The Challenge: Favorite/Fantasy Casts

16752 posts / 0 new
Last post

I want them to bring Theo back so bad. Was rewatching the seasons and I'm on invasions. I remember his Twitter engagements and for a while he wanted a second chance to prove himself. I think if given the chance, he'd come in like a wrecking ball. 

I want them to bring Theo back so bad. Was rewatching the seasons and I'm on invasions. I remember his Twitter engagements and for a while he wanted a second chance to prove himself. I think if given the chance, he'd come in like a wrecking ball. 

The Challenge: Jonna

Jonna - Endurance 1

Jonna - Rivals 1

Jonna - BOTS2

Jonna - Rivals 2

Jonna - Free Agents

Jonna - Exes 2

Jonna - Allstars 1

Jonna - Allstars 2

Episode 1:

Heights over water

Last place: Allstars 1

Winner: Endurance

Voted in by winner: Rivals 2 for being stand offish.

Elimination: Oppenheimer

Loser: Rivals 2

Episode 2: 

Mini final

Last place: Free Agents

Winner: Allstars 2

Voted in by winner: Rivals 1 for getting 2nd in the challenge

Elimination: Back Off Me

Loser: Free Agents (the hottest one)

Episode 3: 

Trivia

Last Place: Exes 2 (too traumatized to remember stuff)

Winner: Allstars 2

Voted in by winner: Endurance (to split up the alliance of Endurance & Exes 2)

Elimination: Puzzle

Loser: Exes 2

Episode 4:

Obstacle Course

Last Place: Allstars 1

Winner: Endurance

Voted in by winner: Allstars 2

Elimination: Endurance game involving holding up your arm without dropping it while being splattered with food

Loser: Allstars 2

Episode 5: 

Roller Derby

Last Place: Endurance (too small and got flung by the adults)

Winner: Allstars 1

Voted in by winner: BOTS2 (Played dirty during the mission)

Elimination: Tree Climb from WOTW2

Loser: BOTS2 literally pulls a Laurel

Episode 6: 

Swimming race

Winner and straight to the final: Endurance 1

Rivals 1 vs Allstars 1

Elimination: Hand cuffs

Loser: Rivals 1

FINAL CHALLENGE:

Involves cayaks, mountain climbing, sudoku, getting directions from locals in the city to find TJs final.

Endurance 1 leads the way the entire time but gets lost when trying to find the finish line when asking for help in the downtown of Portland. Allstars 1 not far behind knows directions better and crosses the finish line.

Winner ALLSTARS 1 AND TITLE AS THE ULTIMATE JONNA ERA.

This was such a funny underrated fantasy cast and game wow

 

The Challege Allstars 4: Heroes vs VIllains

Heroes:

Thomas (RW Explosion)

Tony (RW Skeletons)

Yes (RR Semester at Sea

Cohutta (RW Sydney)

CJ (RW Cancun)

Landon (RW Philadelphia)

Darrell (RR Campus Crawl)

Robb (RW St. Thomas)

Jonna (RW Cancun)

Jodi (RR Xtreme)

Averey (RW Portland)

Julie (RW New Orleans)

Jessica (RW Portland)

Sophia (RR The Quest)

Jamie (RW San Diego)

Aneesa (RW Chicago)

 

Villains:

Marlon (RW Portland)

Wes (RW Austin)

Frank (RW San Diego 2)

Bananas (RW Key West)

Dan (RW Miami)

Abram (RR South Pacific)

Derrick (RR Xtreme)

Jordan (RW Portland)

Nia (RW Portland)

Kailah (RW Go Big or Go Home)

Veronica (RR Semester at Sea)

Coral (RW Back to New York)

Tina (RR South Pacific)

Marie (RW St. Thomas)

Jenn (RW Denver)

Beth (RW Los Angeles)

The Challenge: Battle of the Allies

Female Pairs:

  1. Amanda & Ashley (Invasion)
  2. Bayleigh & Da'Vonne (Big Brother 22)
  3. Bria & Kenya (AYTO?: Season 7)
  4. Francesca & Haley (Too Hot to Handle)
  5. Kailah & Sylvia (All-Stars 3)
  6. KellyAnne & Kendal (All-Stars)
  7. Laurel & Nany (War of the Worlds 2)
  8. Liana & Shan (Survivor 41)
  9. Michele & Natalie (Survivor: WAW)
  10. Jasmine & Paige (AYTO8?) - ALTS

Male Pairs:

  1. Ashley & Theo (War of the Worlds 2)
  2. Brice & Wendell (Survivor)
  3. Cody & Paulie (Brothers)
  4. Fessy & Swaggy (Big Brother 20)
  5. Hunter & Wes (AYTO?: Season 3)
  6. Jeremiah & Johnny (Love Island 2)
  7. Joaquin & Rodney (Survivor: World's Apart)
  8. Joss & Rogan (Ex on the Beach UK)
  9. JP & Turbo (War of the Worlds)
  10. Devin & Mark (Ex on the Beach 3) - ALTS

this realllll cute 

This cast is iconic....

But Julie and Tony as Heroes lol

This cast is iconic....

But Julie and Tony as Heroes lol

[/quote

I did it bc Julie being a Hero on Inferno 2 cracked me up, and they would give Tony the "good dad" edit if he ever came back lol

Why was my Jonna game ignored?

 

The Challege Allstars 4: Heroes vs VIllains

Heroes:

Thomas (RW Explosion)

Tony (RW Skeletons)

Yes (RR Semester at Sea

Cohutta (RW Sydney)

CJ (RW Cancun)

Landon (RW Philadelphia)

Darrell (RR Campus Crawl)

Robb (RW St. Thomas)

Jonna (RW Cancun)

Jodi (RR Xtreme)

Averey (RW Portland)

Julie (RW New Orleans)

Jessica (RW Portland)

Sophia (RR The Quest)

Jamie (RW San Diego)

Aneesa (RW Chicago)

 

Villains:

Marlon (RW Portland)

Wes (RW Austin)

Frank (RW San Diego 2)

Bananas (RW Key West)

Dan (RW Miami)

Abram (RR South Pacific)

Derrick (RR Xtreme)

Jordan (RW Portland)

Nia (RW Portland)

Kailah (RW Go Big or Go Home)

Veronica (RR Semester at Sea)

Coral (RW Back to New York)

Tina (RR South Pacific)

Marie (RW St. Thomas)

Jenn (RW Denver)

Beth (RW Los Angeles)

Does this say Tony is a hero?  lmao.  Even Tom is nonsense

John and Derrick are more likely heroes as sad as that may be

The Challenge: Rivals 4 (Co-Ed)

Teams:

  1. Amanda & Ashley C (War of the Worlds)
  2. Amber & Fessy (Spies, Lies, & Allies)
  3. Ashley M & Josh (Spies, Lies, & Allies)
  4. Ayanna & Darrell (All-Stars 2)
  5. Cara & Jordan (XXX: Dirty 30)
  6. Da’Vonne & Jamar (Ex on the Beach 5)
  7. Kailah & Hunter (XXX: Dirty 30)
  8. Kayleigh & Theo (War of the Worlds 2)
  9. Kenya & Devin (Ex on the Beach 3)
  10. Justine & Tre (Love Island 2)
  11. Laurel & Paulie (War of the Worlds 2)
  12. Liana & Xander (Survivor 41)
  13. Marie & Brad (Final Reckoning)
  14. Nicole & Shane (Invasion)
  15. Olivia & Mechie (Double Agents)
  16. Tori & Gio (AYTO?: Season 4)
  17. Tovah & Dondre (RW: Atlanta)

Yes some are stretched. 

The Challenge: Rivals 4 (Co-Ed)

Teams:

  1. Amanda & Ashley C (War of the Worlds)
  2. Amber & Fessy (Spies, Lies, & Allies)
  3. Ashley M & Josh (Spies, Lies, & Allies)
  4. Ayanna & Darrell (All-Stars 2)
  5. Cara & Jordan (XXX: Dirty 30)
  6. Da’Vonne & Jamar (Ex on the Beach 5)
  7. Kailah & Hunter (XXX: Dirty 30)
  8. Kayleigh & Theo (War of the Worlds 2)
  9. Kenya & Devin (Ex on the Beach 3)
  10. Justine & Tre (Love Island 2)
  11. Laurel & Paulie (War of the Worlds 2)
  12. Liana & Xander (Survivor 41)
  13. Marie & Brad (Final Reckoning)
  14. Nicole & Shane (Invasion)
  15. Olivia & Mechie (Double Agents)
  16. Tori & Gio (AYTO?: Season 4)
  17. Tovah & Dondre (RW: Atlanta)

Yes some are stretched. 

Do you want Paulie and Cara to both make the final?  lol

Battle of the OG Challenge Seasons

Teams consist of winners of a season or ppl who debuted that season

RW/RR Challenge (1999): Mark/Nathan/Beth/Roni

Challenge 2000: Yes/Teck/Veronica/Amaya

Extreme Challenge: Dan/Laterrian/Julie/Ayanna

Battle of the Sexes: Jamie/Theo(Chicago)/Ruthie/Aneesa

The Gauntlet: Steve/Darrell/Katie/Tina

The Inferno: CT/Timmy/Leah/Kendal

Battle of the Sexes 2: Derrick/Brad/Sophia/Arissa

The Gauntlet 2: MJ/Alton/Jodi/Ibis

Alt team- Fresh Meat 1: Wes/Big Easy/Melinda/Casey

10 dailies/eliminations (BOTS2 format). 20 mfs go home, 12 make the final

i tried being realistic with the cast

my cast served and my concept was innovative-ish.

Again, why was my Jonna cast completely ignored?

Again, why was my Jonna cast completely ignored?

ur Jonna cast was great

 

Again, why was my Jonna cast completely ignored?

ur Jonna cast was great

Thank you. I needed someone's validation. Have a blessed night Mac.

Nah you didn't include Jonna almost on FM2 as a team so cancel the whole thing 

The Challenge: Love Triangles

Nany/Dustin/Heather - RW: Vegas

Madison/Tony/Alyssa - RW: Skeletons

Ashley/Nelson/Berna - Spies, Lies & Allies

Jamie/Hailey/Thomas - RW: Explosion

Cory/Brian/Jenny - RW: Explosion

KellyAnne/Wes/Theresa - Fresh Meat 2

Veronica/Aneesa/Rachel - ?

Jenna/Zach/Jonna - Exes 2

Kailah/Dione/Amanda - RW: Go Big or Go Home

Can't think of any more teams but I'm sure Love Island could provide a couple.

Some kind of format where the trios due to go into elimination vote 1 of their team to go in and potentially go home.

 

Battle of the Franchises

Old School RW: Kellyanne, Cohutta, Wes, Jonna

New School RW: Tony, Nia, Kailah, Marlon

AYTO: Kam, Hunter, Shanley, Justin Palm

Road Rules: Derrick, Kendal, Tina, Shane

Survivor US: Michele, Michaela, Jay, Jonathan Young

Survivor Intl: Turbo, Emanuel, Emy, Brooke Jowett

BBUS: Kyland, Paulie, Amber B, Christie Murphy

BB International: Adam Pike, Esther A, Hughie, Kaela Grant

Wildcard: Corey L, Georgia, Ed, Cara Maria

Its El Lobito consistently eating us up  with his fantasy casts for me

Ruins 2

Syrus (Extreme)

  Darrell (Guantlet)

Wes (Duel)

Zack (Battle of the Seasons)

Devin ( 2nd Chances)

Hunter (Final Reckoning)

Turbo ( War of the Worlds)

Tommy (Island of the Idols)

Coral (Battle of the Seasons)

Veronica (Challenge 2000)

Susie (Gauntlet 2)

Aviv (Fresh Meat)

Laurel ( Free Agents)

Natalie (Survivor San Juan)

Ashley (Invasion)

Erika (Survivor 41)

Challengers

Shane (Campus Crawl)

Brandon (Fresh Meat 2)

Robb (St Thomas)

Kyle ( Geordie Shore)

Joss (Ex on the Beach)

Sean (Shipwrecked)

Bret Robinson (Big Brother 20)

Derrick x (Big Brother 23)

Ruthie (RW Hawaii)

Aneesa (RW Chicago)

Nany (RW Vegas)

Kelly Wentworth (Survivor San Juan)

Michaela (Survivor MvG)

Davonne (Big Brother 17)

Mattie (Party Down South)

Melissa (Ex on the Beach)

 

Who do you want to see as the 6 finalists for each team?

Ruins 2

Syrus (Extreme)

  Darrell (Guantlet)

Wes (Duel)

Zack (Battle of the Seasons)

Devin ( 2nd Chances)

Hunter (Final Reckoning)

Turbo ( War of the Worlds)

Tommy (Island of the Idols)

Coral (Battle of the Seasons)

Veronica (Challenge 2000)

Susie (Gauntlet 2)

Aviv (Fresh Meat)

Laurel ( Free Agents)

Natalie (Survivor San Juan)

Ashley (Invasion)

Erika (Survivor 41)

Challengers

Shane (Campus Crawl)

Brandon (Fresh Meat 2)

Robb (St Thomas)

Kyle ( Geordie Shore)

Joss (Ex on the Beach)

Sean (Shipwrecked)

Bret Robinson (Big Brother 20)

Derrick x (Big Brother 23)

Ruthie (RW Hawaii)

Aneesa (RW Chicago)

Nany (RW Vegas)

Kelly Wentworth (Survivor San Juan)

Michaela (Survivor MvG)

Davonne (Big Brother 17)

Mattie (Party Down South)

Melissa (Ex on the Beach)

 

Who do you want to see as the 6 finalists for each team?

probably Darrell, Ashley, Wes, Turbo, Coral, and Laurel for the champs. For the challengers, Kyle, Shane, Bret, Wentworth, Davonne, and Michaela

no way 2022 Coral is gonna make that final over literal CrossFit gym owner Natalie

also love the idea of champs of other shows being on a Ruins 2. especially for the salt Devin being there will create LMAO

no way 2022 Coral is gonna make that final over literal CrossFit gym owner Natalie

also love the idea of champs of other shows being on a Ruins 2. especially for the salt Devin being there will create LMAO

It says "want" not "think"

Agree on the second point for sure. 

This is not a fantasy cast but a fantasy GAME. Maybe a thread for fantasy games can be made if enough people have ideas. I'm sitting at work and randomly had a vision of Paulie vs Bananas in an elimination game where they are hung up like Jesus on a cross but angled towards the ground. The focus of the game is NOT TO SNEEZE..FIRST TO SNEEZE IS ELIMINATED. As they hang there with no way to cover their nose except hold their breath, they will have things blown in their face to force them to sneeze. In my vision black pepper was tossed at them and a funny Allstars edit of silly music was playing as we get a zoom in of Paulie trying SO HARD not to sneeze and we see snot falling out of his nose, eyes bulging out of his head, and Bananas gagging. Then Paulie makes the loudest weirdest hacking noise followed by a sneeze and is eliminated. The entire cast is laughing their heads off and Cara is sitting on the floor in tears. "I can't believe I lost because of a sneeze" - final words

The end

I liked them being on a cross like Jesus. Think  it would be better if they had to get off the cross while it burns

I liked them being on a cross like Jesus. Think  it would be better if they had to get off the cross while it burns

LMAOOOOOOOOO

This is the funniest shit ever

LOL I second the cross burning idea.

Inspired by my man Noor popping up again. 

I'd love to see a cast made up of one hit wonders, or people from RW or AYTO that never got a chance (not saying all the outside additions weren't good, but I liked it coming from a smaller pool) You'd have to have aome regulars I suppose, so maybe it could be a paired show, vet with newbies or onebies

Admittedly, they'd all be a bit older, but that's fine.

I'm going to miss out so many, and not including vets, but Id love to see:

Noor - Fresh Meat 2

Sandy - Fresh Meat 2

Mike - Real World DC

Briana - AYTO 2 ( I know she was in two, but still my rules!)

 

 

Whoops didn't mean to post yet!! Carrying on...

Cooke & Mike - RW Vegas

Keith - AYTO 6

Kenya -AYTO 7

Avery - RW Portland ( was she in more than one?) and Marlon

Jenny - RW Explosion

Jen - RW bad blood

Basit -AYTO 8

Shanley - AYTO 1

Gio - AYTO 4 (assuming he's mentally okay)

Joe -AYTO 6

Most of these havnt been in but Ive drawn a blank to one hit wonders

 

 

 

Pages