Here would be a solid cast that meets the Season 4 formula that they loved, a good mix of new OGs, a few returning OGs, newer names with old school vibes, and an interesting mix of relationships.
How about all Real Worlders who have never done a challenge? We could get ppl like Bronne, Ryan Leslie, Greg from Hollywood
As much as I really wish for Ryan Leslie, he said on Mike Lewis podcast that he was friend of Jonna and only did the show to prove that if she could then he could too. Also, he barely thinks about the show nowadays.
Jisela blew out her ACL and Aneesa breaks something everytime she comes on. Fat people, especially over the age of 35, are not suited for this show.
I mean did you see what happened to Jisela? She competed all season long without injuries and performed well. Ntm.
I'm fine with Jisela coming back, she's a fun personality and she did compete well. I think as a general rule though that heavier people simply don't compete very well/aren't very entertaining to see compete.
Taking everything into account, including who'd realistically accept, the diversity quota, and the new schoolers MTV is inevitably gonna shove down our throats, this is a *realistic cast* I would be excited by (No one who has already done 3 All-Stars)
Dan Renzi (RW Miami) - Alt for AS3, Dropped from AS4, now is his time!!! Gay+
Jake Bronstein (RR The Islands) - This is my token Flora random OG pick. I think he would work out really well. He still looks good, funny as all hell, would love his confessionals. I think he would be game! Just a feeling
Chadwick Pelletier (RR Down Under) - If he was really that close to being on AS4, he checks a ton of boxes
Adam Larson (RR The Quest) - Pink said production liked him on AS4, he's cute and fit. Loud voice that will always rub people the wrong way
Steven Hill (RW Las Vegas) - Still very handsome, from a very well known season which is ++, has expressed interest in the past. Fact that he was sent home from his one challenge b/c of violence is a good hook+
Johnnie McBride (Fresh Meat) - Big personality, still looks in shape, if Aviv can come back, why not him? Diversity+
Cohutta Grindstaff (RW Sydney) - A think a name that's sorta liked by everybody, he needs another show after AS2
Ty Ruff (RW DC) - Diversity, Tempermental, the fans that were excited about the likes of Brandon and Jay should be happy with him.
Noor Jehangir (Fresh Meat 2) - Nice guy, great competitor, diversity+
Marlon Williams (RW Portland) - He's fit, he's not afraid of drama, he's a finalist, he's diverse in two categories, I'm surprised he hasn't been on multiple seasons TBH
Cory Wharton (RW Explosion) - Diversity quota, a name to get those awful casuals excited
Tony Rains (RW Skeletons)- Again, a name for the awful casuals. I can see him being a priority, especially considering his recent flops
Beth Stolarczyk (RW Los Angeles) - 3rd appearence, always good for drama.
Genesis Moss (RW Boston) - Alt for last season, one of my all-time faves. Former bodybuilder. All my fingers crossed. LGBT+
Gladys Sanabria (RR Latin America) I have no idea why she hasn't been on yet. The only woman to come on the challenge knowignly pregnant. Pure gold. Diversity+
Holly Shand (RR Latin America) - Its her time
Veronica Portillo (RR Semester at Sea) - Obvi. A legit All-Star, this would be appearence #3. Diversity+
Shavonda Billingslea (RW Philly) - I feel like she has turned them down, otherwise I would imagine she would have been on already. But I don't think we've heard otherwise so lets give her a shot!
Shauvon Torres (RW Sydney) - She was almost on AS1 or AS2 if I recall correctly but she blabbed too much and was taken off of the cast. I just think it would be hilarious
Kelly Ann Judd (RW Sydney) - 3rd Appearence, has been delivering as of lately. Let's keep the ball rolling
Brianna Taylor (RW Hollywood) - She's game and I think she has a lot more in her than what we saw in the ruins, she deserves a chance. Diversity+
Cara Maria Sorbello (Fresh Meat 2) - I'm not a fan boy, but 's she's good. She's a lightning rod. She's a safe bet and will bring in viewers.
Avery Tressler (RW Portland) - For the youth, plus she's growing on me, plus I'd like to see her and Adam navigate the game as a couple. I hope Chadwick gets petttty
Ashley Mitchell (RW Explosion) - I can see them doing this, particularly if CM & Laurel are too exhausted after season 40. A sure bet, a lightning rod. Again I'm not a fan boy but I understand why they cast her.
My fantasy cast would be: Irulan, Devyn, Jenn, Marie, Cara Z, Evelyn, Cooke, Susie, Sarah R, Coral, Carley, Jisela, Shane L, Landon, Preston, Frank S, Ty, CJ, Marlon, Cohutta, Noor, Bruno, Dustin, and Alton
Jisela blew out her ACL and Aneesa breaks something everytime she comes on. Fat people, especially over the age of 35, are not suited for this show.
I mean did you see what happened to Jisela? She competed all season long without injuries and performed well. Ntm.
I'm fine with Jisela coming back, she's a fun personality and she did compete well. I think as a general rule though that heavier people simply don't compete very well/aren't very entertaining to see compete.
Jisela blew out her ACL and Aneesa breaks something everytime she comes on. Fat people, especially over the age of 35, are not suited for this show.
Here would be a solid cast that meets the Season 4 formula that they loved, a good mix of new OGs, a few returning OGs, newer names with old school vibes, and an interesting mix of relationships.
I mean did you see what happened to Jisela? She competed all season long without injuries and performed well. Ntm.
As much as I really wish for Ryan Leslie, he said on Mike Lewis podcast that he was friend of Jonna and only did the show to prove that if she could then he could too. Also, he barely thinks about the show nowadays.
I also remember Jiesla doing well in everything besides the final.
Plus she clocked Derrick K
I'm fine with Jisela coming back, she's a fun personality and she did compete well. I think as a general rule though that heavier people simply don't compete very well/aren't very entertaining to see compete.
IMG_7889.jpeg
Taking everything into account, including who'd realistically accept, the diversity quota, and the new schoolers MTV is inevitably gonna shove down our throats, this is a *realistic cast* I would be excited by (No one who has already done 3 All-Stars)
Who is this? I don't recognize her (and I've seen every season).
the ashli robson
Take this list and give us the best 32 All Stars. These are not based on who are my faves, but who would make the best cast for season 5.
Anyone but Ashli
Shavonda lost her husband in July and she has two young kids. No way she'll ever appear on this in the next 5+ years.
They should cast Gamer and PR
My fantasy cast would be: Irulan, Devyn, Jenn, Marie, Cara Z, Evelyn, Cooke, Susie, Sarah R, Coral, Carley, Jisela, Shane L, Landon, Preston, Frank S, Ty, CJ, Marlon, Cohutta, Noor, Bruno, Dustin, and Alton
Agree to disagree here.
Does Irulan have any social media?
BA12D52E-3764-4F95-9A1C-EA7C4AF7E4ED.jpeg
Why don't you just marry her already.
Unrealistic Cast:
Shane Landrum
Dustin Zito
Dan Renzi
Kelfa Hare
Los Jackson
Johnnie McBride
Marlon Williams
Darrell Taylor
Ty Ruff
Antoine de Bouverie
Adam Larson
Noor Jehangir
Alton Williams
Blair Herter
The Miz
Frank Sweeney
Coral Smith
Rachel Robinson
Tina Barta
Veronica Portillo
Irulan Wilson
Emily Bailey
Ellen Cho
Canda Sneed
Brittini Sherrod
Marie Roda
LaToya Jackson
Julie Stoffer
Melissa Howard
Beth Stolarczyk
Jenn Grijalva
Roni Martin
Just gonna do a wishlist of people we haven't seen back yet and I hope they get on. After Flora came back for Allstars 4, I'm more optimistic:
Men:
chadwick
Jacquese
cj
landon- give him the check he wants
pete
eric nies
Dan- Miami
Nathan- Seattle, he keeps getting asked and then sidelined
Derek- viewers revenge
marlon
danny j. - we need our flop legend. Hahah
Davis
women:
Coral- pay her the correct amount
Devyn
Irulan
Brianna Taylor
Heather B.
Holly B.
Emily
Julie
Angela Trimbur
Lacey
Shavonda
Kimberly
If you are going to start a dumb thread atleast make a cute collage outside of paint hahahaha
LOL
Mallory from RW Paris
IMG_7904.jpeg
Mallory was a bore on Paris and Inferno.....BUT.....she was not fake so Id love to see her. Id rather have a CT/Leah Rivals pair. That would be epic
Why hasn't anyone named Keena yet?
We have goofy but she's not interested.
IMG_7905.jpeg
Pages