The Challenge: Unpopular Opinions

10051 posts / 0 new
Last post

How are Robb & Trey better than Dustin? Johnny R. has never seen an elimination yet so who knows how good he really is & CJ has only been on 2 seasons never making a final.

I wasn't impressed by Trey at all until Rivals 2, he did really good on his short run during that season. As for Robb, I'm basing it off his Instagram pictures, he is enormous right now and could probably take Dustin out no problem at all. Johnny Reilly performed great on Free Agents, beating Bananas by thirty minutes up the mountain. Dustin hasn't done anything impressive in my books, though I accept I might be a little bias since I'm not a fan of his. 

How are Robb & Trey better than Dustin? Johnny R. has never seen an elimination yet so who knows how good he really is & CJ has only been on 2 seasons never making a final.

I'd take Robb & Trey over Dustin. Robb is huge, and Trey... well... I'm biased <3

Trey did pretty good on Rivals 2, a lot better than I expected. 

How are Robb & Trey better than Dustin? Johnny R. has never seen an elimination yet so who knows how good he really is & CJ has only been on 2 seasons never making a final.
CJ was far more impressive on seasons, why do you think Cancun beat Vegas so much?

Actually, Vegas and Cancun both won a whole two challenges on BOTSeasons. Half the time it was San Diego who won, and we all know why Cancun was safe the entire time.

I'd choose Trey over Robb, and Dustin over Robb as well. But I'm partial to one because one is gorgeous to look at.

I'd choose Trey over Robb, and Dustin over Robb as well. But I'm partial to one Trey because one Trey is gorgeous to look at.

Fixed that for you.

I think Dustin has shown merit as a competitor it's just that he has bad luck I think.

I'd choose Trey over Robb, and Dustin over Robb as well. But I'm partial to one Trey because one Trey is gorgeous to look at.

Fixed that for you.

Thank you! And I agree, Dustin (among other people) need more time on the Challenge to get better.

I'd choose Trey over Robb, and Dustin over Robb as well. But I'm partial to one Trey because one Trey is gorgeous to look at.

Fixed that for you.

Thank you! And I agree, Dustin (among other people) need more time on the Challenge to get better.

Anytime!

It was stupid, but nobody wanted to face easy in a gauntlet

everyone would have beat him...  they acted like because he is big that they can't beat him. Brad beat him in pole wrestle. Easy sucks.

They didn't know what the gauntlets were, for all they knew it could have been reverse tug of war, something where being much bigger matters.

I really doubt Easy could beat Evan in anything. Brad beat him in something that cater to a bigger person. 

It was stupid, but nobody wanted to face easy in a gauntlet

everyone would have beat him...  they acted like because he is big that they can't beat him. Brad beat him in pole wrestle. Easy sucks.

They didn't know what the gauntlets were, for all they knew it could have been reverse tug of war, something where being much bigger matters.

I really doubt Easy could beat Evan in anything. Brad beat him in something that cater to a bigger person. 


Strength matters a lot more then size in pole wrestle. Eric is huge in reverse fig of war or something similar Eric has a advantage

I don't remember Darrell being that bad of a swimmer. He wasn't Wes or anything but he definitely wasn't Brandon or Leroy. 

Yes because is the epitome of a swimmer. wtf??

Well first of all, your response has no subject. I assume you forgot the word "Wes". And yes, as far as swimmers go on the show, as much as I don't like the guy, Wes is probably the best. So yes, Darrell is not on Wes's level, but he still isn't a bad swimmer. What was your problem with that concept? 

Well it sounds like you're saying much more than that.

Uh not really. Someone made the comment that Alton is the only black guy who was a good swimmer. My point was that while Darrell is no Wes (a great swimmer), he is still pretty good and not comparable to Brandon or Leroy who are considered bad swimmers. 

That person was me Smile and it was more of a question than a comment, cuz i asked other people, "unless if there's anyone else."

I think Dustin is the third best behind Frank and Zach from the new generation. He and Heather did well on Exes, he gave a great performance on Seasons, and a meh one on FA from going home so early, but losing to Frank is nothing to be ashamed of. There's no way Johnny R, Trey, Robb, and Leroy have shown to be better than him. Jordan gave a pretty bad performance on FA as well.

I don't think Danny & Melinda should be in the "worst competitors ever" conversation.

 

JamieFire
Anonymous's picture

I don't think Danny & Melinda should be in the "worst competitors ever" conversation.

 


I dont think they are the worst by any means but.....

They are pretty terrible.

I think Dustin has shown merit as a competitor it's just that he has bad luck I think.

Yes, I agree.

And lets not talk like CJ is bad bc he hasnot seen finale yet. First time he let Landon win and second time imo he had pretty weak team. Comparing to Vegas or SD, it is ipressive that they won missions.

I don't think Danny & Melinda should be in the "worst competitors ever" conversation.

 

I agree with this. Danny has so much potential to be decent, as well as Melinda. Danny was so close to beating Jillian and Pete on FM2, and if Danny had kept his mouth shut on Gauntlet III, he might have survived to make it into his first finale.

I don't think he's ever been the problem on team Challenges either. Melinda as well.

Melinda is the best girl from Austin, best than Rachel and Johanna IMO, both of whom are winners. She really surprised me on her elimination against Emily. 

Danny's most impressive moment by far was getting one point on Darrell in oh ring.

Only reason I put Danny on there is because he's been on six challenges, hasn't won ONE elimination and he's never been to a final, I'm not the best at math, but that's pretty bad stats right there lollol same with Melinda

Only reason I put Danny on there is because he's been on six challenges, hasn't won ONE elimination and he's never been to a final, I'm not the best at math, but that's pretty bad stats right there lollol same with Melinda

The same stats as Tyrie, except that Tyrie has only lost five eliminaitons. Danny has lost 6. Danny vs Tyire in any type of elimination will be grand. 0-5 vs 0-6.

CJ never let Landon win. He & his partner just took forever on their first puzzle because they are not very smart lol. By the time they finished the puzzle Landon & Carely had already finished the whole elimination.

CJ never let Landon win. He & his partner just took forever on their first puzzle because they are not very smart lol. By the time they finished the puzzle Landon & Carely had already finished the whole elimination.

Yeah because they had a deal.... nobody is that stupid.

I do not know much if he did let him win but everybody have told me that. Plus they are not that stupid, they could have just skipped that. Its really seems like CJ had enough with this Wes BS and stayed there to solve that puzzle forever.

Where is proof of this deal. I watched Freshmeat 2 not long ago & don't remember CJ volunteering to just go home. The only deal they had in place was for whoever came back from exile would make sure Wes went home.

Where is proof of this deal. I watched Freshmeat 2 not long ago & don't remember CJ volunteering to just go home. The only deal they had in place was for whoever came back from exile would make sure Wes went home.

It was easy to see he threw it, you can skip puzzles, if he had been trying he would have skipped the puzzle....

I think your assuming this why have none of the cast members ever mentioned this before? Why was TJ making fun of them when they finally finished & CJ act surprised Landon was already gone. Pinkrose do you have any info on this or know the full story.

I think your assuming this why have none of the cast members ever mentioned this before? Why was TJ making fun of them when they finally finished & CJ act surprised Landon was already gone. Pinkrose do you have any info on this or know the full story.

CJ isn't a idiot there's no way he wouldn't even consider skipping the puzzle....

Yeah, CJ threw it so Landon could master the course and really find the right/perfect strategy. I'm pretty sure it was mentioned on previous podcasts.

Alright thanks Freshmeat that's all I was looking for was some concrete information he threw it. I just can't ever understand why people do that.

If i was on the challenges i would never throw them without a really strong reason.

Yes now everyone thinks he sucks

Pages