The Challenge: Battle of the Bloodlines Discussion Deux (SPOILERS)

8570 posts / 0 new
Last post
Stommped32 wrote:

So with Diem's passing, there is no longer any orginal FreshMeat cast members active.  6 years after FM2, and really only Cara Maria is active, unless Laurel, Theresa, Brandon ever decide to come back.  So considering this season is basically another FreshMeat, who do you guys think has the best chance of still being around 5 years from now, should the show still be on.  I think Jamie and Vince are the only ones who even have a chance.

I think Jamie, Vince, Shane, Brianna, and Nicole are the only ones that will ever be considered. Maybe Mitch and Larissa.

These are my choices too. But I feel like Brianna wouldn't return.

during reunion week,the challenge twitter had some of the cast answer twitter questions and brianna said that now that she knows what to expect she would return.

Like no shade but who really want to see Brianna return? If so for what theme?

Like no shade but who really want to see Brianna return? If so for what theme?

I really don't see the point in her returning honestly.

Like no shade but who really want to see Brianna return? If so for what theme?

I'm good.

I would be more than Ok with NONE of the Bloodline girls returning.  I mean just going through the list: Rianna - Can't even do monkey bars.. >.<, Brianna - Scared to eat bugs, not physically strong, Nicole - Terrible at pretty much everything competition wise, only good for drama, Larissa/Candice - Not nearly athletic enough to do anything meaninful, and to be fair we didn't see enough of Jill or Emily to make any kind of judgements, but for that reason alone BMP would probably never bring them back.  Compared to the FM 1 and 2 girls like Diem, Ev, Laurel, Theresa, CM these girls are pretty much a joke competition wise.

Brianna can stay home honestly. I don't really care about any of the bloodline girls except Jill lol like she is the only one that has a chance to make it to a final. Plus she was likable to me and if they were able to cast Evelyn again for doing nothing on Fresh Meat 1, Jill should deserve a second shot. 

Who is ready for the complaints season after season when nicole and Vince become regulars lol

Who is ready for the complaints season after season when nicole and Vince become regulars lol

I guess if they want Vince to flop that much... I could be down for that. Nicole is cool, so I won't complain *****.

Who is ready for the complaints season after season when nicole and Vince become regulars lol

Not gonna lie, I'll probably be one of them ***** 

I love Vince and Nicole lol! Brianna and Shane need to join in next!

My thing with Jill and people saying she will never be asked back... Look at Evelyn, she was the first gone and she came back lots 

I don't see the point of bringing Jill back. 

 

My thing with Jill and people saying she will never be asked back... Look at Evelyn, she was the first gone and she came back lots 

That's what I'm hoping for, lol. Jill really needs some redemption. I feel like she could get some airtime, too, without her cousin around or whatever. Any of them could really do a lot for the show, with the exception of Brianna and Emily. Neither of them to me have shown why they deserve to come back. Jill at least has something going on for her with the muscles.

Oh god...muscles should not equal an automatic ticket back to the show. 

The only bloodlines to make an impact whether it's airtime or drama it was Vince, Mitch, Jamie, Nicole, and Brianna. Those are the only people that should come back imo although I don't want to see Mitch again.

Oh god...muscles should not equal an automatic ticket back to the show. The only bloodlines to make an impact whether it's airtime or drama it was Vince, Mitch, Jamie, Nicole, and Brianna. Those are the only people that should come back imo although I don't want to see Mitch again.

You still don't get it. I didn't say it should be an automatic ticket back to the show. I said she has muscles going for her, which is a nice addition

Brianna didn't bring drama, nor did she bring competition. She brought confessionals. Yippe. She has a voice, which is probably better than Anthony/Rianna, but not a strong enough reason as to why she should return. That's all you got anyway. Stretch it, twist it, do whatever you want with it. I could care less.

At the end of the day.. Brianna didn't do much at all. You're just biased because she is Jenna's cousin. Vince really didn't do much, himself, to be brought back. He tried it with CT when he was there; and even CT said that it wasn't as deep. He also tried it with Cory, who would break his skull if he did it again.

bluehatchet2 wrote:

Oh god...muscles should not equal an automatic ticket back to the show. The only bloodlines to make an impact whether it's airtime or drama it was Vince, Mitch, Jamie, Nicole, and Brianna. Those are the only people that should come back imo although I don't want to see Mitch again.

You still don't get it. I didn't say it should be an automatic ticket back to the show. I said she has muscles going for her, which is a nice addition. Brianna didn't bring drama, nor did she bring competition. She brought confessionals. Yippe. She has a voice, which is probably better than Anthony/Rianna, but not a strong enough reason as to why she should return. That's all you got anyway. Stretch it, twist it, do whatever you want with it. I could care less.At the end of the day.. Brianna didn't do much at all. You're just biased because she is Jenna's cousin. Vince really didn't do much, himself, to be brought back. He tried it with CT when he was there; and even CT said that it wasn't as deep. He also tried it with Cory, who would break his skull if he did it again.

Yes she did... She fought with her cousin...fighting = drama... And she has definitely brought competition as of recently. She killed the endurance challenge, the cargo net, and the platform one. 

I'm not biased with Brianna, but to say she shouldn't come back but Jill should is stupid considering Brianna actually had a storyline in the first 2 episodes while Jill didn't.

hardbitten wrote:

bluehatchet2 wrote:Oh god...muscles should not equal an automatic ticket back to the show. The only bloodlines to make an impact whether it's airtime or drama it was Vince, Mitch, Jamie, Nicole, and Brianna. Those are the only people that should come back imo although I don't want to see Mitch again.

You still don't get it. I didn't say it should be an automatic ticket back to the show. I said she has muscles going for her, which is a nice addition. Brianna didn't bring drama, nor did she bring competition. She brought confessionals. Yippe. She has a voice, which is probably better than Anthony/Rianna, but not a strong enough reason as to why she should return. That's all you got anyway. Stretch it, twist it, do whatever you want with it. I could care less.At the end of the day.. Brianna didn't do much at all. You're just biased because she is Jenna's cousin. Vince really didn't do much, himself, to be brought back. He tried it with CT when he was there; and even CT said that it wasn't as deep. He also tried it with Cory, who would break his skull if he did it again.

Yes she did... She fought with her cousin...fighting = drama... And she has definitely brought competition as of recently. She killed the endurance challenge, the cargo net, and the platform one. I'm not biased with Brianna, but to say she shouldn't come back but Jill should is stupid considering Brianna actually had a storyline in the first 2 episodes while Jill didn't.

What was the base of that argument again? Because Bri thought she was better than Jenna? I don't even remember. Doubt majority of America/Canada will, either, at the end of the season and the beginning of the next one.

You're definitely biased with Brianna. If you did, you would know a storyline doesn't stop at two episodes. Jill doesn't need a storyline in her case. If she can bring competition and prove she has a voice, then by all means, she can return.

The only thing that would be stopping (in BMP's eyes at least smh) Jill from coming back would be the fact that she's now married. Otherwise she should definitely come back.

The only thing that would be stopping (in BMP's eyes at least smh) Jill from coming back would be the fact that she's now married. Otherwise she should definitely come back.

honestly i agree with this. i would love to see her back but she wouldn't bring any drama at all which is a no-no

bluehatchet2 wrote:

hardbitten wrote:

bluehatchet2 wrote:Oh god...muscles should not equal an automatic ticket back to the show. The only bloodlines to make an impact whether it's airtime or drama it was Vince, Mitch, Jamie, Nicole, and Brianna. Those are the only people that should come back imo although I don't want to see Mitch again.

You still don't get it. I didn't say it should be an automatic ticket back to the show. I said she has muscles going for her, which is a nice addition. Brianna didn't bring drama, nor did she bring competition. She brought confessionals. Yippe. She has a voice, which is probably better than Anthony/Rianna, but not a strong enough reason as to why she should return. That's all you got anyway. Stretch it, twist it, do whatever you want with it. I could care less.At the end of the day.. Brianna didn't do much at all. You're just biased because she is Jenna's cousin. Vince really didn't do much, himself, to be brought back. He tried it with CT when he was there; and even CT said that it wasn't as deep. He also tried it with Cory, who would break his skull if he did it again.

Yes she did... She fought with her cousin...fighting = drama... And she has definitely brought competition as of recently. She killed the endurance challenge, the cargo net, and the platform one. I'm not biased with Brianna, but to say she shouldn't come back but Jill should is stupid considering Brianna actually had a storyline in the first 2 episodes while Jill didn't.

What was the base of that argument again? Because Bri thought she was better than Jenna? I don't even remember. Doubt majority of America/Canada will, either, at the end of the season and the beginning of the next one.You're definitely biased with Brianna. If you did, you would know a storyline doesn't stop at two episodes. Jill doesn't need a storyline in her case. If she can bring competition and prove she has a voice, then by all means, she can return.

When did it stop? Her and Jenna's underdog story is evidently progressing.

Jill didn't do anything to deserve another shot. She was given the win on the first challenge and got last on the second so the competition aspect isn't even valid.

hardbitten wrote:

bluehatchet2 wrote:

hardbitten wrote:
bluehatchet2 wrote:Oh god...muscles should not equal an automatic ticket back to the show. The only bloodlines to make an impact whether it's airtime or drama it was Vince, Mitch, Jamie, Nicole, and Brianna. Those are the only people that should come back imo although I don't want to see Mitch again.

You still don't get it. I didn't say it should be an automatic ticket back to the show. I said she has muscles going for her, which is a nice addition. Brianna didn't bring drama, nor did she bring competition. She brought confessionals. Yippe. She has a voice, which is probably better than Anthony/Rianna, but not a strong enough reason as to why she should return. That's all you got anyway. Stretch it, twist it, do whatever you want with it. I could care less.At the end of the day.. Brianna didn't do much at all. You're just biased because she is Jenna's cousin. Vince really didn't do much, himself, to be brought back. He tried it with CT when he was there; and even CT said that it wasn't as deep. He also tried it with Cory, who would break his skull if he did it again.

Yes she did... She fought with her cousin...fighting = drama... And she has definitely brought competition as of recently. She killed the endurance challenge, the cargo net, and the platform one. I'm not biased with Brianna, but to say she shouldn't come back but Jill should is stupid considering Brianna actually had a storyline in the first 2 episodes while Jill didn't.

What was the base of that argument again? Because Bri thought she was better than Jenna? I don't even remember. Doubt majority of America/Canada will, either, at the end of the season and the beginning of the next one.You're definitely biased with Brianna. If you did, you would know a storyline doesn't stop at two episodes. Jill doesn't need a storyline in her case. If she can bring competition and prove she has a voice, then by all means, she can return.

When did it stop? Her and Jenna's underdog story is evidently progressing.Jill didn't do anything to deserve another shot. She was given the win on the first challenge and got last on the second so the competition aspect isn't even valid.

It stopped when it wasn't even mentioned again. No one besides you remembers it. 

It's very valid. Jill clearly got those muscles naturally. If anything, she knows how to use them, and probably will be a competitive threat if given a second chance for another Challenge. She didn't even get a chance to prove herself in The Pit, at all. Cohutta's flop *** decided her fate in the game.

I'm not going to continue this with you. An argument with you is twisting words in an effort to look like you got edge in an argument/discussion. Brianna did nothing with her 10 episodes. Jill still has things to prove with her two episodes. Bri's had more of a chance to prove herself but doesn't do anything all that well besides those monkey bars.

 

Are we seriously going to consider that bug mission as something to do with skill? I don't consider being able to withstand the sight of a snake, or chew up bugs, as apart of some type skill. Maybe someone can explain what kind of skill it takes to do that mission.

I mean... I withstand snakes on this site all the time.

Really lovin aneesa on this season. Sad to see her go. She actually worked hard this season. She used strategy

Graphik wrote:

The only thing that would be stopping (in BMP's eyes at least smh) Jill from coming back would be the fact that she's now married. Otherwise she should definitely come back.

honestly i agree with this. i would love to see her back but she wouldn't bring any drama at all which is a no-no

cohutta doesn't bring drama. 

wildcat777 wrote:

Graphik wrote:The only thing that would be stopping (in BMP's eyes at least smh) Jill from coming back would be the fact that she's now married. Otherwise she should definitely come back.

honestly i agree with this. i would love to see her back but she wouldn't bring any drama at all which is a no-no

cohutta doesn't bring drama. 

i think they liked him because of his relationship with nany and maybe they were hoping drama would occur because of that, idk.. I'm not saying every single person they cast needs to be a drama filled person or anything I'm just saying I'm sure they would want people that at least in some way can bring some sort of "drama" to the show. i do hope jill gets a second chance and returns though, she deserves it

Are we seriously going to consider that bug mission as something to do with skill? I don't consider being able to withstand the sight of a snake, or chew up bugs, as apart of some type skill. Maybe someone can explain what kind of skill it takes to do that mission.I mean... I withstand snakes on this site all the time.

*mic drop*

But yeah. Jill should come back. She could be potential competition and part of this show is competition so that's good enough.

 

Jill should definitely be asked back over Brianna. Only reason Brianna was even on this show this long was because she was always on the winning team and never up for elimination, and if she had gone in even once she most likely would've been sent home.

Jill could potentially make a strong girl competitor, which this show seriously lacks at the moment in comparison to the past.

BTW what happened to Cooke? She was practically carrying Cara Maria in Rivals 2 and disappeared since then?

Pages