The Challenge: Favorite/Fantasy Casts

16759 posts / 0 new
Last post

The Inferno 4

Good Guys:
1. Dustin Zito (Las Vegas 2)
2. Johnny Reilly (Portland)
3. Thomas Buell (Ex-Plosion)
4. Trey Weatherholtz (St. Thomas)
5. Cohutta Grindstaff (Sydney)
6. Leroy Garrett (Las Vegas 2)
7. Ryan Malaty (AYTO: Hawaii)
8. Dario Medrano (AYTO: Puerto Rico)
1. Jessica McCain (Portland)
2. Jenna Compono (Ex-Plosion)
3. Averey Tressler (Portland)
4. Laura Waller (St. Thomas)
5. Heather Marter (Las Vegas 2)
6. Nicole Zanatta (Skeletons)
7. Brittany Baldasseri (AYTO: Hawaii)
8. Christina LeBlanc (AYTO: Puerto Rico)

Bad *****:
1. Jordan Wiseley (Portland)
2. Zach Nichols (San Diego 2)
3. Cory Wharton (Ex-Plosion)
4. Brian Williams (Ex-Plosion)
5. Robb Schreiber (St. Thomas)
6. Bruno Bettencourt (Skeletons)
7. Chris Scali (AYTO: Hawaii)
8. Layton Jones (AYTO: Puerto Rico)
1. Nany Gonzalez (Las Vegas 2)
2. Camila Nakagawa (Spring Break Challenge)
3. Sylvia Elsrode (Skeletons)
4. Marie Roda (St. Thomas)
5. Nia Moore (Portland)
6. Jenny Delich (Ex-Plosion)
7. Shanley McIntee (AYTO: Hawaii)
8. Jessica Andreatta (AYTO: Puerto Rico)

I tried to give a realistic cast of people who would do a challenge still

Another challenge I drafted

Battle of the Seasons 3

Skeletons:
1. Bruno Bettencourt
2. Tony Raines
3. Violetta Millerman
4. Sylvia Elsrode

Ex-Plosion:
1. Brian Williams
2. Cory Wharton
3. Jenny Delich
4. Ashley Mitchell

Portland:
1. Johnny Reilly
2. Marlon Williams
3. Nia Moore
4. Avery Tressler

St. Thomas:
1. Robb Schreiber
2. Trey Weatherholtz
3. Marie Roda
4. LaToya Jackson

San Diego:
1. Nate Stodghill
2. Zach Nichols
3. Alexandra Grovere
4. Priscilla Mendez

Las Vegas
1. Leroy Garrett
2. Adam Royer
3. Heather Marter
4. Heather Cooke

Puerto Rico:
1. Dario Medrano
2. Anthony Bartolette
3. Jessica Andreatta
4. Christina LeBlanc

Hawaii:
1. Ryan Malaty
2. Chris Tolleson
3. Shanley McIntee
4. Kayla Lusby

The Inferno 4 Good Guys: 1. Dustin Zito (Las Vegas 2) 2. Johnny Reilly (Portland) 3. Thomas Buell (Ex-Plosion) 4. Trey Weatherholtz (St. Thomas) 5. Cohutta Grindstaff (Sydney) 6. Leroy Garrett (Las Vegas 2) 7. Ryan Malaty (AYTO: Hawaii) 8. Dario Medrano (AYTO: Puerto Rico) 1. Jessica McCain (Portland) 2. Jenna Compono (Ex-Plosion) 3. Averey Tressler (Portland) 4. Laura Waller (St. Thomas) 5. Heather Marter (Las Vegas 2) 6. Nicole Zanatta (Skeletons) 7. Brittany Baldasseri (AYTO: Hawaii) 8. Christina LeBlanc (AYTO: Puerto Rico) Bad *****: 1. Jordan Wiseley (Portland) 2. Zach Nichols (San Diego 2) 3. Cory Wharton (Ex-Plosion) 4. Brian Williams (Ex-Plosion) 5. Robb Schreiber (St. Thomas) 6. Bruno Bettencourt (Skeletons) 7. Chris Scali (AYTO: Hawaii) 8. Layton Jones (AYTO: Puerto Rico) 1. Nany Gonzalez (Las Vegas 2) 2. Camila Nakagawa (Spring Break Challenge) 3. Sylvia Elsrode (Skeletons) 4. Marie Roda (St. Thomas) 5. Nia Moore (Portland) 6. Jenny Delich (Ex-Plosion) 7. Shanley McIntee (AYTO: Hawaii) 8. Jessica Andreatta (AYTO: Puerto Rico) I tried to give a realistic cast of people who would do a challenge still

Pretty good, but it'd be much better without AYTO, same for your BOTS.

So AshtonMartin wants a lot of old time viewers to quit watching.  These kinds of casts will officially end the show

I made it realistic a lot of old schoolers won't do it especially enough to make a 4 person team. I've been watching for a while now and personally this is a cast I would enjoy and probably a lot of people too. Alot of the long time viewers have already stopped watching so it makes no difference to me that you and the few old school watchers aren't happy.

I made it realistic a lot of old schoolers won't do it especially enough to make a 4 person team. I've been watching for a while now and personally this is a cast I would enjoy and probably a lot of people too. Alot of the long time viewers have already stopped watching so it makes no difference to me that you and the few old school watchers aren't happy.

See your Inferno 4 cast bullshit

How long have you been watching?  What was your first season live?

If something like this happens the show ends--especially with the AYTO bullshit.  Even most newer viewers want them out

Another challenge I drafted

Battle of the Seasons 3

Skeletons:
1. Bruno Bettencourt
2. Tony Raines
3. Violetta Millerman
4. Sylvia Elsrode

Ex-Plosion:
1. Brian Williams
2. Cory Wharton
3. Jenny Delich
4. Ashley Mitchell

Portland:
1. Johnny Reilly
2. Marlon Williams
3. Nia Moore
4. Avery Tressler

St. Thomas:
1. Robb Schreiber
2. Trey Weatherholtz
3. Marie Roda
4. LaToya Jackson

San Diego:
1. Nate Stodghill
2. Zach Nichols
3. Alexandra Grovere
4. Priscilla Mendez

Las Vegas
1. Leroy Garrett
2. Adam Royer
3. Heather Marter
4. Heather Cooke

Puerto Rico:
1. Dario Medrano
2. Anthony Bartolette
3. Jessica Andreatta
4. Christina LeBlanc

Hawaii:
1. Ryan Malaty
2. Chris Tolleson
3. Shanley McIntee
4. Kayla Lusby


Horrible cast two are the one teams seriously, because fans reacted so well to four of those losers they will love when 8 are on it

I made it realistic a lot of old schoolers won't do it especially enough to make a 4 person team. I've been watching for a while now and personally this is a cast I would enjoy and probably a lot of people too. Alot of the long time viewers have already stopped watching so it makes no difference to me that you and the few old school watchers aren't happy.

See your Inferno 4 cast bullshit

How long have you been watching?  What was your first season live?

If something like this happens the show ends--especially with the AYTO bullshit.  Even most newer viewers want them out

Explain to me how it was bullshit? I get you don't like the AYTO, neither do I for that matter, but is it all bullshit? Or just the AYTO?

I made it realistic a lot of old schoolers won't do it especially enough to make a 4 person team. I've been watching for a while now and personally this is a cast I would enjoy and probably a lot of people too. Alot of the long time viewers have already stopped watching so it makes no difference to me that you and the few old school watchers aren't happy.

See your Inferno 4 cast bullshit

How long have you been watching?  What was your first season live?

If something like this happens the show ends--especially with the AYTO bullshit.  Even most newer viewers want them out

Explain to me how it was bullshit? I get you don't like the AYTO, neither do I for that matter, but is it all bullshit? Or just the AYTO?

It is all bullshit...you don't ignore 5/6ths of the seasons and all of Road Rules.

BMP ****** up long ago by limiting themselves--the last thing that should be done is to limit it even more.

I wouldn't even consider watching either season--and I've never missed one--there's a problem in that even if some 15 year olds can't see it

Cohutta's the only person that is even before a 2010 debut--if I need to say more to explain why this is stupid then there's a bigger problem than even i see 

I made it realistic a lot of old schoolers won't do it especially enough to make a 4 person team. I've been watching for a while now and personally this is a cast I would enjoy and probably a lot of people too. Alot of the long time viewers have already stopped watching so it makes no difference to me that you and the few old school watchers aren't happy.

See your Inferno 4 cast bullshit

How long have you been watching?  What was your first season live?

If something like this happens the show ends--especially with the AYTO bullshit.  Even most newer viewers want them out

Explain to me how it was bullshit? I get you don't like the AYTO, neither do I for that matter, but is it all bullshit? Or just the AYTO?

It is all bullshit...you don't ignore 5/6ths of the seasons and all of Road Rules.

BMP ****** up long ago by limiting themselves--the last thing that should be done is to limit it even more.

I wouldn't even consider watching either season--and I've never missed one--there's a problem in that even if some 15 year olds can't see it

Cohutta's the only person that is even before a 2010 debut--if I need to say more to explain why this is stupid then there's a bigger problem than even i see 

Oh there's a problem alright..and the problem is you *****ing over a FANTASY cast list. There is nothing wrong with either cast(Save for AYTO) and if you don't like it. Tough. Make your own **** cast.

I made it realistic a lot of old schoolers won't do it especially enough to make a 4 person team. I've been watching for a while now and personally this is a cast I would enjoy and probably a lot of people too. Alot of the long time viewers have already stopped watching so it makes no difference to me that you and the few old school watchers aren't happy.

See your Inferno 4 cast bullshit

How long have you been watching?  What was your first season live?

If something like this happens the show ends--especially with the AYTO bullshit.  Even most newer viewers want them out

Explain to me how it was bullshit? I get you don't like the AYTO, neither do I for that matter, but is it all bullshit? Or just the AYTO?

It is all bullshit...you don't ignore 5/6ths of the seasons and all of Road Rules.

BMP ****** up long ago by limiting themselves--the last thing that should be done is to limit it even more.

I wouldn't even consider watching either season--and I've never missed one--there's a problem in that even if some 15 year olds can't see it

Cohutta's the only person that is even before a 2010 debut--if I need to say more to explain why this is stupid then there's a bigger problem than even i see 

Oh there's a problem alright..and the problem is you *****ing over a FANTASY cast list. There is nothing wrong with either cast(Save for AYTO) and if you don't like it. Tough. Make your own **** cast.

Fantasy casts always create conversation--you create a stupid one many people will point it out.  Doesn't mean you can't write down the stupidity

The Duel 3 Cohutta(Sydney) Greg(Hollywood) Ryan(Brooklyn) Bronne(Cancun) Andrew(DC) Ryan(New Orleans 2) Dustin(Las Vegas 2) Nate(San Diego 2) Robb(St Thomas) Marlon(Portland) Brian(Ex-plosion) Bruno(Skeletons) Ashili(Sydney) Brianna(Hollywood) Devyn(Brooklyn) Ayiiia(Cancun) Erika(DC) Ashlee(New Orleans 2) Heather(Las Vegas 2) Ashley(San Diego 2) Latoya(St Thomas) Joi(Portland) Jenny(Ex-plosion) Madison(Skeletons)

The Duel 3 Cohutta(Sydney) Greg(Hollywood) Ryan(Brooklyn) Bronne(Cancun) Andrew(DC) Ryan(New Orleans 2) Dustin(Las Vegas 2) Nate(San Diego 2) Robb(St Thomas) Marlon(Portland) Brian(Ex-plosion) Bruno(Skeletons) Ashili(Sydney) Brianna(Hollywood) Devyn(Brooklyn) Ayiiia(Cancun) Erika(DC) Ashlee(New Orleans 2) Heather(Las Vegas 2) Ashley(San Diego 2) Latoya(St Thomas) Joi(Portland) Jenny(Ex-plosion) Madison(Skeletons)

Exhibit B

I made it realistic a lot of old schoolers won't do it especially enough to make a 4 person team. I've been watching for a while now and personally this is a cast I would enjoy and probably a lot of people too. Alot of the long time viewers have already stopped watching so it makes no difference to me that you and the few old school watchers aren't happy.

See your Inferno 4 cast bullshit

How long have you been watching?  What was your first season live?

If something like this happens the show ends--especially with the AYTO bullshit.  Even most newer viewers want them out

Explain to me how it was bullshit? I get you don't like the AYTO, neither do I for that matter, but is it all bullshit? Or just the AYTO?

It is all bullshit...you don't ignore 5/6ths of the seasons and all of Road Rules.

BMP ****** up long ago by limiting themselves--the last thing that should be done is to limit it even more.

I wouldn't even consider watching either season--and I've never missed one--there's a problem in that even if some 15 year olds can't see it

Cohutta's the only person that is even before a 2010 debut--if I need to say more to explain why this is stupid then there's a bigger problem than even i see 

Oh there's a problem alright..and the problem is you *****ing over a FANTASY cast list. There is nothing wrong with either cast(Save for AYTO) and if you don't like it. Tough. Make your own **** cast.

Fantasy casts always create conversation--you create a stupid one many people will point it out.  Doesn't mean you can't write down the stupidity

That's fine but don't be so unecessary about it. If you(or anyone else) don't like the casts being created and feel like you want to state that fine  but don't sit here and take it places that it doesn't need to go. You went of talking about BMP's limiting casting(which I agree with) and all of that is unecessary. It's just fantasy. It's never going to happen. No need to get so aggresivley pissy about it. People can put whomever they want on their lists. Nobody has to be included.

 

Edit: After re-watching Exes 2 I realized, NO ARE YOU THE ONE unless they are the only ones left lol-- so I made some changes to my dream Season 27 cast!

 

THE CHALLENGE: BATTLE OF THE SEASONS II

 

This season on The Challenge, 8 of the most infamous Real World seasons arrive in Bali, Indonesia to compete for $350,000. Each week these teams will compete in a series of challenges. The winning team will be named Power Team and be safe from this season's elimination called The Arena. The last-place team must automatically go in to The Arena and their opponent will be chosen by the Power Team. However, only one male and one female will go in to The Arena and represent their team, which means teams must make the decision on who to send in. If they cannot decide, the Power Team will choose for them. If a team looses their players in The Arena, they'll become a 2 person team. 

This seasons twist-- the losing teams will go head to head each week in an online series called, The Challenge: Exiled. Each week the losers will compete in a Fresh Meat style Exile. It'll be a 3 team face-off with the last place team going home each week until the final double elimination where the winners will return to the game and compete in the final challenge and possibly re-join their remaining teammates. 

In the end, only 12 players will compete in the final on a glacier. The first place team wins $250,000, 2nd place wins $70,000, 3rd place wins $30,000, and 4th place wins nothing! So who will and be crowned the best season ever?! 

 

TEAM D.C.

For me to include this team I have really made progress with the whole having a fresh cast and casting people who haven't done a challenge yet, but with Seasons you can do that. I LOVE this team! It's so fresh and they have potential to really shake up the game. I think Mike and Erika would do it. According to you guys both of them have expressed interest in doing a challenge. 

IMAGE(http://i58.tinypic.com/2dkehcl.jpg)

 

TEAM EX-PLOSION

It's pretty obvious why I choose these 4. Brian, Cory, and Jenny were very popular cast members this season and since they weren't on Exes they have to be on Seasons. As for the second girl, I wanted to put Jamie but Jamie without Thomas would be weird. Ashley was just a much better fit and she's crazy-- good for promos. 

IMAGE(http://i58.tinypic.com/2wrhoqs.jpg)

 

TEAM LAS VEGAS

I wouldn't really consider this a repeat team because its actually a new season compared to Seasons 1 having a hybrid of the two which was a mistake IMO. Plus, this seems to be a well liked season so you have to have them. Out of all the cast members from this season this is the perfect 4. Nany is memorable, so is Dustin and Leroy. And many people including myself want to see Heather come back. However, I'm not sure if Heather would return but I can only hope considering the fact she won't just be working with Dustin. If not Cooke can forsure fill her spot. She seems to be interested in doing another one. 

IMAGE(http://i60.tinypic.com/50629x.jpg)

 

TEAM OLD SCHOOL 

Anyway you can stretch Bananas onto a challenge right? Well this is how considering a Team Key West is nearly impossible. Not many Old Schoolers believe it or not are coming back. These were the 4 that I think would and so here you go. I think it's a great mix because Bananas & Wes have that rivalry. Along with Aneesa & Trishelle and I don't think Wes & Theresa like wach other. If Wes decides not to do next season, Mark or even Darrell could easily fill his spot although they are Road Rules. 

IMAGE(http://i58.tinypic.com/8y6hxe.jpg)

 

TEAM PORTLAND

This is the perfect Team Portland. While some of them may get along and others don't I think not only will this team have conflict but could possibly win. 

IMAGE(http://i61.tinypic.com/2929npz.jpg)

 

TEAM SAINT THOMAS

I wasn't really keen on having a repeat team, but this was all I was really left with and that's okay. Robb & Marie were great on Seasons. LaToya brings some fire and well Swift brings jokes. I would use Trey but I wanted to make the team a little different from the first one. 

IMAGE(http://i60.tinypic.com/11ugso7.jpg)

 

TEAM SKELETONS

One thing I noticed with the first Seasons was they put a lot of couples or flings together, so Tony & Madison it is. I could do Bruno & Sylvia but to me Violetta would bring more to The Challenge but we'll see as the season goes on. 

IMAGE(http://i60.tinypic.com/1zpo8wz.jpg)

 

TEAM SYDNEY

This team should have been on the first Seasons and it should be on the second seasons. I just got rid of Isaac and put Cohutta because that's the better choice. 

IMAGE(http://i60.tinypic.com/i1btpk.jpg)

Love that cast! It's got a good mix of regulars and newbies(and some who haven't been seen in awhile).

Swith Erika with Ashley and Heather with Cooke and you have a bad *** cast!

I never even watched D.C. but I heard about Ashley being crazy. However, isn't she sick or something? I doubt she pull a Diem and show up to The Challenge. 

And 9 times out of 10 Cooke would end up being cast but to me Heather brings a better balance to things and evens the teams out. 

I still think most of Ex-Plosion would look good in navy colors.

I say switch out wes/Kenny with Landon I heard somewhere he expressed intrest in doing one more challenge

I say switch out wes/Kenny with Landon I heard somewhere he expressed intrest in doing one more challenge

Recently? 

I say switch out wes/Kenny with Landon I heard somewhere he expressed intrest in doing one more challenge

I heard from here that Landon declined Free Agents, which was fairly recent...

I say switch out wes/Kenny with Landon I heard somewhere he expressed intrest in doing one more challenge

I heard from here that Landon declined Free Agents, which was fairly recent...

That would have been awesome if Landon was on FA. 

I say switch out wes/Kenny with Landon I heard somewhere he expressed intrest in doing one more challenge

I heard from here that Landon declined Free Agents, which was fairly recent...

Landon on Free Agents would have been amazing

Wow. I didn't know Landon was asked for Free Agents. Would he have been good on it? Depends IMO. If he prevents Backpack from winning then yeah he would've been amazing on it. If not then glad he wasn't on.

Free Agents 2 Robb(St Thomas) Ty(DC) Jordan(Portland) Dustin(Las Vegas 2) Cory(Ex-plosion) Will(Hollywood) Bruno(Skeletons) Cj(Cancun) Zach(San Diego 2) Brian(Ex-plosion) Tony(Skeletons) Eric(New Orleans 2) Ryan(Brooklyn) Dunbar(Sydney) Nany(Las Vegas 2) Jenny(Ex-plosion) Kellyanne(Sydney) Devyn(Brooklyn) Marie(St Thomas) Ashlee(New Orleans 2) Cooke(Las Vegas 2) Brianna(Hollywood) Violetta(Skeletons) Ashley M(Ex-plosion) Ashley(San Diego 2) Erika(DC) Nicole(Skeletons) Avery(Portland)

Battle of the Seasons 3

Skeletons-Tony/Nicole/Violetta/Bruno

Ex-plosion-Cory/Jenny/Ashley M/Brian

Portland-Jordan/Avery/Nia/Marlon

Sydney-Cohutta/Kellyanne/Trisha/Dunbar

DC-Mike/Ashley/Emily/Ty

Hollywood-Will/Britnii/Brianna/Greg

Old-School-Brad/Beth/Coral/Ace

Road Rules-Adam/Susie/Cara/Abram

Fresh Meat-Pete/Carley/Linette/Johnnie

 

The Ruins 2: Old School Vs New School Old-School Abram(South Pacific) Mark(Road Rules 1) Backpack(Key West) Darrel(Campus Crawl) Brad(San Diego 1) CT(Paris) Wes(Austin) Aneesa(Chicago) Beth(Los Angeles) Coral(Back to New York) Rachel(Campus Crawl) Veronica(Semester at Sea) Susie(Down Under) Robin(San Diego 1) New School Frank(San Diego 2) Jordan(Portland) Leroy(Las Vegas 2) Zach(San Diego 2) CJ(Cancun) Cory(Ex-plosion) Bruno(Skeletons) Emily(DC) Nicole(Skeletons) Sarah(Brooklyn) Nany(Las Vegas 2) Cooke(Las Vegas 2) Jenny(Ex-plosion) Ashley(San Diego 2)

The Ruins 2: Old School Vs New School

Old-School

Abram(South Pacific)
Mark(Road Rules 1)
Backpack(Key West)
Darrel(Campus Crawl)
Brad(San Diego 1)
CT(Paris)
Wes(Austin)

Aneesa(Chicago)
Beth(Los Angeles)
Coral(Back to New York)
Rachel(Campus Crawl)
Veronica(Semester at Sea)
Susie(Down Under)
Robin(San Diego 1)

New School

Frank(San Diego 2)
Jordan(Portland)
Leroy(Las Vegas 2)
Zach(San Diego 2)
CJ(Cancun)
Cory(Ex-plosion)
Bruno(Skeletons)

Emily(DC)
Nicole(Skeletons)
Sarah(Brooklyn)
Nany(Las Vegas 2)
Cooke(Las Vegas 2)
Jenny(Ex-plosion)
Ashley(San Diego 2)


I really like this cast, it is pretty balanced.
Also did it kill you a little inside to put bananas on a cast?

Battle of the Seasons 3:

 

Xtreme:

Derrick

Patrick

Kina

Jodi

 

Campus Crawl:

Kendal

Rachel

Darrell

Shane

 

South Pacific:

Cara

Christena

Abram

Dave

 

Viewers Revenge:

Tori

Angel

Dan

Derek

 

Las Vegas:

Cooke

Irulan

Alton

Leroy

 

DC:

Emily

Callie

Josh

Mike

 

San Diego:

Robin

Ashley

Brad

Zach

 

Fresh Meat:

Evelyn

Laurel

Kenny

Noor

Pages