyanne Jenn Robin Johanna Evelyn Ashli Paula Rachel Colie Tonya The only changes in the cast I would make are Ryan/Tyrie/Dunbar/Dave for Brad/Darrell/Isaac/Wes. The girls cast is good, maybe change Colie for someone like Susie or Diem.

[B][U]Cutthroat 2[/U][/B] [B][COLOR="#DAA520"]Gold Team (5+ Challenges)[/COLOR][/B] Johnny Bananas (RW: Key West) Mark (RR: First Adventure) Derrick (RR: X-Treme) Evan (Fresh Meat) Kenny (Fresh Meat) Paula (RW: Key West) Jenn (RW: Denver) Sarah (RW: Brooklyn) Rachel (RR: Campus Crawl) Evelyn (Fresh Meat) [B][COLOR="#A9A9A9"]Silver Team (2-4 Challenges)[/COLOR][/B] CJ (RW: Cancun) Leroy (RW: B2 Las Vegas) Zach (RW: B2 San Diego) Frank (RW: B2 San Diego) Jordan (RW: Portland) Kelly-Anne (RW: Sydney) Emily (RW: DC) Nany (RW: B2 Las Vegas) Jillian (RR: X-Treme) Laurel (Fresh Meat 2) [COLOR="#8B4513"][B]Bronze Team (0-1 Challenges)[/B][/COLOR] Bronne (RW: Cancun) Scott (RW: Brooklyn) Ryan (RW: Brooklyn) Cory (RW: Ex-Polision) Noor (Fresh Meat 2) Ashley (RW: DC) Ashlee (RW: B2 New Orleans) Cooke (RW: B2 Las Vegas) Joi (RW: Portland) Arielle (RW: Ex-Polision)

[QUOTE=GDInstall;399022]While watching "The Wire" I came up with a new idea for a challenge. It's called "MTV The Challenge: Prison I: Cops vs. Criminals" If I would be in charge of promoting it, I would make this season 15 episodes long and hyping it as the "BIGGEST CHALLENGE EVER" since it will have 40 contestants who made the biggest Impact on the real world / Road Rules / Fresh Meat and The Challenge. Rules: - First they think it's an individual challenge again and they party the first night thinking what the prison theme will be. On the first challenge, their task will be to choose between two doors "Cops or Criminals" and the first challenge is like "Bottleneck Stampede" and [B]the first/fastest ones there discover that this is indeed a team challenge and they can decide if they want someone on their team or not by fighting with them so they don't get behind the door[/B].[B] The last two guys and the last girls can decide where they go and are automatically the team leader for the next challenge and save from the Elimination round "Prison". [/B] - The other must win the daily challenge to stay safe and the losing team needs to decide who they want to send to prison. However, the chosen one can choose his oppenent. - Individual bank accounts just like the Ruins where they also can lose their Money or multiple it by going into elimination. - Winning the final - 250'000 $ will split between the remaining members which means 400'000 $ are up for grabs on this challenge. - To avoid a Desaster like on Ruins after the mid season (7 episodes) everybody is eligible going into the Elimination except the leaders. Cast (not really possible though) Cops / Criminals CT / Abram Darrell or Brad / Johnny D Cohutta / Cory Brian Williams / Wes Tyrie / Knight or Johnny R CJ / Zach Jordan / Thomas Leroy / Isaac Frank Roessler / Trey Mike Manning / Ty Emily / Nia Sarah / Laurel Cara Maria / Nany Hailey / Jenny Devyn / Jasmine Diem / Susie Ashley K / Kelly Anne Averey / Jemmye One of the Heathers from Las Vegas 2 / Rachel Robinson Averey / Aneesa Robin / Jenn This challenge will however be the farewell to Road Rules and the old era of the challenger.[/QUOTE] I'm so confused...

Exes 2: [COLOR="#FF0000"]Wes & KellyAnne[/COLOR] [COLOR="#FF8C00"]Danny & Melinda[/COLOR] [COLOR="#FFD700"]Brian & Jenny[/COLOR] [COLOR="#00FF00"]Thomas & Jamie[/COLOR] [COLOR="#00FFFF"]Corey & Ashley[/COLOR] [COLOR="#008000"]Johnny R & Averey[/COLOR] [COLOR="#0000FF"]Cohutta & Nany[/COLOR] [COLOR="#800080"]Dustin & Heather[/COLOR] [COLOR="#808080"]Pete & Jenn[/COLOR] [COLOR="#EE82EE"]Mike & Ashley[/COLOR] [COLOR="#000000"]Knight & Jemmmye[/COLOR] [COLOR="#D3D3D3"]Johnny & Casey[/COLOR] [COLOR="#B22222"]Jordan & Nia[/COLOR] [COLOR="#FFA07A"]CT & Anastasia[/COLOR] [COLOR="#008080"]Abe & Coral[/COLOR] [COLOR="#FFFF00"]Leroy & Theresa[/COLOR]

Cutthroat 2 (Discounting the upcoming challenge because I haven't spoiled it for myself) Team Diamond - Multiple Challenge Wins Darrell Taylor Derrick Kosinski Jodi Weatherton Landon Lueck Mark Long Rachel Robinson Susie Meister Tori Fiorenza Veronica Portillo Wes Bergmann Team Platinum - 1 Challenge Win Alton Williams Brad Fiorenza CT Tamburello Camila Nakagawa Cara Zavaleta Coral Smith Emily Schromm Frank Sweeney Kina Dean Zach Nichols Team Gold - Challengers Brittini Sherrod Cory Wharton Dustin Zito Jenny Delich Jordan Wiseley Laurel Stucky Leroy Garrett Nany Gonzalez Nia Moore Robb Schreiber

Fresh Meat 3 Location Tokyo Japan Comment on final 4 [COLOR="#FF0000"]Abram & Arielle[/COLOR] [COLOR="#00FF00"]Derrick & Baya[/COLOR] [COLOR="#0000FF"]Darrell & Averey[/COLOR] [COLOR="#FFFF00"]Dustin & Jenny[/COLOR] [B]Jordan & Ashlee[/B] [COLOR="#808080"]Zach & Ashley M[/COLOR] [COLOR="#0099ff"]Leroy & Trisha[/COLOR] [COLOR="#800080"]Sarah & Cory [/COLOR] [COLOR="#00FFFF"]KellyAnne & Brian[/COLOR] [COLOR="#008000"]Mallory & Scott[/COLOR] [COLOR="#000080"]Cooke & Mike M[/COLOR] [COLOR="#B22222"]Jenn & Will[/COLOR] [COLOR="#ff3366"]Aneesa & Simon[/COLOR] [COLOR="#FFD700"]Jonna & Ryan L[/COLOR]