The Challenge: What Ifs

2827 posts / 0 new
Last post

What If theresa and camila don't get distracted with jonna/jasmine by throwing dirt and getting dirt thrown in their elevator. I wonder if that tangent was enough to keep them out of first place since they were already close to paula and Evelyn, time wise. Would've been perfect if they won and the whole house threw ev and paula against  Laurel 

What If theresa and camila don't get distracted with jonna/jasmine by throwing dirt and getting dirt thrown in their elevator. I wonder if that tangent was enough to keep them out of first place since they were already close to paula and Evelyn, time wise. Would've been perfect if they won and the whole house threw ev and paula against  Laurel 

Nah. Paula and Ev would never see an elimination as long as they don't came last. Bananas, Kenny/Wes would supervise this lol.

If Coral wasn't bitten by the spider, do you think Real World would have won the Gauntlet 1 final?

If Coral wasn't bitten by the spider, do you think Real World would have won the Gauntlet 1 final?

This probably belongs in the "Unpopular Opinions" thread as well because I never did and still don't believe the spider bite story (for one thing, allergic reaction symptoms don't come and go at will like she demonstrated).  Coral was gassed before she'd gone 100 feet and needed piggy back rides so I don't think she'd have been able to complete the final.  With the 10-minute penalty rule, I think Mizz, Nathan, Norman, and Alton could still have won the final since they had fewer people than Road Rules.  Both teams made mistakes along the way but I think Real World wins.

 

If Coral wasn't bitten by the spider, do you think Real World would have won the Gauntlet 1 final?

This probably belongs in the "Unpopular Opinions" thread as well because I never did and still don't believe the spider bite story (for one thing, allergic reaction symptoms don't come and go at will like she demonstrated).  Coral was gassed before she'd gone 100 feet and needed piggy back rides so I don't think she'd have been able to complete the final.  With the 10-minute penalty rule, I think Mizz, Nathan, Norman, and Alton could still have won the final since they had fewer people than Road Rules.  Both teams made mistakes along the way but I think Real World wins.

 

I agree with this.

If Coral wasn't bitten by the spider, do you think Real World would have won the Gauntlet 1 final?

This probably belongs in the "Unpopular Opinions" thread as well because I never did and still don't believe the spider bite story (for one thing, allergic reaction symptoms don't come and go at will like she demonstrated).  Coral was gassed before she'd gone 100 feet and needed piggy back rides so I don't think she'd have been able to complete the final.  With the 10-minute penalty rule, I think Mizz, Nathan, Norman, and Alton could still have won the final since they had fewer people than Road Rules.  Both teams made mistakes along the way but I think Real World wins.

 

You better watch this:

https://youtu.be/qj2mQs3i_LA?list=PLkB0uthwbrXUORWvnoz0R63BTTUcobWXg&t=660 from 11:00 to 13:25

Also, did you miss the part where in the actual episode the medic or whatever said: "she's not breathing", no one gasses out like that.

I've watched that before (it was on before The Inferno) as well as the Gauntlet final itself and I stand by what I said.  Sarah claims that Coral had a "huge bite with striations" on her leg so why, in another bit of video during the final, did we see Coral (breathing fine, by the way) sitting with a female EMT and removing her sock to look under her toes?  If Coral really did have an allergy to spiders, why didn't production seem to be aware of it and why wasn't she carrying an Epi-Pen with her as all people who have allergic reactions are advised to do?  Each time Coral said "I can't breathe", why didn't any medical personnel help her and/or why didn't anyone from production come to her aid?  She's a challenge legend and she was arguably the face of the franchise at that time so why was nobody helping her, including her best friend (who obviously had no knowledge of this allergy situation)?  Mizz clearly believed that she just couldn't handle the rigors of the final because if he thought that she was really having a medical emergency, he would have been the first  one to help her and most likely would have stayed with her and told the other 3 guys to go on without them.

No one knew she was bit until the doctor told her. I don't think she'd be pumped full of adrenaline nor would the doctor misdiagnose her if she had hyperventilation or something.

I guess we'll just have to agree to disagree on this topic.

What if Aneesa or Theresa took out Laurel on FA

What if Aneesa or Theresa took out Laurel on FA

Theresa wins Free Agents, because nobody else would be able to stop her.

What if Aneesa or Theresa took out Laurel on FA

Theresa wins Free Agents, because nobody else would be able to stop her.

What if Aneesa or Theresa took out Laurel on FA

Theresa wins Free Agents, because nobody else would be able to stop her.

What if CM didn't fracture her hand?

What if Aneesa or Theresa took out Laurel on FA

Theresa wins Free Agents, because nobody else would be able to stop her.

What if CM didn't fracture her hand?

She still loses.

What if Aneesa or Theresa took out Laurel on FA

Theresa wins Free Agents, because nobody else would be able to stop her.

What if CM didn't fracture her hand?

I don't think CM can take Theresa out in either the puzzle or the wall. 

What if both Fresh Meats were team challenges instead of pairs
Do you guys agree with Coral that the alumni girls were way stronger?
For me I'm not sure, the alumni guys are better no contest but the girls had Katie Melinda and Johanna to slow them down. The fresh meat girls only really had Casey.

What if Aneesa or Theresa took out Laurel on FA

Theresa wins Free Agents, because nobody else would be able to stop her.

What if CM didn't fracture her hand?

I don't think CM can take Theresa out in either the puzzle or the wall. 

umm ... No .. by far laurel and Cm were the top two female competitor s on FA . With thersa coming in at third nany fourth ... And so on .... With that being said if some how laurel got eliminated and Cm hand would not have been broken ...... Cm would have won Free agents .. honestly I think it would have been like nany and laurel .. I think it would have been Ile Theresa 9 mins or even closer to Cm time

What if Aneesa or Theresa took out Laurel on FA

Theresa wins Free Agents, because nobody else would be able to stop her.

What if CM didn't fracture her hand?

I don't think CM can take Theresa out in either the puzzle or the wall. 

umm ... No .. by far laurel and Cm were the top two female competitor s on FA . With thersa coming in at third nany fourth ... And so on .... With that being said if some how laurel got eliminated and Cm hand would not have been broken ...... Cm would have won Free agents .. honestly I think it would have been like nany and laurel .. I think it would have been Ile Theresa 9 mins or even closer to Cm time

 

I thought the original question was what if Aneesa / Theresa took out Laurel and CM didn't fracture her hand, so obviously Laurel is not even in this picture. And I honestly think Theresa would beat CM. 

What if both Fresh Meats were team challenges instead of pairs Do you guys agree with Coral that the alumni girls were way stronger? For me I'm not sure, the alumni guys are better no contest but the girls had Katie Melinda and Johanna to slow them down. The fresh meat girls only really had Casey.

I think the alumni still wins. They could've dumped those three or carry them if they made it to the end somehow

FA's were for Laurel or Theresa winning tbh.

Melinda and Joahanna would be elimnanted. I doubt they would make it to the end.

What if both Fresh Meats were team challenges instead of pairs Do you guys agree with Coral that the alumni girls were way stronger? For me I'm not sure, the alumni guys are better no contest but the girls had Katie Melinda and Johanna to slow them down. The fresh meat girls only really had Casey.

I think the alumni still wins. They could've dumped those three or carry them if they made it to the end somehow


Eh true the guys on the alumni were so much better.
So even if the fresh meat got rid, of Casey they still lose especially with weaker guys like Jesse Ryan and big easy.

But what I'm saying is idk if coral was right about the alumni girls being much stronger i think Ev and Chanda could beat most of the alumni girls one on one. Plus Aviv Linette and Diem are solid .
Coral and Tonya would be the top girls for alumni with Tina being solid

What if Aneesa or Theresa took out Laurel on FA

Theresa wins Free Agents, because nobody else would be able to stop her.

What if CM didn't fracture her hand?

I don't think CM can take Theresa out in either the puzzle or the wall. 

umm ... No .. by far laurel and Cm were the top two female competitor s on FA . With thersa coming in at third nany fourth ... And so on .... With that being said if some how laurel got eliminated and Cm hand would not have been broken ...... Cm would have won Free agents .. honestly I think it would have been like nany and laurel .. I think it would have been Ile Theresa 9 mins or even closer to Cm time

cara Maria Was lagging behind in the swamp behind nany and especially theresa  even before her hand started to affect her during the dig. You have no proof she would've killed the final much less beat nany or theresa except her performance the previous season where she single handedly made Cooke lose because she was bigger dead weight than the body bags they had to drag 

 

Cara would have flopped in kayaking, but I believe she would have done well in the other parts.

What if Tyrie was in the G3 Final and avoided going against Frank in an elimination?
Do you think he would have flopped and fallen like Big Easy, since Tyrie was around 250 lbs.

I always wonder what would've happened if CT/Diem got to stay on Exes II. The whole outcome of the game would've changed. 

They probably go all the way to the final. Not sure if they would win though. It would depend on which other 2 teams are with them in the end.

What if Cooke/Heather and Averey/Nia were on Rivals 2?

What if Cooke/Heather and Averey/Nia were on Rivals 2 instead of Anastasia/Jessica and Jasmine/Theresa? 

Nia/Averey 3rd, Cooke/Heather toss up with Emily/Paula, but more 1st for Heathers IMO.

What if Cooke/Heather and Averey/Nia were on Rivals 2 instead of Anastasia/Jessica and Jasmine/Theresa? 

Nia/Averey 3rd, Cooke/Heather toss up with Emily/Paula, but more 1st for Heathers IMO.


No way they beat Emily who is elite and Paula who is very good at finals due to her endurance

Pages