The Challenge: What Ifs

2827 posts / 0 new
Last post

what if Danny went against Big Easy in the final instead of Wes. i think Danny would have won, or it would have went to three rounds. Danny is pretty muscular. he gave Darrell a fight for his money in their elimination in the Ruins.plus he was able to hold his own against Trey in wrestling. 

Please.... Danny SUCKS at everything he has ever done on these shows. He has an elmination record of 0 wins and 6 losses. Gauntlet 3 Beach brawl vs. Adam was just pathetic. Where were his muscles then? He couldn't even hold Adam back who was a lot lighter and less muscular. One of, if not the worst competitor ever on these shows in my book.

rwportland2 wrote:

What if Kenny was never banned and was partnered up with Sarah on Exes 1 instead of Vinny? Would they have won? I think they would have made the finals too

Absolutely they make the final. There wasn't a lot of heights/climbing stuff on that challenge for Kenny to be bad at, nor were there any heavy endurance challenges for Sarah to have a problem with so I doubt they would've come in last at anything. Plus, they had Johnny, Paula, Mark, etc. there to never be voted in.I think they definitely make the final but probably don't win. Kenny would've been the best guy on that show at finals by FAR, but Sarah didn't have any cardio at that point.

did she ever had cardio? 

What if the Rivals 3 Finale was a with a lot more of runnning would Jenna/Vince have won, since i think Jenna has better cardio then Sarah?  

JL81790 wrote:

rwportland2 wrote:What if Kenny was never banned and was partnered up with Sarah on Exes 1 instead of Vinny? Would they have won? I think they would have made the finals too

Absolutely they make the final. There wasn't a lot of heights/climbing stuff on that challenge for Kenny to be bad at, nor were there any heavy endurance challenges for Sarah to have a problem with so I doubt they would've come in last at anything. Plus, they had Johnny, Paula, Mark, etc. there to never be voted in.I think they definitely make the final but probably don't win. Kenny would've been the best guy on that show at finals by FAR, but Sarah didn't have any cardio at that point.

did she ever had cardio? What if the Rivals 3 Finale was a with a lot more of runnning would Jenna/Vince have won, since i think Jenna has better cardio then Sarah?  

That's pretty pretty self-explanatory question. Sarah/Bananas won because they were quicker at the checkpoints, Jenna/Vince made up time by being better runners. So obviously if there's more running, they would win. They were only seperated by like 8 minutes I believe.

Wasn't Sarah better when it came to hiking up that final mountain? 

Wasn't Sarah better when it came to hiking up that final mountain? 

Honestly didn't really pay attention too carefully so maybe lol

https://stopbeingpolite.com/2012/03/25/if-wins/

this was interesting to read.

https://stopbeingpolite.com/2012/03/25/if-wins/this was interesting to read.

We really need a new black male winner and by the way the last black girl to win was Janelle on Inferno 3. Leroy/Ty/Brandon(FM2) had so much potential but they decided to be side characters...smh

mickeyflo24 wrote:

https://stopbeingpolite.com/2012/03/25/if-wins/this was interesting to read.

We really need a new black male winner and by the way the last black girl to win was Janelle on Inferno 3. Leroy/Ty/Brandon(FM2) had so much potential but they decided to be side characters...smh

Brandon was screwed from the get go because he wasn't as athletic as Roylee or Ty. notice how he has only won two mission-challenges (one on Cutthroat and the other on FA) and both of them were group challenges. 

and why did you add the last fact of the black female challenge winner that really had nothing to do with my link... no offense. 

xHollyangel wrote:

mickeyflo24 wrote:https://stopbeingpolite.com/2012/03/25/if-wins/this was interesting to read.

We really need a new black male winner and by the way the last black girl to win was Janelle on Inferno 3. Leroy/Ty/Brandon(FM2) had so much potential but they decided to be side characters...smh

Brandon was screwed from the get go because he wasn't as athletic as Roylee or Ty. notice how he has only won two mission-challenges (one on Cutthroat and the other on FA) and both of them were group challenges. and why did you add the last fact of the black female challenge winner that really had nothing to do with my link... no offense. 

Probs jus a fun fact. Since it is interesting enough to point out.

too bad all of the black girls that they cast are jokes now & days..  except nia... and yall know how that go.

Im honestly surprised Janelle even won Inferno 3 tbh, also surprised that Shavonda & Brittini made it as far as they did.. based on their rw seasons I expected them to both be first boots on their challenge seasons ****. 

When B&M stops trying to fit stereotypes ill be happy.. like yeah i know you casting for a tv show & you need certain personality but why when it comes to black people yall choose to keep the "personailties" the same.. atleast thats how it is now.

These black dudes they cast are corny as ****. Give me someone like Greg or Will then we can talk. 

I realize that it has been said, but Wes on free agents would have been great. His rationale/strategy towards the numbers game and probability of the draw would have been great

What if Cooke wised up and did Free Agents? Does Laurel still win that season, or does the outcome change?

What if Tyrie was the replacement on bloodlines rather than Abram?

What if Cooke wised up and did Free Agents? Does Laurel still win that season, or does the outcome change?

Laurel still wins. Although I do think Cooke makes it to the final 3 though.

What if Tyrie was the replacement on bloodlines rather than Abram?

he would have won his first elimination against stephen and thomas. 'noodly arms'

What if Tyrie was the replacement on bloodlines rather than Abram?

that season would have been even more tragic than it was

70companies wrote:

What if Tyrie was the replacement on bloodlines rather than Abram?

that season would have been even more tragic than it was

Daddy DAF
Anonymous's picture

70companies wrote:

What if Tyrie was the replacement on bloodlines rather than Abram?

that season would have been even more tragic than it was

this plus i would also just turn the channel and probably not even finish bloodlines

AlwaysAMess wrote:

What if Cooke wised up and did Free Agents? Does Laurel still win that season, or does the outcome change?

Laurel still wins. Although I do think Cooke makes it to the final 3 though.

If Cooke makes the final I don't think she loses because her endurance is probably way better than Laurel but I wouldn't be surprised if Laurel tried to take her out before the final. 

That season would be maybe the greatest female cast season since The Mean Girls on Inferno 2 and the female cast of Gauntlet2/Duel. The dynamic of Cooke vs Laurel mixed in with Cara Maria. Who's side would Cara be on? I still think Laurel would win. 

What if CT and Diem stayed on Exes 2? I think Sarah would still be looking for that first win. 

Debut Album wrote:

AlwaysAMess wrote:What if Cooke wised up and did Free Agents? Does Laurel still win that season, or does the outcome change?

Laurel still wins. Although I do think Cooke makes it to the final 3 though.

If Cooke makes the final I don't think she loses because her endurance is probably way better than Laurel but I wouldn't be surprised if Laurel tried to take her out before the final. 

Agreed. Also, Cooke’s only weakness in a final is eating gross stuff, but seeing as though Free Agents’ final didn't have an eating portion, Cooke would have KILLED it. As for the elimination rounds, none of them were crapshoots and all required skill. Cooke would have done especially well in eliminations like Looper and Oppenheimer. I could actually see Cooke beating Laurel in something like Looper where endurance is a main factor.

That season would be maybe the greatest female cast season since The Mean Girls on Inferno 2 and the female cast of Gauntlet2/Duel. The dynamic of Cooke vs Laurel mixed in with Cara Maria. Who's side would Cara be on? I still think Laurel would win. 

That would've been an amazing dynamic and storyline to watch. In the end, I see Cara siding with Cooke due to Cara and Laurel having issues that season.

What if CT and Diem stayed on Exes 2? I think Sarah would still be looking for that first win.

CT and Diem staying would have totally changed the season of Exes 2 as a whole.

Just imagine Cara vs Cooke vs Laurel and Bananas vs Wes vs CT even though this sounds like Duel with the guys there's no way any of those 3 are going home early like Bananas did on the Duel.

I'm gonna get hella hate, but what if Jersey Shore came on the challenges back around Cutthroat/Rivals and they had a Real World/Road Rules team vs Jersey Shore/Fresh Meat.

The fact that Cooke would have done Free Agents if she knew it was individual... Miss her *** Sad

I'm gonna get hella hate, but what if Jersey Shore came on the challenges back around Cutthroat/Rivals and they had a Real World/Road Rules team vs Jersey Shore/Fresh Meat.

Lowkey always wanted to see Pauly and all the girls minus Angelina because they were so crazy. Ronnie, Vinny, and Mike can stay home though zzz

xHollyangel wrote:

mickeyflo24 wrote:https://stopbeingpolite.com/2012/03/25/if-wins/this was interesting to read.

We really need a new black male winner and by the way the last black girl to win was Janelle on Inferno 3. Leroy/Ty/Brandon(FM2) had so much potential but they decided to be side characters...smh

Brandon was screwed from the get go because he wasn't as athletic as Roylee or Ty. notice how he has only won two mission-challenges (one on Cutthroat and the other on FA) and both of them were group challenges. and why did you add the last fact of the black female challenge winner that really had nothing to do with my link... no offense. 

 

No Offense taken i just found it curious and added my opinion Blum 3 , Cooke on FA would definetely improve Free Agents. You guys are all saying CT/Wes/Bananas on FA but dont forget about Frank, had he stayed and competed without being ill he would be a big deal.

FA on the male side would be stacked: CT/Wes/Bananas/Leroy/Zach/Frank.S/Jordan plus Laurel/Cara/Cooke/Theresa **** seems like it would be epic, too bad they dont try to make strong casts anymore.

jergatlin5 wrote:

I'm gonna get hella hate, but what if Jersey Shore came on the challenges back around Cutthroat/Rivals and they had a Real World/Road Rules team vs Jersey Shore/Fresh Meat.

Lowkey always wanted to see Pauly and all the girls minus Angelina because they were so crazy. Ronnie, Vinny, and Mike can stay home though zzz

wym, ima need to see Angelina's messy *** again. I would have loved seeing her, Jwoww, Vinny and Pauly. 

HonestTea101 wrote:

jergatlin5 wrote:I'm gonna get hella hate, but what if Jersey Shore came on the challenges back around Cutthroat/Rivals and they had a Real World/Road Rules team vs Jersey Shore/Fresh Meat.

Lowkey always wanted to see Pauly and all the girls minus Angelina because they were so crazy. Ronnie, Vinny, and Mike can stay home though zzz

wym, ima need to see Angelina's messy *** again. I would have loved seeing her, Jwoww, Vinny and Pauly. 

Angelina would have quit again #UMHELLO

Pages