The Challenge: Favorite/Fantasy Casts

16760 posts / 0 new
Last post

Rivals 3: Co-Ed

Bananas & Rachel

Wes & Laurel

CT & Coral

Darrell & Kelly Anne

CJ & Ayiiia

Ryan L. & Jemmeye

Frank & Nany 

Zach & Marie

Jordan & Nia

Swift & LaToya

Cory & Ashley M. 

Jay & Jamie

Brian & Jenny 

Tony & Violetta

Bruno & Madison

 

Elimination Order:

1. Jay & Jamie eliminated by Brian & Jenny

2. Ryan L. & Jemmeye eliminated by Jordan & Nia

3. Swift & LaToya eliminated by Tony & Violetta

4. Bruno & Madison eliminated by Cory & Ashley M. 

5. CJ & Ayiiia eliminated by Zach & Marie

6. Tony & Violetta eliminated by Cory & Ashley M. 

7. Cory & Ashley M. eliminated by Brian & Jenny 

8. Frank & Nany eliminated by Darrell & Kelly Anne

9. Wes & Laurel eliminated by Jordan & Nia

10. Bananas & Rachel eliminated by CT & Coral

11. Darrell & Kelly Anne eliminated by Zach & Marie

12. Zach & Marie eliminated by Brian & Jenny

 

Finals:

3rd Place: Brian & Jenny

2nd Place: Jordan & Nia

1st Place: CT & Coral

I'm not sure how you picked who was beauty, braun or brains but if we're going to have a beauty team let's include people that were "real" models such as Mallory and Scott.

 

I tried to make it some-what realistic for the most part and neither of those two will be asked back. 

I'm not sure how you picked who was beauty, braun or brains but if we're going to have a beauty team let's include people that were "real" models such as Mallory and Scott.

 

I tried to make it some-what realistic for the most part and neither of those two will be asked back. 

They should both be asked back BUT, even so, I don't understand your "beauty" picks.  

I'm not sure how you picked who was beauty, braun or brains but if we're going to have a beauty team let's include people that were "real" models such as Mallory and Scott.

 

I tried to make it some-what realistic for the most part and neither of those two will be asked back. 

They should both be asked back BUT, even so, I don't understand your "beauty" picks.  

Which picks?

I'm not sure how you picked who was beauty, braun or brains but if we're going to have a beauty team let's include people that were "real" models such as Mallory and Scott.

 

I tried to make it some-what realistic for the most part and neither of those two will be asked back. 

They should both be asked back BUT, even so, I don't understand your "beauty" picks.  

Which picks?

The beauty ones...I wasn't saying a couple of them.  Nany makes sense.  Averey too.  Other than that...yikes

And Reilly as "brawn"...come on.

Jordan as a brain--lmao

That's as ridiculous as Brad as a "good guy"

I'm not sure how you picked who was beauty, braun or brains but if we're going to have a beauty team let's include people that were "real" models such as Mallory and Scott.

 

I tried to make it some-what realistic for the most part and neither of those two will be asked back. 


If you're trying to be realistic than why did jenny beat Sarah

I'm not sure how you picked who was beauty, braun or brains but if we're going to have a beauty team let's include people that were "real" models such as Mallory and Scott.

 

I tried to make it some-what realistic for the most part and neither of those two will be asked back. 

If you're trying to be realistic than why did jenny beat Sarah

Theresa's also not losing to Averey and Frank isn't losing to Dustin

I'm not sure how you picked who was beauty, braun or brains but if we're going to have a beauty team let's include people that were "real" models such as Mallory and Scott.

 

I tried to make it some-what realistic for the most part and neither of those two will be asked back. 

If you're trying to be realistic than why did jenny beat Sarah

Theresa's also not losing to Averey and Frank isn't losing to Dustin

Also I love Kelly Anne but I don't know if she could beat Nicole, Nicole lifted a 200 pound man like a weight. Shes extremely strong. Plus her football background means she's pretty athletic

The Challenge: Cutthroat 2

Red Team: 
 
Bruno Bettencourt (Skeletons)
Cohutta Grindstaff (Sydney)
Johnny Reilly (Portland)
Scott Herman (Brooklyn)
Wes Bergmann (Austin)
Zach Nichols (San Diego)
 
Ashley Mitchell (Ex-Plosion)
Beth Stolarcsyk (Los Angeles)
Jonna Mannion (Cancun)
LaToya Jackson (St. Thomas)
Madison Walls (Skeletons)
Sarah Rice (Brooklyn)
 
 
Blue Team: 
 
Abram Boise (South Pacific)
Brian Williams (Ex-PLosion)
Isaac Stout (Sydney)
Frank Sweeney (San Diego)
Leroy Garrett (Las Vegas)
Robb Schreiber (St. Thomas)
 
Coral Smith (Back to New York)
Hailey Chivers (Ex-Plosion)
Jemmye Carroll (New Orleans)
Nia Moore (Portland)
Robin Hibbard (San Diego)
Violetta Millerman (Skeletons)
 
 
Gray Team: 
 
CJ Koegel (Cancun)
Cory Wharton (Ex-Plosion)
Darrell Taylor (Campus Crawl)
Jordan Wiseley (Portland)
Thomas Buell (Ex-PLosion)
Trey Weatherholtz (St. Thomas)
 
Averey Tressler (Portland)
Heather Marter (Las Vegas)
Jenny Delich (Ex-Plosion)
Kellyanne Judd (Sydney)
Sylvia Elsrode (Skeletons)
Trishelle Cannatella (Las Vegas)
 
 

You guys know that they could do a BOTsexes3 and it doesn't have to be a vote off, right?

13 players per team. After each misision whatever rules they are if there's an inner circle two guys and two girls could be sent into elimination every week with one coming back. 10 eliminations, 3 in the final per team.

You guys know that they could do a BOTsexes3 and it doesn't have to be a vote off, right?

13 players per team. After each misision whatever rules they are if there's an inner circle two guys and two girls could be sent into elimination every week with one coming back. 10 eliminations, 3 in the final per team.


Yeah this is the best way to do it

Since there has been interest from the old schoolers I wouldn't mind seeing three team challenge so it would be like Old School Vets VS New School Vets VS Rookies. Old School Vets could be people started challenges prior to Fresh Meat (this could change based off of how many old school they got) then new school Vets is if you have been in at least 3 challenge and Rookies would be less then 3 challenges. I think the dynamic would be good because there would be so much variety even in strategy especially between.  10 per team.   

People that I would be fine with being on the show:

Old School:

CT

Derrick 

Mark

Brad

Abram

Coral

Veronica

Annessa

Trishelle (Since she quit I doubt she would be on it or asked) 

Kina

Ruthie

Other maybes: Theo, Landon, Darrell, Ace, Adam, MJ, Tonya, Tina, Katie, Rachel, Ibis, Robin

 

New School Vets:

Wes 

Bananas

Kenny (Not Likely)

Zach

Cohutta

Evelyn

Sarah

Cara

Laurel

Cooke

Maybes: Danny, Nehemiah, Dunbar, Chet, Brandon, Evan (Not likely), Preston, Dustin, Leroy, Melinda, Johanna, Paula, Jenn, Kelly Ann (Doubtful), Emily (Doubtful), 

 

Rookies: (3 or less challenges) 

Mike Mike

Johnny

Jordan

Cory

Adam (AYTO since we know they will be on there from now on) 

Averey

Hailey

Jamie 

Nicole

Simone (AYTO)

Maybes: Brain, Jay, Thomas, Bruno, Tony, Jason, Nia, LaToya, Jess, Jenny, Jenna, Madison, Sylvia. AYTO I do not remember Season 1 and have not watched season 2 so Idk who would be good. 

Since there has been interest from the old schoolers I wouldn't mind seeing three team challenge so it would be like Old School Vets VS New School Vets VS Rookies. Old School Vets could be people started challenges prior to Fresh Meat (this could change based off of how many old school they got) then new school Vets is if you have been in at least 3 challenge and Rookies would be less then 3 challenges. I think the dynamic would be good because there would be so much variety even in strategy especially between.  10 per team.   

People that I would be fine with being on the show:

Old School:

CT

Derrick 

Mark

Brad

Abram

Coral

Veronica

Annessa

Trishelle (Since she quit I doubt she would be on it or asked) 

Kina

Ruthie

Other maybes: Theo, Landon, Darrell, Ace, Adam, MJ, Tonya, Tina, Katie, Rachel, Ibis, Robin

 

New School Vets:

Wes 

Bananas

Kenny (Not Likely)

Zach

Cohutta

Evelyn

Sarah

Cara

Laurel

Cooke

Maybes: Danny, Nehemiah, Dunbar, Chet, Brandon, Evan (Not likely), Preston, Dustin, Leroy, Melinda, Johanna, Paula, Jenn, Kelly Ann (Doubtful), Emily (Doubtful), 

 

Rookies: (3 or less challenges) 

Mike Mike

Johnny

Jordan

Cory

Adam (AYTO since we know they will be on there from now on)

Averey

Hailey

Jamie 

Nicole

Simone (AYTO)

Maybes: Brain, Jay, Thomas, Bruno, Tony, Jason, Nia, LaToya, Jess, Jenny, Jenna, Madison, Sylvia. AYTO I do not remember Season 1 and have not watched season 2 so Idk who would be good. 

Uh, what makes you so sure?

Free Agents 2 Frank(Las Vegas 2) Robb(St Thomas) Abram(South Pacific) Cj(Cancun) Thomas(Ex-plosion) Brad(San Diego 1) Brian(Ex-plosion) Jason(Skeletons) Nehemiah(Austin) Dan(Viewer's Revenge) Eric(New Orleans 2) Ryan(Brooklyn) Andrew(DC) Tony(Skeletons) Janelle(Key West) Jenny(Ex-plosion) Marie(St Thomas) Susie(Down Under) Britnii(Hollywood) Tina(South Pacific) Jillian(X-TREME) Jamie(Ex-plosion) Violetta(Skeletons) Madison(Skeletons) Avery(Portland) Kellyanne(Sydney) Veronica(Semester at Sea) Mallory(Paris)

Exes 3
Location Barcelona Spain
Teams of four, battle of the seasons rules
Red Team
CJ
Ashley K
Zach
Jonna
Green Team
CT
Laurel
Jordan
Sarah
Blue Team
Brian
Jenny
Cory
Ashley M
Yellow Team
Cohutta
Susie
Ace
Mallory

Black Team
Leroy
Theresa
Wes
Kelly Anne

Purple Team
Darrell
Rachel
Abram
Coral
Aqua Team
Bananas
Nany
Johnny
Averey
Emerald Team
Will
Janelle
Alton
Irulan

The Ruins 2
Champions

The Banana Man
Zach Nichols
Nehemiah Clark
Tyler Duck
Dunbar Merrill
Wes Bergmann

Laurel Stucky
Ashley Marie
Carley (whatever her last name is)
Camila(not even gonna try and spell her last name)
Paula walnuts
Sam(BOTS2)

Challengers

Jordan wiseley
Johnny Portland
Leroy Garrett
Dustin Zito
Noor (FM2)
Cj (Cancun)

Cara maria
Theresa
Nany
Nia
Jonna
Aneesa

Even though I don't want to see anyone else from AYTO, I'm just bored

Real World paired with someone from AYTO

Nany/Anthony

Kellyanne/Dario

Susie/Adam

Jonna/Brandon

Ashley K/Scali

Marie/Layton

Averey/John

Bananas/Shanley

Wes/Paris

Darrell/Christina

Jordan/Briana

Leroy/Jenni

Cory/Jacy

Mark/Brittany

 

 

 

Exes 3 Location Barcelona Spain Teams of four, battle of the seasons rules Red Team CJ Ashley K Zach Jonna Green Team CT Laurel Jordan Sarah Blue Team Brian Jenny Cory Ashley M Yellow Team Cohutta Susie Ace Mallory Black Team Leroy Theresa Wes Kelly Anne Purple Team Darrell Rachel Abram Coral Aqua Team Bananas Nany Johnny Averey Emerald Team Will Janelle Alton Irulan

Green and Purple are for sure making the final, with either Black or Aqua as the third team. 

Exes 3 Location Barcelona Spain Teams of four, battle of the seasons rules Red Team CJ Ashley K Zach Jonna Green Team CT Laurel Jordan Sarah Blue Team Brian Jenny Cory Ashley M Yellow Team Cohutta Susie Ace Mallory Black Team Leroy Theresa Wes Kelly Anne Purple Team Darrell Rachel Abram Coral Aqua Team Bananas Nany Johnny Averey Emerald Team Will Janelle Alton Irulan

Green and Purple are for sure making the final, with either Black or Aqua as the third team. 


Red could also make it, I feel like they'd be great together. Especially CJ Zach and Ashley K

Exes 3 Location Barcelona Spain Teams of four, battle of the seasons rules Red Team CJ Ashley K Zach Jonna Green Team CT Laurel Jordan Sarah Blue Team Brian Jenny Cory Ashley M Yellow Team Cohutta Susie Ace Mallory Black Team Leroy Theresa Wes Kelly Anne Purple Team Darrell Rachel Abram Coral Aqua Team Bananas Nany Johnny Averey Emerald Team Will Janelle Alton Irulan

Green and Purple are for sure making the final, with either Black or Aqua as the third team. 

Red could also make it, I feel like they'd be great together. Especially CJ Zach and Ashley K

Final 3 will definitely be Green, Black, and Aqua. Love Purple especially Coral but they would have to have Rachel in every elimination.

Since there has been interest from the old schoolers I wouldn't mind seeing three team challenge so it would be like Old School Vets VS New School Vets VS Rookies. Old School Vets could be people started challenges prior to Fresh Meat (this could change based off of how many old school they got) then new school Vets is if you have been in at least 3 challenge and Rookies would be less then 3 challenges. I think the dynamic would be good because there would be so much variety even in strategy especially between.  10 per team.   

People that I would be fine with being on the show:

Old School:

CT

Derrick 

Mark

Brad

Abram

Coral

Veronica

Annessa

Trishelle (Since she quit I doubt she would be on it or asked) 

Kina

Ruthie

Other maybes: Theo, Landon, Darrell, Ace, Adam, MJ, Tonya, Tina, Katie, Rachel, Ibis, Robin

 

New School Vets:

Wes 

Bananas

Kenny (Not Likely)

Zach

Cohutta

Evelyn

Sarah

Cara

Laurel

Cooke

Maybes: Danny, Nehemiah, Dunbar, Chet, Brandon, Evan (Not likely), Preston, Dustin, Leroy, Melinda, Johanna, Paula, Jenn, Kelly Ann (Doubtful), Emily (Doubtful), 

 

Rookies: (3 or less challenges) 

Mike Mike

Johnny

Jordan

Cory

Adam (AYTO since we know they will be on there from now on)

Averey

Hailey

Jamie 

Nicole

Simone (AYTO)

Maybes: Brain, Jay, Thomas, Bruno, Tony, Jason, Nia, LaToya, Jess, Jenny, Jenna, Madison, Sylvia. AYTO I do not remember Season 1 and have not watched season 2 so Idk who would be good. 

Uh, what makes you so sure?

Even if they dont ask other people from that show again, I am 99.9% sure that at least 1-2 that did their debut on Exes 2 will be back just like camila was back after cutthroat

Adam strikes me as one of those guys that production love casting and will be back.

Since there has been interest from the old schoolers I wouldn't mind seeing three team challenge so it would be like Old School Vets VS New School Vets VS Rookies. Old School Vets could be people started challenges prior to Fresh Meat (this could change based off of how many old school they got) then new school Vets is if you have been in at least 3 challenge and Rookies would be less then 3 challenges. I think the dynamic would be good because there would be so much variety even in strategy especially between.  10 per team.   

People that I would be fine with being on the show:

Old School:

CT

Derrick 

Mark

Brad

Abram

Coral

Veronica

Annessa

Trishelle (Since she quit I doubt she would be on it or asked) 

Kina

Ruthie

Other maybes: Theo, Landon, Darrell, Ace, Adam, MJ, Tonya, Tina, Katie, Rachel, Ibis, Robin

 

New School Vets:

Wes 

Bananas

Kenny (Not Likely)

Zach

Cohutta

Evelyn

Sarah

Cara

Laurel

Cooke

Maybes: Danny, Nehemiah, Dunbar, Chet, Brandon, Evan (Not likely), Preston, Dustin, Leroy, Melinda, Johanna, Paula, Jenn, Kelly Ann (Doubtful), Emily (Doubtful), 

 

Rookies: (3 or less challenges) 

Mike Mike

Johnny

Jordan

Cory

Adam (AYTO since we know they will be on there from now on)

Averey

Hailey

Jamie 

Nicole

Simone (AYTO)

Maybes: Brain, Jay, Thomas, Bruno, Tony, Jason, Nia, LaToya, Jess, Jenny, Jenna, Madison, Sylvia. AYTO I do not remember Season 1 and have not watched season 2 so Idk who would be good. 

Uh, what makes you so sure?

Even if they dont ask other people from that show again, I am 99.9% sure that at least 1-2 that did their debut on Exes 2 will be back just like camila was back after cutthroat Adam strikes me as one of those guys that production love casting and will be back.

That's unfortunate.

Was Camila only brought back because of what she did on SBC? Or was it she was the only one who expressed interest?

Free Agents 2:

 

Nia

Nany

Theresa

Averey

Sarah

Cara Maria

Marie

Lacey

Devyn

Jenn

Paula

Kellyanne

Jonna

Camila

 

Bananas

Cohutta

Alton

Darrell

Abram

Zach

Leroy

Scott

Chet

Dustin

Dunbar

Kenny

Evan

Derrick

the challenge: allies

Location: Punta de Mita, Mexico; final challenge in Austria 

Brian & Cory 

Sylvia & Violetta

Leroy & Mike 

Rachel & Veronica

Frank & Zach 

Camila & Nany 

Bananas & Mark 

LaToya & Marie

Briah & Bruno

Jessica & Nia 

Johnny & Jordan 

Aneesa & Emily 

Alton & Dustin 

Ashley & Jenny 

Danny & Wes

Cara Maria & Laurel 

 

 

 

Since there has been interest from the old schoolers I wouldn't mind seeing three team challenge so it would be like Old School Vets VS New School Vets VS Rookies. Old School Vets could be people started challenges prior to Fresh Meat (this could change based off of how many old school they got) then new school Vets is if you have been in at least 3 challenge and Rookies would be less then 3 challenges. I think the dynamic would be good because there would be so much variety even in strategy especially between.  10 per team.   

People that I would be fine with being on the show:

Old School:

CT

Derrick 

Mark

Brad

Abram

Coral

Veronica

Annessa

Trishelle (Since she quit I doubt she would be on it or asked) 

Kina

Ruthie

Other maybes: Theo, Landon, Darrell, Ace, Adam, MJ, Tonya, Tina, Katie, Rachel, Ibis, Robin

 

New School Vets:

Wes 

Bananas

Kenny (Not Likely)

Zach

Cohutta

Evelyn

Sarah

Cara

Laurel

Cooke

Maybes: Danny, Nehemiah, Dunbar, Chet, Brandon, Evan (Not likely), Preston, Dustin, Leroy, Melinda, Johanna, Paula, Jenn, Kelly Ann (Doubtful), Emily (Doubtful), 

 

Rookies: (3 or less challenges) 

Mike Mike

Johnny

Jordan

Cory

Adam (AYTO since we know they will be on there from now on)

Averey

Hailey

Jamie 

Nicole

Simone (AYTO)

Maybes: Brain, Jay, Thomas, Bruno, Tony, Jason, Nia, LaToya, Jess, Jenny, Jenna, Madison, Sylvia. AYTO I do not remember Season 1 and have not watched season 2 so Idk who would be good. 

Uh, what makes you so sure?

Even if they dont ask other people from that show again, I am 99.9% sure that at least 1-2 that did their debut on Exes 2 will be back just like camila was back after cutthroat Adam strikes me as one of those guys that production love casting and will be back.

That's unfortunate.

Was Camila only brought back because of what she did on SBC? Or was it she was the only one who expressed interest?

Everyone that was on the spring break challenge, at that time was told that any of them could have been contacted for any future BMP related show. But as far as actually getting a call Camila was the only one over her pepper meltdown.

Since there has been interest from the old schoolers I wouldn't mind seeing three team challenge so it would be like Old School Vets VS New School Vets VS Rookies. Old School Vets could be people started challenges prior to Fresh Meat (this could change based off of how many old school they got) then new school Vets is if you have been in at least 3 challenge and Rookies would be less then 3 challenges. I think the dynamic would be good because there would be so much variety even in strategy especially between.  10 per team.   

People that I would be fine with being on the show:

Old School:

CT

Derrick 

Mark

Brad

Abram

Coral

Veronica

Annessa

Trishelle (Since she quit I doubt she would be on it or asked) 

Kina

Ruthie

Other maybes: Theo, Landon, Darrell, Ace, Adam, MJ, Tonya, Tina, Katie, Rachel, Ibis, Robin

 

New School Vets:

Wes 

Bananas

Kenny (Not Likely)

Zach

Cohutta

Evelyn

Sarah

Cara

Laurel

Cooke

Maybes: Danny, Nehemiah, Dunbar, Chet, Brandon, Evan (Not likely), Preston, Dustin, Leroy, Melinda, Johanna, Paula, Jenn, Kelly Ann (Doubtful), Emily (Doubtful), 

 

Rookies: (3 or less challenges) 

Mike Mike

Johnny

Jordan

Cory

Adam (AYTO since we know they will be on there from now on)

Averey

Hailey

Jamie 

Nicole

Simone (AYTO)

Maybes: Brain, Jay, Thomas, Bruno, Tony, Jason, Nia, LaToya, Jess, Jenny, Jenna, Madison, Sylvia. AYTO I do not remember Season 1 and have not watched season 2 so Idk who would be good. 

Uh, what makes you so sure?

Even if they dont ask other people from that show again, I am 99.9% sure that at least 1-2 that did their debut on Exes 2 will be back just like camila was back after cutthroat Adam strikes me as one of those guys that production love casting and will be back.

That's unfortunate.

Was Camila only brought back because of what she did on SBC? Or was it she was the only one who expressed interest?

Everyone that was on the spring break challenge, at that time was told that any of them could have been contacted for any future BMP related show. But as far as actually getting a call Camila was the only one over her pepper meltdown.

Weak.

The Duel 3

Kimberly

Aneesa

Tori

Sarah

Cara Maria

Theresa

Nany

Kellyanne

Marie

Trisha

Jenna

Jonna

Svetlana

 

Bananas

Kenny

Derrick

Evan

Brad

Alton

Darrell

CT

Zach

Leroy

Jay

Cory

Brian

Episode 1:

Winners: Derrick and Aneesa

Exempt from Duel because of the position they were in on the challenge: Nany and Darrell

Not picked: Cory and Jonna 

Opponents: Alton and Theresa

Eliminated: Jonna and Cory

 

Episode 2: 

Winners: Evan and Sarah

Not Picked: Brian and Svetlana

Opponents: Alton and Theresa

Eliminated: Brian and Svetlana

 

Episode 3:

Winners: Alton and Theresa

Not picked: Darrell and Nany

Opponents: Bananas and Kimberly

Eliminated: Darrell and Kimberly

 

Episode 4: 

Winners: Nany and Alton

Not Picked: Leroy and Trisha

Opponents: Brad and Tori

Eliminated: Brad and Tori

 

Episode 5: 

Winners: CT and Kellyanne

Not Picked: Aneesa and Bananas

Opponents: Jay and Jenna

Eliminated: Jay and Jenna

 

Episode 6:

Winners: Alton and Nany

Not Picked: Leroy and Trisha

Opponents: Bananas and Aneesa

Eliminated: Bananas and Trisha

 

Episode 7:

Winners: CT and Sarah

Not Picked: Derrick and Cara Maria

Opponents: Leroy and Marie

Eliminated: Derrick and Cara Maria

 

Episode 8:

Winners: Sarah and Alton

Not picked: Marie and Leroy

Opponents: Nany and Kenny

Eliminated: Kenny and Nany

 

Episode 9: 

Winners: Sarah and Evan

Not Picked: Leroy and Marie

Opponents: Theresa and Alton

Eliminated: Marie and Leroy

 

Episode 10:

Not Picked: Kellyanne and Zach

Opponents: Evan and Theresa

Eliminated: Kellyanne and Evan

 

3rd: Ct and Aneesa

2nd: Zach and Theresa

1st: Alton and Sarah

Pages