The Challenge: All Stars 4 Old Schooler Fantasy

668 posts / 0 new
Last post

 

Holly from RR9 is definitely top tier

I don't disagree with this.

Yeah and I don't think it's a bad list

@Production I have made a list of who your top tier (realistic) priorities and backup options should be.

Top Tier: Beth RW2 (ONLY if with Veronica, Tina, Julie), David RW2, Julie RW9, Coral RW10, Lori RW10, Landon RW15, Ashli RW19, Marie RW26, Antoine RR3, Chadwick RR6, Holly RR7, Veronica RR8, Ayanna RR8, Katie RR10, Adam RR10, Rachel RR11, Shane RR11, Tina RR12, Cara RR12, Tori RR14, Pete FM2

Mid Tier: Heather & Julie RW1, Sharon RW4, Dan RW5, Elka RW6, Syrus RW6, Jamie RW9, Theo RW11, Steven RW12, Svetlana RW17, CJ RW22, Dan RR5, Susie RR6, Kefla RR6, Holly RR9, Laterrian RR9, Steve RR10, Jisela RR10, Jeremy RR12, Jillian RR13

Back-Ups: Eric RW1, Cynthia RW5 (really just give us Miami Homecoming), Amaya RW8, Trishelle RW12, Alton RW12, Leroy RW25, Tara RR5, Gladys RR7, Kendal RR11, Ibis RR13

Bad Options But Acceptable Options To Please Casuals: CT RW13, Wes RW16, John RW17, Mark RR1

Ashli and Marie ****

Other than that nonsense you're good

Pete from FM2 is not top tier...

Ashli and Marie ****

Other than that nonsense you're good

You are right Marie and Ashli belong on the MTV show not this.

Pete from FM2 is not top tier...

Disagree.

 

Pete from FM2 is not top tier...

Disagree.

what in the WORLD do you think Pete is gonna provide 12/13 years later? if you have a crush on him just say that, but I highly doubt anybody (who even remembers him) is anticipating his return...

Noor, Pete, Carley, Sandy and Sydney for AS4.

Brandon Nelson for AS4.

No one on fresh meat 2 should be on this

Svetlana not top tier ?

Svetlana not top tier ?

She shouldn't even be on the list

 

Ashli and Marie ****

Other than that nonsense you're good

You are right Marie and Ashli belong on the MTV show not this.

Agreed. We need early boots for the main show

No one on fresh meat 2 should be on this

I'd be ok with that but there are several who should be on the mtv show.

 

@Production I have made a list of who your top tier (realistic) priorities and backup options should be.

Top Tier: Beth RW2 (ONLY if with Veronica, Tina, Julie), David RW2, Julie RW9, Coral RW10, Lori RW10, Landon RW15, Ashli RW19, Marie RW26, Antoine RR3, Chadwick RR6, Holly RR7, Veronica RR8, Ayanna RR8, Katie RR10, Adam RR10, Rachel RR11, Shane RR11, Tina RR12, Cara RR12, Tori RR14, Pete FM2

Mid Tier: Heather & Julie RW1, Sharon RW4, Dan RW5, Elka RW6, Syrus RW6, Jamie RW9, Theo RW11, Steven RW12, Svetlana RW17, CJ RW22, Dan RR5, Susie RR6, Kefla RR6, Holly RR9, Laterrian RR9, Steve RR10, Jisela RR10, Jeremy RR12, Jillian RR13

Back-Ups: Eric RW1, Cynthia RW5 (really just give us Miami Homecoming), Amaya RW8, Trishelle RW12, Alton RW12, Leroy RW25, Tara RR5, Gladys RR7, Kendal RR11, Ibis RR13

Bad Options But Acceptable Options To Please Casuals: CT RW13, Wes RW16, John RW17, Mark RR1

Ashli and Marie ****

Other than that nonsense you're good

Great cast!  Not sure Ashli should be top tier... but i wouldn't mind seeing her in a Sydney Homecoming 

I wonder if they would ever bring Jo back. She said she wanted to return 

Kind of want ayiiia on, whatever happened to her

I wish that Sophia would come back but I think she is busy with her other projects.

"I want Dunbar" - what no one ever said.

I wonder if they would ever bring Jo back. She said she wanted to return 

Give us Jo, omg.

I wonder if they would ever bring Jo back. She said she wanted to return 

likely not, I would love to see her again tho... especially after the mike Lewis podcast she did...

Jo would have a nice redemption comeback for like season 6 but there are way better names out there.

Jo would redeem herself. 

"I want Dunbar" - what no one ever said.

Maybe a chick in that **** he did or the high schooler he was dating on Exes. 

I'm kind of sick of Jonna and Kellyanne ESPECIALLY Derrick and Nehemiah if they come back... lord 

We want TONY!

Jo provided more in one episode than most people who have done multiple

All these random people you want back will have like 1 second of airtime while Derrick and Nehemiah have their beef again for 10th time 

all stars should be 1hr30

We want TONY!

Please take this to the season 3 thread.

Production, I've saved you some trouble and given you the cast list:

Women: Coral, Rachel, Tina, Veronica, Ayanna, Julie, Lori, Jillian, Holly Shand, Jisela, Ibis, Ellen

Men: Landon, Marlon, Dan Renzi, Mark, Pete, Adam L, Alton, Brad, Abram, Eric Nies (jumprope is a must), Theo Von, Darrell

You're welcome.

 

Pages

Topic locked