American Idol

627 posts / 0 new
Last post

I know Simon was considered the mean one, but apparently JLo was pretty tough during auditions.

id laugh in JLo’s face if she criticized my singing ability 

HonestTea101 wrote:

I know Simon was considered the mean one, but apparently JLo was pretty tough during auditions.

id laugh in JLo’s face if she criticized my singing ability 

Idk about her live but her songs are pretty great. She had to be a good enough singer to get the role of Selena back in the 90s

JayTea wrote:

HonestTea101 wrote:I know Simon was considered the mean one, but apparently JLo was pretty tough during auditions.

id laugh in JLo’s face if she criticized my singing ability 

Idk about her live but her songs are pretty great. She had to be a good enough singer to get the role of Selena back in the 90s

she’s passable, in her defense she’s mostly known for Dance/Performing so I understand her role as a judge, but a stable vocalist she is not 

J lo hated Haley Reinhart. So J Lo sucks 

J lo hated Haley Reinhart. So J Lo sucks 

Oh? Now I'm pissed

I always forget Haley came from AI. 

J lo hated Haley Reinhart. So J Lo sucks 

Omg..... really?

This top 5 is umm questionable, I think I like Maddie and that’s about it. I can’t believe this got renewed for a season 2 

Gabby will be a big star.

Gabby will be a big star.

I defenitely see her finding a strong lane in Country Pop. I have no Idea how the other 3 boys made it this far 

First Michelle and now Catie, became dust.

Queen Catie Legendturner and Jurnee was robbed! Sad

Zzzzzzzzz @ Cade and Caleb

 

Maddie ICONIC Poppe >>>>>>>>>>

This is Trump's America :(Maddie and Caleb is who I am rooting for lol

We not gonna act like Gabby isn’t a star. Cade is also legendary as well. I love Maddie too. Michelle should be in Top 5 over the black kid I can’t remember name. 

No thank you. Although the Spanish girl gonna be something. 

This is Trump's America :(Maddie and Caleb is who I am rooting for lol

Journee did kinda get screwed but she was not relatable. She had little personality and her story of being married at 18 to a girl in the military was dumb. The producers didn’t put any black people through with star quality, the show only likes black church singers and that doesn’t win the show.

We not gonna act like Gabby isn’t a star. Cade is also legendary as well. I love Maddie too. Michelle should be in Top 5 over the black kid I can’t remember name. 

Gabby will be a major success in the industry if she wins. Cade looks greasy, weird, and has no personality.

Michelle = 2018 verison of Selena Quintanilla

Garrett and his cringy Eyebrow expression shouldn't had been in the Top 14 in the first place smh. Laine should of been picked over him smh

Garrett and his cringy Eyebrow expression shouldn't had been in the Top 14 in the first place smh. Laine should of been picked over him smh

Did someone actually say Cade was good? Maybe at future head and shoulders commercials but it certainly isn’t at singing 

Did someone actually say Cade was good? Maybe at future head and shoulders commercials but it certainly isn’t at singing 

To each their own. I think he’s good. Catie was just weird and people liked that for whatever reasonzzz

JayTea wrote:

Did someone actually say Cade was good? Maybe at future head and shoulders commercials but it certainly isn’t at singing 

To each their own. I think he’s good. Catie was just weird and people liked that for whatever reasonzzz

Zzzzzz @ Cade and don't be slandering my Catie like that

Catie was okay with her original songs, nothing that hasn’t been done before but she could sing. She left at the right time imo. Cade I could maybe see in a band making stoner music but no real star power or peak there. 

Overall I think Maddie or Gabby will win 

Catie was okay with her original songs, nothing that hasn’t been done before but she could sing. She left at the right time imo. Cade I could maybe see in a band making stoner music but no real star power or peak there. Overall I think Maddie or Gabby will win 

She has a good fanbase. She will be fine lol

Catie had strong enough vocals but was a hot mess.  She still outperformed Michael J so she should have stayed around another week.  Not loving any of them this season but the mixing is off to me.  The music is crowding out the vocals too often.  

Catie had strong enough vocals but was a hot mess.  She still outperformed Michael J so she should have stayed around another week.  Not loving any of them this season but the mixing is off to me.  The music is crowding out the vocals too often.  

I do agree the music and the crowd over powers the contestants singing. I watched when Cade was singing and I could not hear him at all.

People still watch this?

The sob stories do suck but it’s a tv competition show and being relatable or rootable is the name of the game. By a certain point of the competition everyone can sing well so something has to give you the edge i know not all of us have rooted for the text book BEST singer on every show, meaning something irrelevant to their talent stood out to you. Maybe their looks or personality. To me that’s no different than the sob story card 

That's why I can't stand watching these singing competition shows. They prioritize good TV over actual singers and finding breakout stars. Work in the industry so it irks my life knowing how fake those shows are. 

Pages