The X Factor USA

[QUOTE=producer88;328987]SOO HAPPY my top 2 are still Carly & Tate! I said it all season, they are always leading because they resemble American Idol contestant. They don't need the production, or be manufactured. With both of them it's about THE VOICE!! I love both of them cause of it. Emblem 3 made it this far cause of their looks, Fifth Harmony deserves to be there more. Hopefully Simon gets the clue on making the show about TALENT, and the voice and not about production. Raw natural talent>>>>Over produced acts X Factor needs to be more like American Idol, so their ratings can increase, and there could be actual talent on the show.[/QUOTE] Then why not just have two seasons of American idol? Fact is that neither Carley nor Tate would have been able to go on idol. Idol hasn't produced a star in the longest time (biddies Phillip)

[QUOTE=RMD1;329026]Then why not just have two seasons of American idol? Fact is that neither Carley nor Tate would have been able to go on idol. Idol hasn't produced a star in the longest time (biddies Phillip)[/QUOTE] Ummm Phillip, Scotty, Lauren Alaina, Adam Lambert, and soon Jessica Sanchez will debut her music early next year. I don't know if you follow music award shows, music news, and charts (sales & position), but of the last few seasons they found success. X Factor has NO ONE so far (but they are only one season in), but even Idol season 1 produced KELLY CLARKSON!

I love pop acts now, don't get me wrong I'm not a music snub. Heck Britney is in my Top 3 all time favorite artist, and I know vocally she isn't great (she's a great performer), but when it comes to SINGING or TALENT competition, I want to hear amazing voices.

[QUOTE=RMD1;329026]Then why not just have two seasons of American idol? Fact is that neither Carley nor Tate would have been able to go on idol. Idol hasn't produced a star in the longest time (biddies Phillip)[/QUOTE] Carly, even though she's young, would've been able as well as Tate, so I don't understand what you're talking about.

[QUOTE=ILoveRW;329369]Anyone watching X Factor UK will appreciate this. [url=http://www.youtube.com/watch?&v=m4kMEPCRpTE]A Weekend At The X FACTOR - YouTube[/url] Chris is such a mess, its so funny.[/QUOTE] Jahmene deserved that win

[QUOTE=Nostalgic;329054]Carly, even though she's young, would've been able as well as Tate, so I don't understand what you're talking about.[/QUOTE] I don't understand what you're talking about. Neither fit the age requirement for idol.

[QUOTE=Nostalgic;329370]Jahmene deserved that win[/QUOTE] James was the best decision for that hot mess of of a Final 3 , Jade Eliis,Union J and MK1 should have made it farther. Adam Burridge,Amy Mottram and Robbie Hance should have made Finals. Nicole should have been replaced by Cherly Cole.

[QUOTE=RMD1;329379]I don't understand what you're talking about. Neither fit the age requirement for idol.[/QUOTE] There is no "age requirement" dude (mostly a preference) considering after a senior lost his wife he auditioned for AI the season Simon/Kara/Paula left. Keep up.

[QUOTE=Npresh24;329381]James was the best decision for that hot mess of of a Final 3 , Jade Eliis,Union J and MK1 should have made it farther. Adam Burridge,Amy Mottram and Robbie Hance should have made Finals. Nicole should have been replaced by Cherly Cole.[/QUOTE] This is a joke right? Jahmene has awesome vocals its just that, like many people overseas are saying, he should've song more masculine singles and not just female-oriented songs. I like Chris but the only hot mess was him and James. Cheryl Cole? Yeah right. Even in her own country she gets the shaft, lol.

[QUOTE=Nostalgic;329404]There is no "age requirement" dude (mostly a preference) considering after a senior lost his wife he auditioned for AI the season Simon/Kara/Paula left. Keep up.[/QUOTE] There is an "age requirement" dude. Did that man get through? No! Because he was over the age of 28. You must be between the ages of 15 to 28 to be on American Idol.

[QUOTE=RMD1;329415]There is an "age requirement" dude. Did that man get through? No! Because he was over the age of 28. You must be between the ages of 15 to 28 to be on American Idol.[/QUOTE] Yeah in the first three season of idol, you had to be between 16 and 24, the 4th season raised it to 28 and the 10th season lowered the age limit to 15.

[QUOTE=RMD1;329415]There is an "age requirement" dude. Did that man get through? No! Because he was over the age of 28. You must be between the ages of 15 to 28 to be on American Idol.[/QUOTE] The"age requirement" is a show preference not saying that you wouldn't still get an audition by not being in that category but still not as important as you are saying. Tell me, when have you seen someone get turned around for not being in that particular age group? I have been watching every season since the inception and have not heard one judge tell them otherwise when it comes to disqualification.

That was boring. If Fifth Harmony gets in the final 3 in some way, I will flip my ****. But I'd be happy, because this show needs something to be shaken up. I don't it want to end in such a boring, predictable way.

I feel bad for 5th Harmony. Simon neglected them to **** the less talented and annoying Emblem 3 so sad. Pray top 3 is Carly, Tate, and 5th Harmony

Fifth Harmony is awesome, but their second song choice is not cool. They are playing it safe. But if Emblem 3, Carly Rose or Tate win this ****, then I'm calling bull**** because nobody wants to see them win X-Factor.

I hope a miracle happens and 5th Harmony makes the top 3. Imagine if they do and end up being the winning act! I would die.

[QUOTE=Nostalgic;329461]The"age requirement" is a show preference not saying that you wouldn't still get an audition by not being in that category but still not as important as you are saying. Tell me, when have you seen someone get turned around for not being in that particular age group? I have been watching every season since the inception and have not heard one judge tell them otherwise when it comes to disqualification.[/QUOTE] The original argument stated that Carly and Tate wouldn't be able to be on Idol, which is the truth. I don't care if they can audition or not because they wouldn't make the show. End of story. Stop dancing around the facts because you were proven wrong. Anyway, this thread is about the Xfactor USA so lets keep it that way.

It was kind of a big deal when they raised and lowered the age limit on idol. People that are too old or too young that are seen auditioning are always meant to be joke contestants. I like 5th Harmony but am fully expecting a Tate win, which I am fine with. I am sure he will do well. I usually like Carly, but tonight I did not enjoy what she did to either of those songs. Especially Imagine....eek

I can see Tate taking it as well. At first I enjoyed that they showed the rankings, but they should have only done it once or twice. It took away a lot of the "unpredictability" of the show. Sure I would still have assumed Carly or Tate taking the win, but It would make for a better finale.

[QUOTE=RMD1;329784]The original argument stated that Carly and Tate wouldn't be able to be on Idol, which is the truth. I don't care if they can audition or not because they wouldn't make the show. End of story. Stop dancing around the facts because you were proven wrong. Anyway, this thread is about the Xfactor USA so lets keep it that way.[/QUOTE] Nobody is dancing around the fact but you and no they are not "joke contestants" whatever the hell that means. I just find it weird that the top 3 can't even sing. Fifth Harmony is obviously going home sadly.

What's with the 5th Harmony fandom? They are horrid. 2 of the 5 can sing/have unique voices, the rest are average at best. Emblem3 is an alternative rock band and Simon turned them into a pop group. Carly is 13 years old and doesn't deserve 5 million. Tate for the win, despite him being generic, at least generic is quality in this competition.

5th Harmony is through? Yea, baby. Haters to the left please.

Wow. Now I am back to be interested in this show. Honestly, beating down the girls wasn't smart of the judges to do. It only makes people support them more (i.e CeCe) And Britney's face? PRICELESS.

Damn right legend for once I agree with you and wth is Bruno Mars? Lol@this Lauryn Hill wannabe

[QUOTE=Legend;329916]Wow. Now I am back to be interested in this show. Honestly, beating down the girls wasn't smart of the judges to do. It only makes people support them more (i.e CeCe) And Britney's face? PRICELESS.[/QUOTE] OMG I died at Britney's face. I seriously rewound it 3 times.

^Lol Praise Jesus because that **** that is Emblem 3 is finally gone.