The Challenge: All Stars 4- Cast Discussion

4863 posts / 0 new
Last post

Someone said Tara has more all star status than Nicole Z which is simply not true. Nicole Z has been a more prominent force on this show than that lady and a lot other old schoolers. 

Nicole Z has never done anything but be hard to look at and difficult to listen talk. Tara is at least cool and cute.

The new school ppl bring more subscription to this than Oldschoolers unfortunately lol

The new school ppl bring more subscription to this than Oldschoolers unfortunately lol

Casuals aren't subscribing for Silvia, Kailah, Nicole Z, Jimmy. Old school fans are more likely to subscribe for OGs than those few fans are of the names mentioned above. I've said from the begininng out John, Wes, and CT on to appeal to the casuals but still true to the theme.

I would LOVE to know how many people watch this because tbh I'm still surprised it got a 4th season. If  <600k are watching the main show what percent of them are watching this? I imagine very few people that don't watch the main show watch this (no matter what y'all oldschool fans think, this isn't "nostalgic" enough for that)

once this got green lit it was "All Stars" TheKonquerer wasn't wrong about that.

At no point had there ever been a show titled or surrounding "OGs" that's Marks silly idea he let a producer bounce off of and hand him scraps. 

 

Someone said Tara has more all star status than Nicole Z which is simply not true. Nicole Z has been a more prominent force on this show than that lady and a lot other old schoolers. 

Nicole Z has never done anything but be hard to look at and difficult to listen talk. Tara is at least cool and cute.

Tara was actually a huge character on her one and only challenge appearence. She had the 3rd most confessionals and mentions, had multiple storylines, and a relationship with the Miz. I can't remember anything about Nicole other than Devin calling her a toddler

way to hung up on a name and a hashtag how long later? give up 

once this got green lit it was "All Stars" TheKonquerer wasn't wrong about that.

At no point had there ever been a show titled or surrounding "OGs" that's Marks silly idea he let a producer bounce off of and hand him scraps. 

No show is gonna be called We Want OGs or anything stupid like that, well they did call a show Spies, Lies, and Allies so nevermind. Anyway All-Star was a marketable name but it was never "All-Stars" lol. Even the new people they cast aren't "All-Stars".

Imagine if Zanatta isn't on this after all these posts ****... y'all know she gets "rumored" every season nowadays right? She very well could be on but we have nothing that tells us she is

way to hung up on a name and a hashtag how long later? give up 

Nah. Imma keep on and so will Chavo and Potato.

 

once this got green lit it was "All Stars" TheKonquerer wasn't wrong about that.

At no point had there ever been a show titled or surrounding "OGs" that's Marks silly idea he let a producer bounce off of and hand him scraps. 

No show is gonna be called We Want OGs or anything stupid like that, well they did call a show Spies, Lies, and Allies so nevermind. Anyway All-Star was a marketable name but it was never "All-Stars" lol. Even the new people they cast aren't "All-Stars".

it's not either, you were right about that it has no identity it's just 1 of 8 Challenge shows. So why invent these rules 3 seasons into it like it's supposed to honor something for y'all lol.

just yelling at air 

it's not either, you were right about that it has no identity it's just 1 of 8 Challenge shows. So why invent these rules 3 seasons into it like it's supposed to honor something for y'all lol

No one is inventing anything. It's a message board where the point is to share your opinion. And I'm giving my opinion on what I think would make this successful.

You are so correct OS, honestly don't know how i didn't see it. 

GAMER JUST SAID ON TWITTER THE CAST THREAD IS FRIDAY!! 2 MORE DAYS! WE UP

You are so correct OS, honestly don't know how i didn't see it. 

Finally someone gives me some acknowledgment.

The new school ppl bring more subscription to this than Oldschoolers unfortunately lol

how do you know?  Have subscription numbers for Paramount been released comparing season 1 to 3?  Because I haven't heard a peep about subs due to this All Stars show. 

Kvm hate for Tony is weird. Everytime Tony is brought up Kvm speaks on him. Obsession vibes. 

It's not weird--he's an awful person and annoying as sin.  I'd take 10 Devins before listening to "Tony Time" again especially since he's an awful competitor.  

Tony going home broke on Vendettas was the only good part of that entire season.

Tony's. a champ and any champ is eligible to be an all star

KVM obession with Tony dates back 7+ years ****.

UNHINGED.

I'm not posting randomly about him.  New to me means Nicole Z & Tony which I can't stand.  Hopefully Nicole gets "minorly" injured and quits again.

Um Nicole brings amazing drama and relationship drama just go back and watch invasion and the reunion

My Cast Prediction (Not My Ideal Cast)

 

Brandon Nelson 

Derek Chavez

Jordan Wiseley

Leroy Garrett

Ryan Kehoe 

Brad Fiorenza

Danny Jamieson

Johnny Devanienzo

MJ Garrett

Syrus Yarbrough 

Yes Duffy

Tony Raines

Zach Nichola

Kefla Hare

 

Jasmine Reynaud

Rachel Robinson

Tina Barta

Veronica Portillo

Aneesa Ferriera 

Ayanna Mackins

Beth Stolarczyk

Jemmye Carroll

Jodi Weatherton

Laurel Stucky

Nia Moore

Nicole Zanatta

Ruthie Arcade

Sophia Paquis

I agree tho it should have been OGs and they just redo Gauntlets, Infernos, Duels.

3 seasons of it and then put a bow on it. Would have made it stand out. Ultimately i don't believe anybody is watching it anyway so at least committing to something would have helped 

Yeah, I said that too.  It should have been "THe Inferno All Stars", "The Gauntlet All Stars"  "The Duel All Stars" and they could have build the cast around team vs individual.   Then if that worked they could have continued.

Tony's. a champ and any champ is eligible to be an all star

NO, he's not a champ--even those that want to count All Stars and Challenge USA/World whatever don't count Champs vs. Stars/Whatever.

Um Nicole brings amazing drama and relationship drama just go back and watch invasion and the reunion

Who's she hooking up with on this?   I don't care about relationship stuff (I know I'm in the minority) as drama should be game related but who wants to watch her making out with anyone or fake crying about it?

Champs vs stars finals was way harder than old finals like Gauntlet 2 or inferno 3. So yes his championship counts periodt

Champs vs stars finals was way harder than old finals like Gauntlet 2 or inferno 3. So yes his championship counts periodt

lol no it wasn't.   Literally no one counts those--none should count but those definitely don't.  It wasn't even a challenge.

For the record, as long as this keeps casting to RW/RR/FM I won't complain.  I'll eventually cave and accept Bloodlines or AYTO but not yet--maybe if this gets to S7 or so.

Nicole is known for turning straight girls gay and being a homewrecker so the possibilities are endless

might be in the minority but i actually would be kind of excited to see Danny agsin. Low key always was in drama and from what i hear he's in decent shape. Or he could suck and it would be funny to see him go home early 

might be in the minority but i actually would be kind of excited to see Danny agsin. Low key always was in drama and from what i hear he's in decent shape. Or he could suck and it would be funny to see him go home early 

Don't know why but I'm convinced he'll be on this.   Will probably lead to his second divorce but I think he'll be on.

Pages